Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Bill - Zinsser can...

Posts

Bill - Zinsser can...

#1

Bill - Zinsser can...

David Weaver

I can't find the post you made last week about the cost of shellac in a can from zinsser, but unless you can buy shellac from india, it's likely to be the cheapest.

3 pound cut in a can, so 3/11*32 = 8.3 roughly - ounces of shellac in a can.

My favorite seller of flakes is what appears to be a younger guy running an online store called "wellermart".

You can get buttonlac, carious flake shellac or crushed powder. Blonde dewaxed in bulk is still $20 a pound, so figure $10-$11 for flakes plus solvent. I'm not sure there's a reason to get waxed (like the blonde can that zinsser uses), but it may be a little cheaper for them to use that.

To get a mostly ethyl denatured alcohol, it would be difficult to do much better than the price in the zinsser can.

There's no magic secret, though - i'm sure they just get their shellac directly from india.

When I was buying buttonlac from wellermart ($23 a pound for light pure buttonlac - which is really a darker shellac, or $28 for kusmi buttonlac), I noticed an amazon india listing that google brought me that suggested the price for buttonlac in india (on amazon) is around $4 US for 500 grams.

Of all of the things in the world where it makes no sense to be brand loyal, shellac is at the top of my list.

You're also right about MEK - and possibly something else. It's been a while since I read the MSDS, but I recall a big deal being made a few years ago about how unhealthy methyl alcohol fumes are (my what's healthy and what's not threshold doesn't really register for things like that). As I recall, zinsser at the time used a mostly ethyl alcohol base.

There were and still a lot of people who suggested that the zinsser shellac is not highbrow enough, but I have no clue what they're talking about.

If you think $38 for a bandsaw blade is bad, try buying firewater at the liquor store and shellac flakes from a woodworking supplier.

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#2

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

Wiley Horne

David,

Certainly agree with your findings. But could you elaborate on your conversion math? I couldn’t follow it.

Wiley

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#3

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

David Weaver

I believe that zinsser is a 3 pound cut.

Bill estimated in his post (IIRC) about 30 percent solids. a 3 pound cut (alcohol is less than a pound, but I think it's by volume - not an expert though)

should be 3 pounds shellac to one gallon of alcohol. (shellac's specific gravity is actually 1.15-1.2 or so, so there's a little error here).

At any rate, the simplistic view with the error included would be that there are 11 parts total, 3 shellac and 8 solvent.

So, the amount of shellac in the can is 3/11 * 32 (fl. oz in a quart can) = ...oops, rounding error....or copying error.

8.72 (I remembered that as 8.27 calculating it earlier) ounces of shellac in a can. as far as solids go.

23 or 24 ounces of solvent leaves somewhere around 5 1/3rd quarts of shellac to each gallon of solvent used.

the SLX type of DNA here is about $18 per gallon. The kind I prefer that's ethyl alcohol is a few bucks more per quart because it's not available in gallons.

Either way, I end up slightly above the cost of the zinsser can, their advantage being that it's not hard to dissolve shellac and pure ethanol is probably about $3 a gallon or less (made all over the place now that we put it in cars). If they can manage to buy shellac in india for $4 a pound, then their ability to make, distribute and then allow lowes and HD to mark up the product a hefty amount makes much sense.

We small timers are left grasping at the "shellac cutoffs".

All that said, I used about $7 or so of shellac and alcohol on each of the two telecasters that I showed pictures of, and there's just about nothing else that makes a suitable (to eye and touch) finish on a guitar that costs that little. Nitro lacquer is cheaper, as are acrylics, but I never liked the way they felt.

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#4

Bravo!!!  Thanks much.   


Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#5

repost Zinsser analysis:

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Went to buy shellac at Lowes and found Zinsser amber no longer on the shelf. There was something called "clear". I needed shellac so I bought it. For others in this pickle:

It seems to be waxed. It is light amber in color in the dry film. It is 25% solids by my measurement.

2 pound shellac plus 6 pounds of alcohol is going to come up to about a gallon of "shellac". Make you own from Woodcraft would be twice Zinsser price.

You would not believe how cheap ethyl alcohol is by the tank car.

I long suspected Zinsser shellac had a high boiling solvent as part of the formulation. I asked an "expert" in finishing and was assured it was pure ethanol. Well, its MSDS says the solvent is ethanol, plus isopropanol and methyl isobutyl ketone, a high boiling solvent. The later two ingredients are there to retard evaporation rate, perhaps for brushing, but the price to pay is longer time to get hard.

This stuff is cheaper than make-you-own unless someone knows a cheaper source of shellac than I do.

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#6

Re: repost Zinsser analysis:

David Weaver

Thanks, I don't remember reading the tank car, but my parents being farm owners (until about 3 days ago), I'm familiar with how much acreage is spent growing corn to convert into supposed fuel. The net effect is kind of a waste, but I guess it's kept rents up for them.

That said, the price at the pump of e85 suggests that ethanol is cheap.

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#7

the cheapest is from gas

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the shale wells have lots of ethane. It is easily cracked to make ethylene, from there to ethanol cheap. Before Shale Gas ethane was getting expensive but now there is an abundance. Current bulk price about 15 cents a pound.

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#8

clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Ethanol is about 15 cents a pound. A bottle of water costs more.

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#9

Bullseye

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I calculated the relative costs of "Bullseye Shellac" and flakes about 35 years ago. I usually use the flakes even though it is more expensive. It is faster drying, maybe a little harder, and has longer shelf life.

Re: Bill - Zinsser can...

#10

good points

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

home made is, "It is faster drying, maybe a little harder, and has longer shelf life. "

The addition of the high boiling ketone and isopropanol definitely makes the Zinsser slower to get hard, for better or worse. It dries to the touch about the same but takes hours to fully harden in my cool shop. It certainly sprays better than pure ethanol formulation, but it is annoying when you want it to harden quick.

I looked up the patent for the Zinsser process to stabilize their product. The acid is extracted. This acid catalyzes ester formation between shellac components and the alcohol solvent. Remove it and the result stays useable longer, but not forever. What else the extraction does, for better or worse, I don't know.