Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Dropped my LABP

Posts

Dropped my LABP

#1

Dropped my LABP

Bruce Mack

Today I dropped my Veritas low angle block plane on my concrete shop floor. It must have landed on its nose as the adjustable mouth plate had jammed and blunted the edge of the blade. My right hand is often painful and the LABP hard to hold. After resharpening, I still had a plane that is uncomfortable in my hand. My Lie-Nielsen adjustable mouth block plane feels better and will be my go-to instead of the Sunday-best block plane from now on. I reread Derek's review of the Veritas premium block planes and I'm thinking of getting the DX60 which looks exceedingly hand-friendly. I'd like a comfort assessment from anyone who has held both. Thanks.

Re: Dropped my LABP

#2

Re: Dropped my LABP

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have one. It’s easy to hold but if hand strength is problematic, it’s heavier than a Stanley 60-1/2. I have very dry hands, so I use those gloves with sticky nubbins on them, makes it much easer.

Th DX60 is so precise I use it as a small smoother.

Re: Dropped my LABP

#3

Re: Dropped my LABP

John in NM

I have a DX60 and I like it. Years ago a friend had a LN 60 1/2 but I found it hard to hold - hands too big as I recall. My Stanley 60 1/2 was a better fit.

The LN 102 I do like, even though its smaller than the 60 1/2 I can hold it comfortably. No idea why. Lighter maybe?

Re: Dropped my LABP

#4

Re: Dropped my LABP

David Weaver

Bruce, I know you didn't ask this question, but I have minor arthritis and found doing the block plane functions with a small bench plane or files to be preferable.

Re: Dropped my LABP

#5

Re: Dropped my LABP

Bruce Mack

Thank you all for your suggestions and observations. My thumb is painful and my grip is weak. Gloves sound like a useful option as do alternative planing/shaping methods. I have a rubber mat in front of the bench but I was at a small assembly area when the plane "leapt".

Re: Dropped my LABP

#6

Recommendations

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bruce, you cannot go wrong with either the LN #60 1/2 or the Veritas DX60. Both are comfortable to hold.

Both are the same width, and will suit the same hand. They are also the same length. If anything, I slightly prefer the LN as the grip is a little more rounded.

Of the two, the ergonomics of the Veritas are much better: better blade adjustment, not just with the Norris-type adjuster and depth stop, but the lever cap wheel is easier to get to on the Veritas. This is only an issue after you have used both.

Veritas has PM-V11 steel, which is excellent and better, however I have not experienced any issues with the A2 steel in the LN. Both get sharp and hold an edge well.

The other block planes to consider are the LN #102 and, a personal favourite, the Veritas Pocket Plane. Both these are excellent, especially if you are looking for something small and light with authority.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dropped my LABP

#7

Re: Recommendations

Jim Matthews

While not my first choice, ECE makes a modern wood body block plane.

It doesn't weigh as much as the cast iron variants, and might be less slippery.

https://www.highlandwoodworking.com/primusadjustableblockplane.aspx

HNT Gordon also makes a smaller block plane with a steeper blade, but it's expensive.

Re: Dropped my LABP

#8

Not a bad idea...

John in NM

Wood plane might just do the trick.

One could even stipple it for better grip, though that might be an experiment better left for a shop made one. Stippling works best for things lightly gripped, but then I also use a pretty aggressive tool to do it so the stipple ends up being deep.

Re: Dropped my LABP

#9

Re: Not a bad idea...

William Duffield

Stippling might be most appropriate for a shoot board plane. :D Ducking and running!

Re: Dropped my LABP

#10

Re: Recommendations

William Duffield

There is one small advantage to the Norris Adjuster: If you lend the plane to some lunkhead, they might strip the Norris threads if they don't know enough to loosen the lever cap wheel before trying to adjust the blade depth.

Re: Dropped my LABP

#11

It took a minute...

John in NM

But I finally got it :D

Re: Dropped my LABP

#12

Re: Recommendations

Bruce Mack

Derek - I purchased the DX60 and today I hollow-ground and sharpened the blade. I find I can apply more pressure and more consistent downward pressure with my right hand as I push with the left (leftie for writing and planing, rightie for hammering). The knob is easy on the ball of my thumb. No pain at all after planing many scraps. Very pleased.

Re: Dropped my LABP

#13

Re: Dropped my LABP

Don Peters

I have both, and I've used them both for years. My standard for the past fifty years has been the Record low angle block planes (#60?). They're significantly improved by substituting Veritas V11 irons. They're a bit more comfortable in my hand than the DX60, which is larger and heavier with a shallower, smoother top to the cap iron. However that cap iron requires me to grip it harder to keep from slipping off it. But the Noris adjuster is nice, and as always, Veritas' fit and finish are superb. I think you need both, and they'll both get roached if you drop them