Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

planing failure

Posts

planing failure

#1

planing failure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was planing a walnut top for one of the dressers. On one side there was a "hump" in the grain so each direction involved modestly upsloping grain. But the upsloping was not particularly steep......as best I could measure about 10 degrees. Actually it was hard to see the grain orientation on the board edge. Tearout! Simply rough surface one way, that I could feel and hear when planing. The other direction(other side of the humped grain) there was tearout that ran almost parallel to the surface. When I turned around and focused on this area the tearout was easier to observe and it ran along the surface more than diving into the depth. Maybe this observation is simply reflecting the grain is only sloping 10 degrees (approx)

By humped grain I mean the grain rises and falls when looking at the edge of the board.

I have done a lot of planing building these two dressers, but little planing over the span of building stuff. I have become complacent that I will ever get tearout, so this result came as an unpleasant surprise.

Is some grain just inherently weak and more prone to tearout? I have too little experience over a wide range of lumber to know.

Re: planing failure

#2

Re: planing failure

David Weaver

Strange orientation or really weak early wood can sometimes both prevent a nice planed job.

Re: planing failure

#3

Re: planing failure

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Quarter sawn boards are more vulnerable to tear out because the wood rives most easily along a radial plane.

Re: planing failure

#4

Re: planing failure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My drawer sides were quartered. I could hear the difference when planing them when they were near perfect quartered. The planed surface was some rougher when the grain was near perfect quartered. But I did not have any torn grain beyond the roughening, which of course was torn grain but on a tiny scale.

The misbehaving walnut, or my misbehaving of planing it, is as flat as it can be. The tears were 1/4" long +/- and not much below the surface, angling into the board of course. They did not dive into the depths because the grain that was separating was not steep in these areas. I would describe the torn grain flaking as opposed to deep divots like I once got with the cap iron set back. A few concentrated passes of the pane in the reverse direction in the torn area removed them entirely.

My question is whether even an experienced planer might encounter some wood that just won't plane smoothly or must this problem be a result of not optimum plane set up?

Re: planing failure

#5

Every board unique

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

It sounds like you have a case of surfacing, or reversing, grain. For example, here is a soft maple board with reversing grain at 5 places along its length. I use it to check my planes before use:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49670996658/in/dateposted-public/

If you look up close, you see surfacing grain that’s fairly steep, like this:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49670996353/in/dateposted-public/

or fairly shallow like this:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49671535961/in/dateposted-public/

This latter place will produce a fairly wide tearout on the edge with the chipbreaker set back. And it’s because of the shallow grain angle that you point out.

These grain reversals are planeable with adequately-set Stanleys or LN’s, or Konrad’splanes. As I say, it’s a test board. But does that extrapolate to your walnut board? Surely not. David, in another nearby thread, makes the point that every situation is different. And so you deal with them as they come. On your walnut, if your best set-up, sharpest iron, and thinnest shaving won’t work, then I suggest approach from each side (with the grain), exiting the cut short of the grain reversal, and scrape or sand what’s left (if it won’t plane, it may not scrape either).

Wiley

Re: planing failure

#6

Re: planing failure

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, you can plane this board. Some combination of sharp iron, close cap iron and light cut will surely work. I don't recommend a stainless steel blade.

I always plane a surface entirely in one direction with continuous strokes for best visual effect.

One of the advantages of preparing stock by hand is that by the time you are ready to smooth for the finish you are well acquainted with the grain pattern.

Re: planing failure

#7

Two animals...

David Weaver

Stainless is something that has to be divided into two animals:

* pre-PM, and some high vanadium PM (the latter does fine in sharpness vs. carbon steel, but may be harder to get sharp or have more resistance)

* XHP/V11 - high chromium powder steel

The latter will plane anything that carbon steel does and do it with results/surface quality just as good (or brighter)

There is a chance that some folks running around using V11 or XHP or anything similar will say that an edge has more nicks in it, but I can guarantee from testing that's only because the material abrades away half as fast.

If bill has an issue here, if he's sharpening V11 on 1 micron diamonds, it won't be a sharpness issue.

Re: planing failure

#8

Clarifying the question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...to those that have experience on many samples of lumber, in my case walnut, but it could be other domestic hardwoods.

Can one run into grain that just won't plane without grain lifting from what seems to me to be a modest upsloping grain orientation?



The answer is of great importance to me for I am at a fork in this road. Do I write this experience off as an unusual occurrence and carry on? Or, does there remain a flaw in my preparation or technique to be corrected?

The blade is near freshly sharp, the cap iron set close enough for every other grain reversal encountered, the shaving thickness is thin but not as thin as practically possible.

Re: planing failure

#9

Practical Application

David Weaver

If you can plane a board with a modestly thick shaving (using the cap iron set on a smoother), and have nothing other than a small amount of surface smoothness issue (in ribboning or quartered wood), you can often back the shaving off to something thin, and make several passes and remove any issues.

