Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

oil stones

Posts

oil stones

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

oil stones

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have a white oil stone I found at a flea market years ago. I just used it to polish up the edge on a spokeshave blade and it appears to be a fine stone,gritwise. I've heard about white and black arkasas stones. What is the grit equivalent to a water stone? Is white the finest?

Re: oil stones

#2

Re: oil stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Years ago Brent Beach asked me about my sharpening regimen and then told me I was sharpening backwards. He had looked at grit charts and thought the Arkansas stones I used to finish the edge were coarser than than the coarse water stone I started with. He did not know the value of actual experience.

Oil stones like Arkansas are so different from waterstones that grit comparison is meaningless. Arkansas stones are not a collection of grit particles held together by some binder and gradually wear away and expose fresh grit. For all but the smallest tools, they serve to polish the edge, not so much to wear steel away.

You are better off rubbing an already sharp tool on your Arkansas stone and seeing for yourself whether the stone improves sharpness or durability.

Re: oil stones

#3

Density...

David Weaver

..air space on oilstones determines their fineness. If a stone is 10% air, it'll actually cut fairly coarsely (except washitas - not sure why that is), until it's broken in.

If a stone is 1% air, it'll cut very finely. Generally, lack of air space in a stone means a very smooth looking surface, and on white stones, allows passage of a bright light through the stone (that's not always true).

If your stone is regular/square enough to measure accurately and weigh, anything above 2.6 specific gravity in density correponds to a stone that would be sold now as a fine finishing stone.

As warren suggests, ignore most of the charts that show ranking of various stones (whether they're grit vs. other stones, or oilstone exclusive density charts).

A stone that had no pores at all would be somewhere in the range of 2.67 specific gravity. There's a gigantic difference between a stone that's 2.4 vs. 2.65.

Try shining light through the center of the stone or a large part of the edges, though - that's your first easy test. I've never seen a stone that easily passes light that wasn't very fine.

Re: oil stones

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Density...

Jack Guzman from Maine

This stone is mounted in a wooden box. Obviously important to someone. It is flat and removes scratches from coarser stones. I will be using it alot more,learning the stone. I have never used oil stones. I started with sandpaper,switched to water stones. I hated the fact that water stones erode so easily. I had to reflatten often. I've been using diamonds but I want to explore oil stones a bit.

Re: oil stones

#5

Re: Density...

David Weaver

You'll like it (I think). Oilstones and other slower stones favor more experienced woodworkers who have developed touch.

They're also good at working out scratches and kind of run out of steam as the scratches are disappearing (depending on hardness - the particles are about the same hardness as a 62rc iron carbide. Steel in hardness around that number is where they seem to have the most flexibility).

Re: oil stones

#6

Re: Density...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

At their finest, are they abrading or mostly moving metal around?

The correlation of translucence and lack of voids is reasonable. The huge difference in refractive index between air and silica is going to cause extreme light scatter. More scatter, darker. Other extreme, crystal quartz, no voids, transparent.

Re: oil stones

#7

Re: Density...

David Weaver

I couldn't tell you if they're moving metal or abrading it, except to say that for certain, when the steel isn't as hard as what's typical now, you can still generate black swarf (not like an aggressive stone, but it's generated) on a translucent arkansas. No matter how settled in it may be.

Under the microscope, even this settled in stone (which I've only used for razors until testing irons) will show scratches:


Where 1 micron diamonds looked like this:


You may recall that the 1 micron edge lasted a little bit longer (it was subjectively sharper, too, and left a brighter finish on the test surface).

It's certainly the case that the oilstone becomes very slow on harder steel, and that can be used advantageously. At the same time, something like a cheap pocketknife that may be mid 50s hardness (or softer) stainless steel will never cease to generate a large wire edge on even the finest arkansas stone.

It just makes it difficult to compare because of the added variable of steel hardness having so much influence on what it's doing.

I've sold off a lot of my sharpening stones, and one of the questions that I always get from people is "what grit equivalent would you say this is?" I usually waste my time explaining to them that they need to think of oilstones as oilstones and use them as oilstones, not with some kind of technique that they like to use on a soft synthetic stone with a baked binder. I don't think it registers. (black and trans stones are excellent for straight razors - one of the few things that you would sharpen where you can actually feel the difference between the various stones).

Re: oil stones

#8

Re: oil stones

Jim Matthews

You've got responses from the people who taught me what little I know about oilstones.

I like Arkansas oilstones for my older (1970s and before) high carbon O1 steel. I have poor results honing Japanese plane irons on Arkies.

I keep my Arkansas stones "fresh" with a coarse Atoma diamond plate, which also works as a grinding plate for damaged edges. I clean the plate with WD40 and a file brush.

