Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

Posts

Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#1

Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

David Weaver

This is an area i know nothing about.

In the past, when I've installed mouldings on solid wood casings (which is only three times), I've glued the front of the moulding and pinned the back.

This is not going to be a high end cabinet. It's going to be stained, but I don't want seasonal gaps in the miters at the edges of the mouldings.

Does anyone have any tips (too late for quartersawn wood, and the lack of quartersawn wood for the sides would negate that).

https://i.imgur.com/jI8jxXW.jpg

These mouldings should be situated so that nobody will ever get a solid grip on anything but the front of the cabinet (kids).

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#2

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

David Weaver

The depth of the bottom cabinet (which will get a base, but moulding on the top) and the top cabinet (which will also get a moulding on the top) are 18" and 12", respectively.

If it's necessary to go gizmo, I could glue the fronts of these and attach a small dovetail (like 2 inches long) to the back that fits in a groove in the case. It will be hidden.

it would also be a nuisance to fit neatly on a project that I will admit not being that motivated to do.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#3

Seasonal allowances

Jim Matthews

I would fix the front to the carcasse, glue and pin the miters.

If there's room at the back, the "return" moldings could be left a little long.

Rather than deal with alignment of what would be very fine (and fragile) sliding dovetails -

would heavier brads be sufficient? If the head of the brad is broad, it will offer clenching power.

Predrilled "slots" for the pin can be made by chucking a same size brad into a power drill, and leaning the drill side to side. This would offer some ease to the squeeze.

If the shaft of the brad is resilient, it should "give" with lateral forces.

I would apply the "floating" side pieces with heavier double sided tape (full length), just below the revealed surface to allow for finish. The pin should slightly pivot the molding toward the side of the carcasse. (Tape slightly below center, pin slightly above center.)

Dunno how long double sided tape will last.

****

I'm sure someone who has already done this will offer a verified solution.

This is how I would approach it, given time constraints, available materials and budget.

FYI - There is no construct built by Man that a teenager can't randomize.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#4

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

Sgian Dubh

Glue (and pin [brad] if you want) the front moulding. Glue and pin the front 4" - 5" of the side mouldings, use small gauge flexible pins (brads), and pin but no glue towards the back. Drive pins through the mitre from both the side moulding and the front moulding. Put a bit of filler in nail head holes. Slainte.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#5

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

TomD

Those are good suggestions. There was a traditional way of mounting the return molding that used a dovetail. A cheapness version of that is t-screws, in molding slots, of screw in slots in the cabinet, if you have access from the inside, or from over the top.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#6

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

Sgian Dubh

Tom, similar is to use slot screws. Put a countersunk screw(s) into the outside of the carcase side. Get it/them to marry up with a reasonably generously long keyhole slot(s) cut on the back face of the moulding, drop the moulding over the screw head(s) through the circular part of the slot(s), and drive the moulding horizontally to engage the screw head(s) with the slot(s). Glue and pin the mitres at the front as I suggested earlier.

However, to me slot screwing does seem a bit over the top for this, as does the arrangement with a similarly locking sliding dovetail arrangement, but all perfectly legitimate and do-able, if relatively time consuming compared to simply gluing and pinning in place. Slainte.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#7

Thanks Tom and Richard

David Weaver

Though this is just utility furniture, I'd prefer to keep the gizmocity at a low level. The dovetail idea into the case is doable, but as richard says, time consuming. It's something that I'd like to do in the future, though - just not on this piece.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#8

Re: Seasonal allowances

David Weaver

yes on the brads - I've done this with brads/pins and I've done it separately with screws. Screws are too strong and the result was predictable.

The second time I did it, I pinned it, but i"m sure that I didn't trust the glue (on the sides) and glued too far back.

I will plane this case if necessary after the moulding is attached, so I have some wiggle on the fronts (and have only glued them). I'm sure the movement issues are the case sides across the width of a board with side mouldings attached by length. I could've built it with plywood. hah!

It's taken me about 15 years not to be such a (word for kitty) about some things like this and sting myself thinking i'm making it stronger - instead, I think I just prevented the side miters from floating and they moved more with the center of the case and less with the front of it.

These mouldings are pretty significant and I could make a strong dovetail, but I realize I would much rather get back to building planes and guitars.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#9

Re: Seasonal allowances

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here in eastern Pennsylvania, we have traditionally just nailed the mouldings on. Here is one from a quarter millennium ago:


Usually work like this has Half blind dovetails with the pins on the sides, dovetails visible from the top.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#10

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

Wiley Horne

David,

I think you would do this anyway, but...you can miter the ends ever so slightly acute, for example 44+ rather than 45, so that the ends are touching first. Then apply the side moldings last, so that the crucial joins at the front will come together tightly under compression when you clamp.