It's uncommon for wood to not tolerate that, especially if you'll be sanding with 220 grit or something after the planing. In my experience, there isn't much as far as defects in most wood that can't be quickly removed with 220 grit to extreme uniformity.

Much of this absolute lack of uniformity (the kind of spots that you'll notice tiny bits of dust accumulating on first pass with sandpaper) is what gives wood characteristic depth when planed that sanded wood lacks.

At any rate, back off of the shaving to half or a third and see if things improve. In my experience, the rare wood that doesn't respond to such a thing, even when you change the direction of planing, is something that just won't plane well.

The benefit of the cap iron is that even on the woods that require a final thin set of shavings, you get there much faster because such woods don't tolerate planing anything thick without a cap iron.

Re: planing failure

#10

Re: Practical Application

Jim Matthews

I lack sufficient skills to anticipate this, and often find it in local Walnut and Yellow pine.

If you're like me, these always appear front and center of the "show" face.

My first approach to taming this is to "wet" the undulation with tap water and try a lighter shaving. My second approach is to use a small Bahco carbide scraper under bright lighting.

Those have three sharp corners and can leave gouges *DAMHIKT*.

If those fail, I finish the rest of the board and apply blackened epoxy to the offending blemish and polish it before applying finish. I use Waterlox or Watco to good effect over epoxy.

If each finish layer is buffed progressively finer with a non woven pad, such as Mirlon.

Bob van Dyke demonstrated this to my class, and it has saved two of my projects.

https://www.finewoodworking.com/2007/10/26/use-epoxy-to-fill-voids-in-wood

Re: planing failure

#12

PIC 3

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Indeed that is the kind of tear-out I would get when I first tried planing (and why I gave up planing at the time.) I would call them divots as they dive into the depths of the wood.

And that is the kind of tear-out I thought was a thing of the past when I got, what I supposed, proficient with the cap iron setting. I planed all the drawer's fronts and sides with reckless abandon with what wound up a blade duller than any of you would consider tolerating. The drawer sides had grain going all ways, and the fronts were lightly figured with broad curl. No matter.

Someone from club visited and he wanted to see what I was building and how I sharpened. So I sharpened and he planed some and I planed some and all went well. Then it came time to plane this top of the dresser.

The blade was at this point not as sharp as possible nor was the shaving as thin as I could get it with undue fussing. So, yes there are refinements that could be made. But, for the rest of this project, and others, they were unnecessary.

In this side of this board the grain change is modest, approx. 10 degrees up and then down, way less than your test piece. This slope means when the grain separated it ran almost parallel to the surface and quite some distance.

The wood is flat sawed with growth rings nearly parallel to the surface and the wood several inches away from the center of the tree.

I finish sand anyway so reverse planing this area, scraping and final sanding wound up where I needed. But it shook my confidence. If this issue rears again I may be in a part of a project where I can study it more.

Re: planing failure

#13

Re: Two animals...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Years ago someone on this forum introduced a sharpness test that involved newsprint. Bill Tindall admitted that his plane irons could not pass this test, but that it did not matter since the initial sharpness would not last beyond four feet of planing. He said "Let's hear from the newsprint cutters."

I tried it. It is a pain in the neck planing a bit, then taking the plane apart to see if it passes et cetera. After several rounds of this and forty feet of planing, it still passed the test, but I could notice some deterioration. It was probably still sharper than Bill had without any planing. It is really wrong to assume that anyone who goes through the motions is getting equal results sharpening.

Re: planing failure

#14

Re: Clarifying the question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I remember once you were planing quarter sawn ash for a desk, Bill, and getting tear out. I wrote that there was something wrong with the plane. Two hours later, you had solved the problem, and you said I was no help at all.

Something is wrong with your set up. I don't know what it is.

Re: planing failure

#15

well that ended what could have been....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....a helpful discussion.

The Forum could be a place to share knowledge but that gets squashed when questions and discussion open one up to disparaging attacks. Little wonder participation here has dwindled.

Re: planing failure

#16

Re: Two animals...

David Weaver

Bill has received an iron from me, sharpened. I sharpened it well, and beyond the level of sharpness possible with natural stones. I rarely actually do that for regular work, but using the abrasives that bill has on hand, this isn't hard to do. As much as I like natural stones, he shouldn't have trouble bettering the edge from them.

In this case, we're talking about two different problems.

First - the stainless iron (presumably XHP). It's equal to or better than any carbon steel iron that I have ever bought or made with one exception - it grinds more slowly. It is sharper at every footage planed vs. carbon steel and the surface brightness (planing resistance, pull into the wood) is at least as good at double the footage of the best carbon steel irons. It's not similar to any other alloyed iron I've tried. It's not the problem here.

Second, the sharpness - bill can advise if he resharpens.

I've run into wood that didn't plane well twice that I can recall, but it wasn't the same issue as bill's having. In both cases, it was quartered wood with very hard early wood and very dry powdery latewood (one was quartered cocobolo, which is notorious for having very hard early wood and should be notorious for very soft latewood that dries to a fragile dusty and poor wearing surface).

