Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

5 1/2

Posts

5 1/2

#1

5 1/2

david charlesworth

David W,

I thought I would attempt to answer your question!

When I trained in about 1971, I was bought a 41/2, 51/2 and 7. Stanley UK were at a particularly low state. The 4 1/2 has never been used due to a huge trench round the throat caused by a belt sander. It took me about 20 years to true up the no 7. I would do a little work with each intake of students.

The 5 1/2 worked reasonably well and I got used to using it for everything, which of course it does very well. A couple of years later I realized it was being difficult, so encouraged by an article in Fine Woodworking, I flattened the sole. The improvement was huge, so I never felt the need of a smoothing plane at all.

This experience started my lifelong interest in plane tuning.

My workshop has always had machinery, so no need for preparing sawn boards.

I'm afraid Warren's criticisms of my methods are of little interest. He is a professional, I teach beginners who can't sharpen and have no idea how to plane up a component.

Best wishes

David

Re: 5 1/2

#2

Re: 5 1/2

David Weaver

Thanks for filling in the dots, david. You probably feel a cold breeze from my comments sometimes (as on the cap iron discussions on the UK board or plane design - plane design and function is something I've spent a lot of purposeful time on as a hobby), but that's not really the whole story.

I quite appreciate that because of your videos, I was once one of those beginners and the saga of sharpening that I saw discussed on many forum posts is something I never had to struggle through.

First edge was an excellent edge. I didn't know if it was or was not at the time, but I came to realize over time that it was.

I don't scrape much now and sharpen a scraper freehand, but I also learned from your 5 topic video what to expect and eventually moved to the same standard freehand before going down the planemaking rabbit hole (and some would consider dimensioning wood by hand a rabbit - to do it well and with reasonable speed requires the same experimentation as the planemaking).

I agree on plane flatness. I won't say much more aside from the fact that I've made dozens of planes and cleaned up probably more than a hundred and figured out how to do it very quickly to within what LN uses for a spec - I'm not sure I could teach it to beginners, and sometimes forget that others teach beginners. The worst working planes I've had are those that looked clean and had a sneaky twist or low toe and heel (concave sole). It's not possible to do fine work with the latter.

Even though our arguments go to the point that i think you referred to me as "the most arrogant person you've ever come across" :) I still have great fondness for having gotten off to a good start.

Re: 5 1/2

#3

by the way....

David Weaver

Another point of disagreement between the two of us has been the level of improvement of a replacement iron. I figured that out a couple of years ago.

By buying a stanley plane from the 1970s or late 60s with the rounded top irons.

It's the only stanley plane that I'd say the iron was pretty close to intolerable on. It is maybe bordering on impossible to use productively without a cap iron and a less refined (fast) sharpening method that you wouldn't be able to teach beginners (lest you loose them on the world looking for washita oilstones).

Re: 5 1/2

#4

Re: 5 1/2

david charlesworth

David,

Thanks for that.

I had forgotten the comment, it must have been a bad day!

David

Re: 5 1/2

#5

Re: 5 1/2

David Weaver

Given my insistence on the plane thing, I didn't find it really out of line at all. I still send people to your plane sharpening video when they say they're working in a vacuum and want to know how to sharpen something - follow the steps, have success. Even if one moves away to another method later, they do so with a good sense of what properly sharp (all the way to the edge) is.

Re: 5 1/2

#6

Re: 5 1/2

Wiley Horne

That’s the key insight—no one starts out knowing what sharp is. Let alone how to get there.

Wiley