Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

Posts

A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

#1

A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

David Weaver

..on larger planes that aren't practical to lap, or on mild steel planes that are very resistant to abrasive lapping.

I apologize if some folks don't like an imgur link, it's just easily (practical) for me to sequence pictures in it and provide comments about what i'm doing. outside of what's described in this (I don't get ad revenue or any incentive for using this site, by the way - not directing traffic to it - I don't know if it's possible for people to get anything from the site, but like youtube, I don't care - I don't do ads).

At any rate, in the middle of my plane building blitz, I built two infills after building 3 before, and got to buying older infills. I like the norris a13 pattern, as well as spiers. I've since sold several of the infills that I bought as patterns, but I paid the moon for this plane because they're not common and when it showed up, it was very worn and very out of flat. Fine for heavy panel work, but not good at getting to a try planed surface and doing finish work or making a very flat surface for subsequent smoothing quickly.

It was so far out of flat that I sat it aside. At lunch, I decided to fix it today. I've used this method many times, and just didn't address this sooner out of laziness.

Some planes are too out of flat to lap into flatness with the appropriate low effort that I prefer, and when I was making my last two infills, I realized that in order to move to the last tiny bit of impractical perfection that you need to go to to match an LN plane, I needed to figure out how to match them or better them in flatness. I suspect most planes are flatter than their 1 1/2 thousandth spec by a wide margin. I have a 1.2 thousandth feeler and that is my goal - within reason - as shown at the end of this progression- the very heel was very high and never did get filed in this progression to any significant amount and once it was within about 2 thousandths, I stopped. The rest of the sole passes the 1.2 thousandth test straight off of the file.

https://imgur.com/gallery/NxDqmR0

The beauty of this process is it requires no machine tools. Just marking fluid, a lap (that must be very flat as it's the reference), a good straight edge (I have two starretts that I bought new), a feeler, a file ($8 black max imported simonds is my preference - they're flexible and cut faster than anything else short of a vixen) and some 80 grit paper for the lap.

Lapping something like this would be huge labor, the result would be less accurate, at a higher cost (it would spoil a lot of the psa paper), and for a mild steel infill, generally not possible - especially at the level of accuracy.

Filing took half an hour, and I didn't sweat. This is a feel thing, much like dimensioning wood. Learning to feel what's fast cutting for the file and what's not, and avoiding problems by not doing anything that isn't necessary.

The edge at the end is literally 80 grit sandpaper to initially prepare the file and a turkish oilstone (the ones written about in holtzapffel but almost never found). prep time after the 80 grit sandpaper was pretty much the same as a single sharpening session, so future refinement can occur in use.....

.....or I can legitimately sell this plane to someone who will use it without knowing they'll never enjoy using it.

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

#2

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

Steve Voigt

Gorilla! :D My favorite part was reading that through the shaving.

Looks good to me. How far do you want to pursue flatness? You could get much flatter--within way less than .001--if you used a surface plate and layout fluid and scraped. I seem to recall you did do some scraping at one point--any reason you are using the file instead?

By the way I bought a couple of those same files off Ebay. They cut nice, not super flat but reasonable for cheap files. The handle fell off one, which is fine because I always have use for an unhandled file for certain things.

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

#3

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

David Weaver

I think I got enamored with faster methods of removing metal (that are cheap) and just completely forgot about it. I think I asked george about it and he suggested a biax if I was going to do much scraping....and maybe it takes more accurate initial work for me to need to consider it.

Those files are kind of like a junk store item. They flex, and cut really well for the price, but they wouldn't be confused for a real swiss file (quality-wise) and the handle is something you'd expect on a dollar store screwdriver (they come off, I put them back on with contact cement). They're a consumable for me, like sandpaper - never feel guilty wearing one out and throwing it away, but I'll be sad if they stop being sold on ebay for $8 shipped.

Never thought about the negative side of their cheapness (not being suitable for a scraper).

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

#4

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

Wiley Horne

David,

That’s a really good tutorial. Back and forth between lap and file is something that is new to me, but I like it—ordered a new Simonds file as a matter of fact.

The best thing I liked about it was the approach to go slightly hollow, then lap to final surface. To get to flat, first go concave. I use this approach on edge joining—work from the center of the board outward, until a fine set just scrapes at the center, then go full length a couple times for final passes. The progression of shavings give you a topo map of the edge, without any other diagnostic. Very similar to what you did.

Wiley

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

#5

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

David Weaver

That's a good assessment - a good strategy (for wood and metal) seems to be removing the parts that are problematic so that everything else can be worked.

In this case, the method would horrify a machinist, but it's the product of my laziness (constantly trying to find a way to get to very good, but not perfect, with less effort).

It's probably been done a million times, or maybe it's not common because anyone with a professional setup would find it dopey. But it works well to make a very out of flat plane much more usable and fits a key thing due to a hole in my brain - if I figure it out, I'll be able to do it again in 10 years. If I read about it or learn from someone else, the knowledge will be soon gone.

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

#6

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

AlanWS

When you think of the process as identifying a spot that's too high and lowering it, then repeating, you are more likely to succeed than doing anything blind.

The problem some encounter is that a convex surface can rock, taking the blue off areas that are high compared to different planes. If you started by placing the plane on the reference surface and adding feeler gauge shims so it did not rock, that would give a stable orientation. Bluing the bottom and rubbing with shims in place would remove blue to mark areas whose removal would be more certain to lead to a plane.

This isn't really different from what you were doing, it's just emphasizing something else you were doing without explicitly stating it: being very careful to not rock the plane while lapping.

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

#7

Re: A novel method for flattening plane bottoms..

Robert Hazelwood

Thanks for description of the process.

Eventually I will be doing this to my #8. It is straight enough down the length but across the width it is convex by several thousandths, such that the corners of the blade protrude more than the center. The center 2 inches are flat enough, so it's still useful for edge jointing but difficult to correct an out of square edge. Not currently useful for face jointing.

I had in mind to use a vixen file screwed down to a slightly curved block of wood with comfortable handles, and then essentially use the scraping process- spotting on a surface plate, removing marked high spots, just with the vixen file instead of a scraper.

I see that vixen files are kind of pricey. I may have up to 0.010" to remove, so if they are faster it is probably worth it.

I may finish it off with a few passes with a hand scraper, because I like the look honestly and because it might reduce friction a bit, or at least hold wax/oil better.