experience from buying..
David Weaver
..this is subjective, but it's from real sampling.
I made comments about SG because I noticed that as norton was getting kind of whiter and whiter stones, I ended up buying an IM-313 trans stone. It barely passed light. It was 2.6 SG instead of 2.6+ (we maybe able to measure a little more easily than the old sample, or maybe the sample you mentioned wasn't one of the most dense).
There is a clear difference in fineness between a 2.6SG sample and one that's very close to the maximum density of silica. Both can be finishers, but a stone that I'd call marginal (which offended a norton dealer when I said it) will take a while to get broken in. It just isn't as good as something like dans.
I had stones from these different makers:
* dans (black, trans, hard, soft - no "true hard" white)
* norton (black and trans)
* halls black
* natural whetstone (black trans, hard, soft)
* case soft arkansas (may be a smiths product - modern and coarse)
The dans hard stones are the best. I've had at least a dozen of them (there were times I could manage to find them cheap, then just turn them over to someone else and it was a waste of time but no cost). If fine is the order, they're generally better than vintage stones. I couldn't say that about any of the other makers, though the "black trans", which is just a gray translucent stone from NW was also good, and very dense. But it's costly and it's just another colored translucent stone.
There are rumors here and there about the rarity of trans and good black stones, but dan's can charge enough to go deeper and deeper to get them. They do tours (maybe they're private) and I mentioned to someone who went on a tour about how norton says there's an appalling amount waste to get good thickness trans stones. Apparently, the material that dan's is bringing up is more consistent and less waste.
Halls black stone had the characteristic foreign particle here or there, was more coarse feeling in general with the particles, and then settled into a more glassy feel. It's not subtle enough that someone else wouldn't notice the same thing I do.
At the same time, natural whetstone (which has inexpensive black stones that I didn't dare to try) at least at one point had wonderful large white inexpensive soft stones that can be slurried to cut about as fast as an india stone, but the edge condition that they leave is really nice for going straight to a novaculite finisher.
As I recall, I sold most of my settled in stones to shavers. They pay enough that I can break even.
My curiosity is satisfied, and i no longer do that kind of screwing around.
Magog stones were at type in canada to add to the novaculite. Llyn idwall (gray stones with black specs, usually a little undersized) are also superb finishing stones that may be slightly finer than a trans or black ark, but even slower, too. Charnley forest, also, fine but softer than arkansas novaculite.
In regard to the turkey stones, if anyone ever had any question about them being novaculite, scuffing the surface of an arkansas stone and then comparing it to a fast cutting turkey stone - identical feel. Every slurried type has a different feel. Slate, japanese, coticule, novaculite - they all have a slightly different feel even at the same coarseness, and the edge quality is different between the various types. It's easy to see why japanese stones have sold continuously, as have arkansas stones, while slates and coticules fell out of fashion.
Same with charnley forest hones - they all have the same general feel, but the best are not quite as good as an arkansas stone, and they're more variable. I'm sure that made it easy for retailers to get good uniform arkansas stone stock and sell mail order or based on reputation.
I'm also fairly sure that in a world where shysters sold pencils made mostly of a sulfur mix or inserted a tiny bit of genuine lead before garbage that there was some necessary separating of wheat from chaff as far as early arkansas stones sold. I had a combination stone that was novaculite at one point that I got for tool use. it was novaculite, but unusable. I'm sure there was a fair amount of substandard black stone material sold on the reputation of the good material until pike and norton dominated the market.