Your stone is likely finer than the last stone I use; a "Lily White" Arkansas.

I use a hard leather strop to release the wire burr formed. I use a Norton "Fine India" first, until I raise a wire burr, repeat on the Lily white and strop off reduced wire edge.

If the stones stop cutting, the diamond plate restores a clean surface.

DW is too modest to suggest his own invaluable video, which illustrates the method.

https://youtu.be/G85B6iVCyMo

Re: oil stones

#9

grit size

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Thank you for the data. Interesting.

Specifying a particle size for a stone that was made by sintering graded particles makes some sense. I don't know the details of how ARK stones were made but the result bears no comparison to sintered graded particles. Hence, it makes no sense to describe them in terms of a particle size. Given their variable performance with steel of different hardness and composition it doesn't even make sense to describe them in terms of a "scratch " or particle size equivalent.

Do you know at what time ARK stones became widely available, that is, a cabinet maker in Charlestown could buy one locally?

Re: oil stones

#10

Perked my curiosity

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Read up on geology of Novaculite. Marine silica organisms die and sink. These dissolve, ore or less, and recrystallize to make chert. Finally the chert gets squished and heated to consolidate the silica crystals in the chert, maybe not unlike sintering. The bottom line is that this stone is the product of silica crystallization and "sintering" of sorts. As if by magic the resulting morphology becomes what is good for sharpening....whatever that is. I'll bet you have some insight. I didn't go searching for a SEM picture of the structure...maybe later. Need to work on finishing drawers.

Re: oil stones

#11

Re: grit size

John in NM

Arkansas stones are microcrystaline or cryptocrystaline silica, a subset of chert known as novaculite. The theory is that they are like a sandstone, but vastly finer grained due to being made up of siliceous skeletons of micro organisms like diatoms. Density likely has to do with how much they have been compressed by layers of rock deposited above.

Sintering isn't a bad analogy actually, the difference in performance has to do with how densely they are compacted and also the material of which they are composed. I don't think anyone making sintered material would bother making the equivalent of a chert. Too fine, too soft, too dense.

Quartz is an odd mineral, as soft as it is, I've always found it much harder to polish than other minerals. I suspect that it is less reactive in the chemical component of polish-material interaction. I wonder if that has something to do with why Arkansas stones don't work well for very hard blades. Just speculating wildly though :D

Re: oil stones

#12

Re: Perked my curiosity

John in NM

That's what I get for writing a wordy response! :D In the time it took me to write out, you went and researched it, and summed up the same material more succinctly.

Re: oil stones

#13

Re: grit size

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Grit size does not make sense for Arkansas stones. The stones are partly metamorphosed so that the crystals have melted together through heat and pressure. A freshly cut Arkansas stone will be somewhat rough, but we use them in a polished condition where it is productive to think about them as flat with voids that catch irregularities on the steel. The density of the stone is related to the size and frequency of voids.

Turkey stones are similar. They were used in Europe from at least the first century to the 19th, although Roubo (1769) was complaining about the deterioration of quality. (too many defects, as if they were mining stuff that had previously been passed over). Turkey stones were imported to America in the 18th century and were the stones used by serious craftsmen. Holtzapffel (1850) mentions both Turkey stones and Arkansas stones as stones available in England.

Arkansas was settled in the early 19th century; I don't think there are any 18th century building extant in the state. The Indians used Arkansas stones for projectile points.

Re: oil stones

#14

Re: grit size

David Weaver

I think warren partially answered this already, that it seems like 1800s (relatively early for some areas, maybe? Don't know - but you'd expect a natural stone of this type to be in use for many more centuries than that, just as the japanese stones were).

As far as its composition, i stay out of chemistry because chemistry is all or none (it seems to me to be one of those things where guessing at it leads to a lot of wrong conclusions, and I've been told many about arkansas stones). The best description I've seen is silica transformed by heat and pressure, and the good veins have great purity - like over 99% novaculite or something).

I've had many stones made of silica, from the US and from japan, and there just isn't much similarity in use to a silica stone that doesn't go through the same transformation. It's luck, I guess.

Warren mentions turkish stones. There are two types, light and dark. The light is still commercially available, but it's not a good finisher - more of a middle stone. They are also novaculite, and they feel a lot like a novaculite stone if you slurry it, except they slurry on their own and wear down faster. The consequence is that they wear and the edge that they create isn't as fine. For a craftsman doing a lot of full bevel work, maybe the tradeoff in europe was worthwhile.

What I've been told that's incorrect about novaculite is that it won't sharpen anything hard (that's not true, it will sharpen slowly, and you will be able to create black swarf). It's absolutely essential to be able to sharpen freehand with a novaculite stone and hard steel to get the most out of it. The same is true of a good japanese stone - you get the most out of those stones by being able to manipulate them.