Re: planing failure

#17

clarify...slow abrading....

David Weaver

.I didn't finish that thought, but it should be obvious (often things aren't in brief reading -at least when I'm the reader and not the poster).

slower honing and grinding leaves nicks in irons for a simple reason - people are often routine oriented and not results oriented.

When I was testing irons, it became a bit of a nuisance to remove every bit of wear from the hardest sharpening irons (V11 wasn't one of those) to the point that not only would the surface look and feel even, but that I couldn't see any damage or wear under the microscope.

Re: planing failure

#18

Re: Two animals...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I routinely sharpen my iron before smooth planing the top of a dresser. This is a show surface, much more important than the bottom of a drawer or even the side of the case. Bill did not do this, and apparently did not even think to sharpen when he ran into trouble. I would not want to rule out sharpness as a possible solution.

Re: planing failure

#19

Re: Two animals...

David Weaver

I haven't ruled it out, just stating that he will have a feel for what's sharp and what's not.

I would be surprised if he hasn't sharpened edges as good as the one I've sent him, but your message about show surfaces is important for anyone planing a show surface. It's more often defects that spoil the surface than sharpness (for anyone who sharpens reasonably often). Some of this depends on how bright the finish and how good your eyes are (and what you consider enough evidence that a plane passed over the surface to be a problem).

But this is, again, a case where the XHP iron is different from something like A2. A2 tends not to last through clear planing footage as long as O1, even though it can outwear it in a test. XHP tends to take defects on the same things that carbon steel does (at about the same frequency, seemingly).

Re: planing failure

#20

Re: planing failure

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, I may have a solution. It is along the lines of David's comments.

I have a photo of planing a panel in 2013 with a high angle single iron plane (Veritas Bevel Up Smoother). The wood is Curly Marri, which is pretty hard, but extremely interlocked with constant reversals. I commented at the time, "The grain switches back-and-forth".


All was going well ...


Then, without warning, this might occur ...


At that time, when the high angles did not work, out came the scraper ...


Fast forward to the project-just-completed.

The wood is Fiddleback (Curly) Jarrah, which is just as interlocked as that Marri. The drawer faces need to be planed, and they are as much at-risk for tearing out.

You can get a glimpse of it here ..


This time the plane is a bevel down Veritas Custom Smoother with a 42 degree frog. The chipbreaker is set close, and the shaving is deliberately fine. The shavings still straighten (rather than curl), although they lack the strength to stand up.


These shallow shavings do not allow the chip to lift, and the closed up chipbreaker forces it down as well. One can be confident, in wood like this, that the result will be a tear-free, polished surface.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: planing failure

#21

wet the wood

GolfSteve in Calgary

For tough spots to plane, try wetting the wood with water or low odour paint thinner. Softens the fibres so they cut more easily.

For some trouble spots I've soaked the area with cyanoacrylate before planing. Holds the fibres together.

For most trouble spots I just switch to sandpaper.

Re: planing failure

#22

Re: wet the wood

William Duffield

I don't think CA would be my first choice, because it has a good chance of interfering with your choice of finishes. Either hide glue or shellac might work better because they are much more easily removed, hide glue has a reputation for non-interference with finishes, and shellac is often the first coat in many finishing regimens.

Re: planing failure

#23

Tack coat of shellac?  Brilliant!

Jim Matthews

That's so simple, and easily reversible.

I hate the smell of CA glues.

Clever

Re: planing failure

#24

Re: planing failure

TomD

Yes some wood do tear out more than others. The worst I have ever seen is Osage.

In general crafts that are practiced with the intention to finish off the tool, like hand chair making; fly rods; Japanese furniture; use perfect wood. Chairs, today, often being made of veneer grade wood.

Crafts that use figured or secondary wood, do not finish off the plane, though the plane may well be used for the majority of finishing. The main techniques are to:

-Scrub the surface while reversing the plane as required. There is no attempt to take long flowing shavings the length of the board. You simply direct the plane where it will not damage the surface. The surface will end up patchy, but efficiently reduced. You then do the final finishing with a scraper, and sandpaper. This is extremely efficient.

-Use a scraper plane throughout. The plane allows one to do this without burning or wearing oneself out. I have a few of these planes, but for some reason I do not resort to them much. This is a technique that should work well on your walnut. Some very hard woods are going to require the scraper to be sharpened a lot, though the blades on these devices are very easy to set. If one goes though the most precious sharpening technique one will waste a lot of time. A quick zap on the belt, and working out with a burnisher will keep the maintenance to a minimum.

- Toothing plane. For me a specialty trick, largely for Osage, or very expensive guitar woods. Might be worth it for burl if I used much. Also good for some bonding tasks.

- Cross grain or diagonal attack with radiused blades. Works very well at roughing stage, and on down to fine work. Less effective than some of the other approaches when dealing with really extreme reversal.

I made my first planes over 40 years ago, and am an ardent devotee of planing, but there is a reason why so many furniture makers use belt sanders.