Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A plea for more "user tools"

Posts

A plea for more "user tools"

#1

A plea for more "user tools"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I didn't know what to title this post. At Midwest tool Collectors meets there are beautiful collector tools. If some cosmetic defect makes a tool undesirable to collect they become "user tools" and cheap. They can be bought inexpensively to try and if they don't work out the investment is small. I have bought, sold and kept many. They were a cheap way to assess utility for my line of work.

By analogy there are tools people make and post here, and elsewhere, that took a great deal of care and skill make. They may do a job that I and others might consider. But the investment to replicate them is too great compared to the perceived benefit.

Buried below is a picture of the ugliest plane ever made. However, it did not require a great deal of skill and care to make it and it did the job. It is an example of a tool that one might quickly make to see if was useful for their needs.

The value in posting these kinds of tools is underappreciated. I would like to see more detail of how the plane was made. It seems the basic design could be used for other specialty planes.

Another example is the Moxom vise. I was unsure of its benefit, making the cost of a kit, or the time to make one like others posted , too steep an investment. When someone posted a crude one I could make in an hour inertia was overcome. Ditto the shooting board.

Keep up posting the beautiful tools you all make. But, be brave and post the ugly functional ones that one could quickly make to try.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#2

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

William Duffield

You must have buried that plane very deeply, because I can't see it. :D

Often, you can add a touch of class to a user-made tool without a lot of additional expense or effort, especially when you know you will use it a lot and just want to make it a little more comfortable to hold or a little quicker to set up. In anticipation of these "opportunities", I save fancy junk in a "potential tool parts" box or drawer. It is fairly simple to add a brass wear strip where you know it will prevent wear on a critically dimensioned wooden part. A knurled brass knob might be easily substituted for a galvanized wing nut. A scrap of exotic hardwood might be substituted for a block of OSB, MDF or Baltic Birch plywood. ou might find a small piece of curly crotch walnut that was right next to a huge knot from a branch, and thus tossed into the parts bin because a furniture component could not be cut out of it. A few strokes from a scraper, file or sand paper are often useful to relieve sharp arises to make the tool more comfortable also improve its appearance, and might not take more than a minute or two to implement. A quick wipe with your favorite quick finish (e.g., Watco or walnut oil or beeswax, etc.) can add some luxuriousness to a tool, but maybe not to a hunk of MDF. :D

Sure, if you only need it once, or if you are not sure it is going to work, just throw it together out of drywall screws and 2x4's, but show us and tell us how well it works, and also any functional shortcomings you have discovered while building and using it.

Rule of Thumb: For everything that you point out that you did wrong, also explain two things that you did right.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#3

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

David Weaver

I think he meant my Lego style dovetail plane. Though I felt offended by his judgment....

...because it's wrong.

I have made far uglier planes. :)

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#4

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

David Weaver

I like to make nice looking tools, but I have a lot of built tools that are single purpose and quickly made. They are made for things that most would do with a router or table saw, so folks using routers and tables wouldn't abide, as the dude says.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#5

but no one cares?

ken ca

Well, I posted a cheap and easy conversion of a round plane to a side round and no one gave a hoot. Zero responses (other than to my side question of posting multiple pictures) so I think that tells you that people are only interested in buying Bridge city or whatever tools and not making themselves users.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#6

wrong conclusion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I recognized that David described something I could use if I had it. And what he made could be possible for me to make. It perked my interest

I saw your post. I get interested in what I can use. I have no idea what the planes you are making are used for. Maybe what you did has relevance to how I make stuff. But you are going to have to teach me this relevance for me to become excited about what you did.

You didn't respond to my line and berry post. I would not expect you to if it had no relevance to your work.

BTW, I own one Bridge City tool, an miter square I bought used as a steal.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#7

Or maybe

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

your post was clear enough that no one had anything to add.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#8

Re: A plea for more "user tools" *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I posted a picture of my quickly made butt hinge mortise plane some years back, and it turned into an article. Picture, and a link to the article, below.

It's been an occasionally used, but always appreciated tool, ever since the first time I used it.

The occasion of my making it was switching the swing on my Uncle Charlie's bathroom door, so that we could reach him if he fell (when he fell in his small bathroom, he would invariably block the door). Now that my Uncle Charlie is long gone, I can testify that the first use proved the tool's worth: I got the job done rapidly, nearly quickly enough to avoid Uncle Charlie complaining that it was unnecessary. At least he only grumped about it for a few minutes, instead of the longer time it would have otherwise been.


img

http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/handtools/articles_114.shtml

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#9

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, what I believe that you are asking for are useful and simple tools, which do not require much in the way of careful or complex construction.

It is worth noting a point made by William, “Often, you can add a touch of class to a user-made tool without a lot of additional expense or effort, especially when you know you will use it a lot and just want to make it a little more comfortable to hold or a little quicker to set up”. You and I have a quite different mind set about the tools we use. I get a lot if pleasure out of building tools as well ... building anything ... and will go the extra mile to make something interesting or special to use. What is “a lot of extra work” to one is not to another.

You will see quick-and-dirty tools and fixtures in my furniture builds. Look at the second last post on the Hall Table (#12) for a jig to drill with a forstner bit where it cannot use its leading point. There is also a template for laying out dovetails for multiple drawers. Then the most recent post (#13) on the Hall Table shows a bench hook with multiple uses, a bench stop for planing face grain, a fixture for holding drawers to plane the sides, and a shop made handle for a chisel.