Warren pointed out long ago (and I thought it sounded simplistic, but it is - to my mind - correct) that one ought to find the stone that was used in conjunction with the steel. As in, if you want to sharpen japanese tools with natural stones, they will probably work best using the stones that were local to the toolmakers. If the stones wouldn't have been able to sharpen hard tools there (their natural stones have natural aluminum oxide from volcanic sediment), then the tools would've been softer. They wouldn't have made tools as hard if they had novaculite on hand.

I'm not sure what the 18th century woodworker would've used, but I'm sure at the same time, there were people sailing ships to the US who were willing to sell it to them. I'm sure poorer people tried various slates (I have, too, just for fun), but slates are less refined than novaculite for use, and slower.

Re: oil stones

#15

Some litrature data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When the scientific literature is searched there has been a lot of work done on Ark rocks with composition and structure. At least on some ARK Novaculite the particles that fused, by water dissolution/precipitation not thermal, remain distinguishable. In this study the particle size distribution peaked at 3 micron with a range "0" to about 10 micron. Occasional 100 micron particles were observed that are thought to be skeletal remains that were not transformed.

It would seem that the surface of these rocks would do more plowing across the steel than the cutting/milling desirable for machine grinding. While these rocks certainly remove material from the steel it would seem that a fair amount of moving it around occurs. I would expect the scratch profile to be substantially different from diamond or fresh surface aluminum oxide. It is tempting to speculate that these relatively soft stones do more to the metal surface than simply scratch away metal from it.

Re: oil stones

#16

Re: grit size

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A few notes:

There are quite a few references to Turkey stones in America in the 18th century and early 19th century. Here are two examples.

George Washington ordered a Turkey stone along with a number of woodworking tools in 1759.

Fifty years later, James Dinsmore made an inventory of Jefferson's joinery shop at Monticello in 1809, which included a Turkey stone.

Two scientists, Hunter and Dunbar, were sent by Jefferson to explore Arkansas in 1804, in a parallel expedition to Lewis and Clark. They noted the stones which were later called Arkansas stones in their journals.

Thomas Nuttall, who was a botanical explorer, made trips to Arkansas 1819-1820, brought back hone samples, and made a description of the stones, which he noted had a specific gravity of 2.60. He claimed this was the first scientific description. We were quarrying the stone about a decade later.

Re: oil stones

#17

ARK Novaculite question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Any explorer familiar with Novaculite stones from Turkey, or elsewhere, presumably would have recognized this material when they encountered it in ARK. I understand the Indians were quarrying it so the material would have been exposed, as well as seen in their points , scrapers and knives. Expeditions certainly carried knives. Would it have been likely many/most expeditions would have had a Novaculite stone with them to be referenced when they saw the tools and quarries in ARK?

Or, did the need to sharpen steel settle in ARK and in the quest to find something local to sharpen the kitchen knife someone tried that rock the Indians dug out of the ridge and found it worked great?

No doubt there is a study somewhere in some archive that answers this question.

Re: oil stones

#18

That sounds like...

David Weaver

..the likely origin. Someone measuring specific gravity and hauling samples back probably knew that there was some value to the stone (or at least potential value).

I don't read back that far but have never managed to find an arkansas stone that has any documentation earlier than the 1850s (as in, one that I've been able to find and buy).

The early stones are often a little bit thicker, maybe not quite as geometrically perfect, and my early ones have had chisel marks on the backs.

I'd imagine the speed of the turkish/cretan stones made them very marketable because a good craftsman would've been able to use one alone without much else. I spent the time it took to find one of each and they're OK, but the lack of ability of the stone to really hold its particles tight like an arkansas stone makes it less desirable. One could use a stone like that and get stuck dressing it (not absolutely necessary, but they do shed surface fast enough that you have to be more diligent in using the whole surface).

As bill is talking about with the combination of removing and moving material on the surface of an iron, a turkish stone with a laminated iron does more hard cutting and gives a feel/edge more like a modern stone because of it.

I didn't pay a lot for my two, but it took a year or two before I managed to find the darker type (and mine is more of a dark brown where the most choice are closer to black). They have a reputation for being a little bit fragile and not tolerant at all of any mishandling and I can see why.

Re: oil stones

#19

the light colored stones are still mined.. *LINK*

David Weaver

...and sold.

There may be some sticker shock looking at this at first, but a deep breath and you can notice that this is a 10 pound stone.

The darker brown stone that I have is finer, which matches the commentary either in holtzapffel or another text that I saw somewhere.