Wiley

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#11

Re: Seasonal allowances

David Weaver

Thanks, warren - what's your assessment for the dovetail orientation on the top? I have an extreme aversion to end grain, but it's not based on advice from someone else or reading of anything - it's just being eccentric.

Do you think they're oriented that way so that they hold the sides fixed? rather than the top?

My two carcases are HB top as shown (oriented opposite, though), the shelves are holding the case sides together and the whole thing may fail at some point, but hopefully i'll be dead by then.

I like the style of the case that you've shown - is that your own make?

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#12

That's clever

Jim Matthews

The joint would be "sprung" slightly.

Kudos

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#13

Re: Seasonal allowances

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The chest I showed is Chester County around 1770.

Years ago my instincts would have been to make through dovetails and cover with moulding. I now prefer this traditional method [half blinds]. For one thing, you don't have to flush off the sides. So you don't have to worry about smooth planing after gluing or having the flushing off mess up the flatness. It is smoothed before gluing, which is much easier. If the top is not visible,you don't have to flush at all.

On some cases you have to use half blind dovetails at the bottom anyway because they would otherwise be exposed. It is probably more precise to have the same treatment top and bottom.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#14

Re: Seasonal allowances

David Weaver

Thanks, Warren - fortunately, my bottom case's through dovetails will be sitting in a base, or they would've been half blinds oriented differently on the bottom than they are on the top.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#15

Re: Seasonal allowances

Steve Voigt

That's a great tip on the HB vs through DTs, Warren. Thanks for that.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#16

Agree!!  Most helpful.


Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#17

Thanks, Wiley!

David Weaver

I usually fit miters together by hook or crook or any means necessary, but I LOVE little biases like these. My engineering buddy would call them errors "what do you think we're doing...building boats?".

My planes are pretty much nothing but biases like these. Some for function, some to protect cosmetics.

Thanks!

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#18

Errors are great!

Wiley Horne

That’s how we learn. In fact, that’s how you want to fit the side pieces once the front and back are glued on. Make the side molding just a few thousandths long off the saw, then shoot the miter and test fit, one shaving at a time, til it fits. The test fitting will tell you the angle adjustment for the next shaving, which is gotten by shimming the shooting board. On the final shaving, it’s perfect!

Wiley

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#19

Those errors of bias...

David Weaver

..i always intentionally put in planes. I just wish I could figure out more biases!

Even if you're trying to do fine work, especially in tools, little tiny errors result in great users (the bias is always bigger than the error) and then the tool still has room to move and be great.

If I have to pick a spot where the mortise will be the slightest open, on the top just where it meets the case is ideal. It's easy to hide. When the fronts open a little bit, it's not so easy to hide. On something like this, I'm not to proud to jam "furniture" crayon in it and call it good a season or two down the road, but I'd rather avoid it.

As far as the biases go, as time went on, each of those little biases went away and the planes didn't fare as well -the user has to put the biases in them (if the iron is flat you can hollow the bed a little bit in the middle, etc).

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#20

Initial fit...

David Weaver

I haven't hung the side mouldings on this cabinet yet as it's the top and I need to do a few things to it before getting there. This is the hand fit.

I don't know what the rules are to making furniture as I don't much care for doing it, but usually when I put a moulding like this on a cabinet, I roll the front edge a little as I'm fitting it to close it (the top won't be seen - it's about 7 feet up).

https://i.imgur.com/Vywsmxi.jpg

I used a standard power miter saw to cut these and since I rarely use such a thing, of course the initial result wasn't that great. Last year, I bought a nice hardly used miter jack from england because it was literally cheaper than I could make one, and I was excited to have the occasion to use it, but rather than do that, I used a #4 to shave some of the back side of this miter off to get it closer to fit and then pared a little bit out of the center of the miters with a sharp chisel, so the total amount of screwing around to get to this point from a bad initial cut was about 5 minutes.

This whole thing will be stained very dark at the end of this and a sensible person would just wax fill the miter with beaumontage after the fact, but this has been a fun little learning experience.

I cut the other side of this top further from square top to bottom, so fitting the miter of the adjoining side piece will be more interesting, but not difficult.

Bottom line, even though this looks tight to the back, it's only at the very top and bottom for a small sliver. The rest has "wiley's bias" in it. I'm sure that when I go to glue it on, I'll close it up the rest of the way even though I know it's a waste of time to do that on this particular piece. No reason to go into why except to say that the mrs wanted no frame and no divider on the cabinet, so the doors will literally sit on top of the front like slabs and be mounted with modern adjustable european hinges. Not very artful.

Re: Help me!! (mouldings on solid cabinets)

#21

That "Wiley sliver" has a proper unit of measureme

Jim Matthews

Known as a "scoche".

One scoche = take another

Two scoches = best fit, stop now

Three scoches = recut molding

This technique was first alluded to by the Grimm brothers.

(Where beds are an obvious metaphor for window casings.