I recall, in an earlier post, there was a dovetail plane made out of a Stanley #79, which simply required a tapered fence add-on. That would take 5 minutes to make.

I’ve made many tools, and they do not need the extra care I put in to work. (I am omitting complex tools, such as plough planes, infills, braces, woodies, travishers, etc).

I have made router planes. This is one I put up for auction (I cannot recall who purchased it - review?) ..


The best scraper ..


Birdcage awl ..


Kerfing chisel! :)


I made marking knives for detail work and skinny dovetails for years and gave so many away (they are now made by Chris Vesper - I have no financial involvement. There are plans for these - and all the tools above - on my website) ..


Let me know if you want more. I have barely scratched the surface :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#10

question and comment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think what I am seeing in your plane and David's is what I will call "Krenov plane construction" applied to a "specialty plane". This novel thinking opens up the possibility of making these kinds of planes by a means easy to master, as opposed to chopping them out like a traditional wooden molding plane. You each chose a different means of holding the blade in place, the key to these planes. In your case you used what seems to be a thumbscrew and a steel rod for the pivot. This approach looks easiest if it works. Did you find this arrangement held the blade securely in use?

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#11

Blade securing

John in NM

I have a shop made scrub plane that uses a similar method as Bill's, except I did minimal thinking about it - blade, chipbreaker, and lever cap were all repurposed from the previous scrub, a 5 1/4 handyman (Stanley's cheap line) that had the usual crack at the mouth and did not survive a drop on the concrete. The screw that it bears against is just a big wood screw from the hardware store.

I had just read Cecil Pearce's book and that was how he did them, though he used shop made caps with a thumbscrew rather than the Stanley (or whoever) lever. Wouldn't probably do as well for Bill's plane as his arrangement looks easier for the size of plane, but the geometry is easier to sort out. If one had to make the screw cap from scratch the Krenov style cross bar wins out for easy, no question.

I never liked Krenov planes much, but that is admittedly a traditionalist aesthetic prejudice on my part, nothing more. Functionally it doesn't matter whether the sides are glued on or the whole is chopped out of a billet. I agree that the method is very well suited to specialized user tools though - you could crank one out in a couple hours if you needed it to do a job that afternoon.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#12

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Because, "the method is very well suited to specialized user tools though - you could crank one out in a couple hours if you needed it to do a job that afternoon", I have interest in the concept for specialty planes.

Are you saying that in place of the round head screw threaded into the metal plane body you substituted a round head wood screw threaded into the wood? This seems an easier arrangement to the cross bar, when the blade width will accommodate a readily available lever cap.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#13

Yep, held it fine

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As I mentioned in the article, the cross bar was cut from a 16d nail. The trickiest part, as I recall, was cross-drilling the lever cap and getting the hole in the right place; can't now recall exactly how I did that, but the design allowed for some imprecise placement as long as I drilled it straight across the width, not slanted in either axis. I owned a drill press by then; I probably just clamped the lever cap in or against some reliable vertical (relative to the drill press table).

I made the knurled thumbscrew from lamp parts; but, if I hadn't figured out that technique, I'd have used a regular thumbscrew.

For my purposes, it was a much easier approach than a wedge: I could set the cutting iron depth exactly to the hinge leaf thickness and tighten up the lever cap, no fussing/fossicking about with wedging the iron, having it slip slightly due to the wedge pushing it out, tapping, etc. (remember: speed was of the essence on the first project I used this on).

I have insufficient knowledge to know whether this would be better, worse, or no different were I making, say, a smoothing plane for difficult woods. I will note, though, that the physical forces of this lever cap are basically the same as those involved in the lever cap on a Bailey plane.

By the way, we see that glued-up plane construction as an innovation by James Krenov; I don't think he originated it, although I do think the originator's name is lost to history.

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#14

Incidentally

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In the first couple of pictures of my plane, you can see, around the top where the iron beds, some little carve-outs in the rounding. I'd like to assert that those are decorative flourishes, but they are, in truth, what happens when a bearing-guided roundover router bit loses its reference surface. If I'd been in less of a hurry, I'd have wedged some wood of the thickness of the center pieces of the plane body into the opening before cutting out the shape on the bandsaw, so that I'd have a reference surface for the bearing all the way through.

But, no, I was NOT in less of a hurry (time with bride; kids; job; house/cars/etc. that called out for maintenance regularly; helping to address my uncle's needs; time for myself somewhere in there). The carve-outs make utterly no difference to use; the rounded corners overall do improve the plane's comfort when using.


img

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#15

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill and all,

Some years ago, I needed to edge plane a bunch of thin sticks, so I hacked out this thing which never had a name, but I’ll call it a v-stop:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49635934231/in/album-72157713412424322/

Goes in the end vise, and holds sticks in whichever V fits best:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49635933876/in/album-72157713412424322/

Different thickness needs a wider V:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49635409133/in/album-72157713412424322/

The stop can extend different heights sbove the bench. Here, it is pulled up to hold another ‘helper’. This helper is plowed out to capture a molding which needed planing on the flat side—note the v-stop stops both the helper and the molding:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49636209362/in/album-72157713412424322/

In general, stops are simple and fast planing aids. I suppose we all use them. Derek I believe fixed one permanently to his bench.

Wiley

Re: A plea for more "user tools"

#16

Re: question

John in NM

That was it exactly - about an inch or bigger #12 screw if I remember correctly. Works best with the old kind of lever cap that doesn't have the little jog between the big hole and the littler one.