The light cretans being mined and sold are usually in blockier stubby sizes, and someone was selling them for about $60 on ebay years ago. Once oil is used with them, they become darker than this, but they have a coarser grittier feel.

if cased, I guess they would've made a good carpenter's stone. You could refresh properly handled laminated tools indefinitely with one.


light cretan

Re: oil stones

#20

Re: ARK Novaculite question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Today we call Arkansas stones and Turkey stones both Novaculite. Novaculite also occurs in Japan and Israel and other areas of North America.

There is quite a variation in the Novaculite found just in Arkansas. Nuttall felt that what he found was sufficiently different from Turkey stones as to merit a new mineral name. And some 19th century descriptions suggest that Arkansas stones were of poor quality. It probably took quite some time to sort out various strains of the rock in different quarries.

If you want to read Nuttall's description, here it is in the Journal of the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia. Footnotes on pages 50 and 51.

https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/page/36831303#page/65/mode/1up

Re: oil stones

#21

experience from buying..

David Weaver

..this is subjective, but it's from real sampling.

I made comments about SG because I noticed that as norton was getting kind of whiter and whiter stones, I ended up buying an IM-313 trans stone. It barely passed light. It was 2.6 SG instead of 2.6+ (we maybe able to measure a little more easily than the old sample, or maybe the sample you mentioned wasn't one of the most dense).

There is a clear difference in fineness between a 2.6SG sample and one that's very close to the maximum density of silica. Both can be finishers, but a stone that I'd call marginal (which offended a norton dealer when I said it) will take a while to get broken in. It just isn't as good as something like dans.

I had stones from these different makers:

* dans (black, trans, hard, soft - no "true hard" white)

* norton (black and trans)

* halls black

* natural whetstone (black trans, hard, soft)

* case soft arkansas (may be a smiths product - modern and coarse)

The dans hard stones are the best. I've had at least a dozen of them (there were times I could manage to find them cheap, then just turn them over to someone else and it was a waste of time but no cost). If fine is the order, they're generally better than vintage stones. I couldn't say that about any of the other makers, though the "black trans", which is just a gray translucent stone from NW was also good, and very dense. But it's costly and it's just another colored translucent stone.

There are rumors here and there about the rarity of trans and good black stones, but dan's can charge enough to go deeper and deeper to get them. They do tours (maybe they're private) and I mentioned to someone who went on a tour about how norton says there's an appalling amount waste to get good thickness trans stones. Apparently, the material that dan's is bringing up is more consistent and less waste.

Halls black stone had the characteristic foreign particle here or there, was more coarse feeling in general with the particles, and then settled into a more glassy feel. It's not subtle enough that someone else wouldn't notice the same thing I do.

At the same time, natural whetstone (which has inexpensive black stones that I didn't dare to try) at least at one point had wonderful large white inexpensive soft stones that can be slurried to cut about as fast as an india stone, but the edge condition that they leave is really nice for going straight to a novaculite finisher.

As I recall, I sold most of my settled in stones to shavers. They pay enough that I can break even.

My curiosity is satisfied, and i no longer do that kind of screwing around.

Magog stones were at type in canada to add to the novaculite. Llyn idwall (gray stones with black specs, usually a little undersized) are also superb finishing stones that may be slightly finer than a trans or black ark, but even slower, too. Charnley forest, also, fine but softer than arkansas novaculite.

In regard to the turkey stones, if anyone ever had any question about them being novaculite, scuffing the surface of an arkansas stone and then comparing it to a fast cutting turkey stone - identical feel. Every slurried type has a different feel. Slate, japanese, coticule, novaculite - they all have a slightly different feel even at the same coarseness, and the edge quality is different between the various types. It's easy to see why japanese stones have sold continuously, as have arkansas stones, while slates and coticules fell out of fashion.

Same with charnley forest hones - they all have the same general feel, but the best are not quite as good as an arkansas stone, and they're more variable. I'm sure that made it easy for retailers to get good uniform arkansas stone stock and sell mail order or based on reputation.

I'm also fairly sure that in a world where shysters sold pencils made mostly of a sulfur mix or inserted a tiny bit of genuine lead before garbage that there was some necessary separating of wheat from chaff as far as early arkansas stones sold. I had a combination stone that was novaculite at one point that I got for tool use. it was novaculite, but unusable. I'm sure there was a fair amount of substandard black stone material sold on the reputation of the good material until pike and norton dominated the market.

Re: oil stones

#22

Re: oil stones

Charlie

http://archeology.uark.edu/novaculite/index.html?pageName=What%20is%20Novaculite?

Re: oil stones

#23

Re: oil stones

Charlie

https://encyclopediaofarkansas.net/entries/novaculite-2220/

Re: oil stones

#24

Re: oil stones

Charlie

http://archeology.uark.edu/novaculite/index.html