Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

Posts

Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

#1

Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

Line and Berry is the decoration found on Chester County furniture from the early 1700’s. It is described in detail in a PhD thesis by Lee Ellen Griffith. It consists of geometric patterns like that shown on this spice box door. The patterns were largely scratched into the wood with a compass with a cutter on one end and a point on the other.


In making similar furniture the problem is how to reproduce these patterns. The pattern on spice box door is familiar to anyone with a compass who was bored at the progress of geometry class. Its origin is inscribing a hexagon in a circle.


It is less obvious how the pattern on this drawer is created and scaled to the drawer height. I decoded this pattern fortuitously while trying to draw it on a drawing board. The arcs are all of radius R or 2R. The centers of all the arcs lie on an R x R grid. Reproducing the pattern on any size drawer is a simple matter of setting R to some fraction of the drawer height that will result in the pattern attractively filling the space.

When I proposed in a letter to Popular Woodworking that this common Chester County pattern was created this way the claim was met with skepticism by one expert on this furniture. Undeterred, this discovery perked my curiosity about other Line and Berry patterns.

I was granted permission to study these patterns on furniture in the Chester County museum. I found that many of the patterns could be laid out with just a ruler and compass or divider as was the case with the drawer illustrated in the picture. To word another way, the patterns were laid out with geometric proportions, not by freehand.

I also discovered that when examined closely, many of the inlaid lines varied in thickness. I failed to get any interest in looking into how the conventional explanations for how these patterns were scratched and inlaid would lead to lines of varying thickness along their length.


I want to decorate the top drawer of this bedside dresser with a pattern I found illustrated in the Griffith thesis, page 23.


I faced the problem of figuring out how it was created. Given my previous experience I was certain it was created by simple combinations of compass arcs centered according to some underlying geometric principal. The arcs are clearly all of the same radii. Connecting their centers revealed how the pattern was made to develop across the surface. Now came the problem of how to scale it to my drawer space.

There are three independent variables- the desired pattern height, width and the fact that it is symmetrical. The graceful development of the pattern was at first not apparent. Not only the size of the resulting pattern but its ascetics is dictated by not one dependent variable like the drawer pattern, but 3 variables- arc radius, bottom angle the bottom arcs are centered on and the top angle these arcs are centered on.

I could not determine a predictive relationship between the dependent variables that enabled me to predict the final height and width of the pattern.

In the beginning I imagined this patter between two pulls. But as I worked on scaling it I realized it accommodated a single knob nestled in the center. Now I had to rescale it again by trial and error of the three variables so that it would stretch across the drawer front. Many sheets of drawing paper later......

Before scratching on an actual drawer front I needed to see what this paper pattern would look like in reality. Also I wanted to determine if it would look good on cherry. I have never seen line and berry done on cherry. And finally, I needed to determine what size berry looked right.



Shown in picture 5 is the test pattern hastily scratched on a cherry test piece. The first thing I learned was that I was out of practice scratching- ragged cuts, points that slipped out.....But, a test pattern emerged and I find it OK for the need. Oh, I never explained the need. I promised granddaughters I would have something special on their dressers.

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

#2

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks for this; I would have to experiment to understand your statements, but I'm not surprised the folks who made those relied on basic geometry to lay them out.

It sounds to me like your granddaughters have grandpa's heart pretty thoroughly ensnared.

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

#3

a good place to start decoding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

presuming you have an accurate picture or the piece at hand...... Set a divider to one of the radii. Then start walking it around trying to discover how to walk from the first radius to the next. In the case at hand by swinging the divider from the first radius to where the arc intersected the next arc, driving the point in there, the second radius center was where the point intersected the top angle. Soon it became apparent that the intermediate divider points lay on a line bisecting the two angle. The pattern spread as a function of the difference in these two angle (30 and 40 degree on the Figure). The spread makes the pattern graceful, not geometrically ridged.

It is easier than it sounds once you believe there is an underlying geometric pattern for the points.

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

#4

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

Wiley Horne

Bill,

Really fine piece of analysis! And coupled to your own practice and results too.

1. I notice in the top picture of the spice box door you made, the inlay is arranged so that all the compass points end up being covered. In the originals you’ve seen or found in the thesis, were the compass points covered, or just frankly left wherever they fell. Just curious.

2. Could you show your compass/scratch equipment?

3. Beautiful drawer design you have underway!

Thanks, wiley

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

#5

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Chester Co museum...Typical


I do not intentionally cover the points. Some fall where they get covered

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

#6

tools for line and berry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Some of these tools are specifically for excavating the corners when string frames a drawer, for example (1st on left). The second from the left is a punch. It is impossible to scratch the end of a dead end channel to depth. The punch is used at dead ends to punch a crisp ending to the channel. Other tools are used to dig out crumbs that stick in the channel.

I take great delight in scratching these geometric patterns. It is precision work. Strategy is involved. I scratch from the outside in. Why? because scratching the next arc in will cut the end of the previous arc and make a perfect mating of the end of the outer arc with the next innermost arc. These strategies reveal in the practice rounds.

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

#7

Re: tools for line and berry

Wiley Horne

Bill,

Thanks, very interesting! I never thought of using a punch to make crisp stringing corners—maybe we should call the punch a kerfing tool. On the Lee Valley tool, is the cutter a sawtooth type, or the gouge type?

To get the holly strings into the curves, do tou have to wet them, or are they persuadable dry?

Wiley

Re: Deconstructing Line and Berry Decoration

#8

Wet the string!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Um, that would be a very bad idea. If the arc is too tight the string is contact heated over a mandrel, upon which it bends readily.

Holly is almost like alimp plastic. I bends easily. Some substitute maple. Miserable by comparison.