Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

question planing case pieces

Posts

question planing case pieces

#1

question planing case pieces

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I machine planed these panels they picked out both directions. So I drum sanded the last bit. In my hands drum sanding is bad news with rogue scratches showing up that are onerous to sand out by hand. So I decided to plane them out.



Where does one put a case piece to plane it? On the floor is too low with no way to hold it. On the bench is too high. I stood on step ladder....most inconveniently.

Re: question planing case pieces

#2

Re: question planing case pieces

John in NM

The last shop I worked for had assembly tables that were various heights, the one at my bench was short, around 16". Usually we ended up making the same pieces over and over, being the new guy I got to make a lot of case pieces since most of the other guys didn't like doing them.

Another shop I worked for had benches on benches, they had removable dowels in the legs and holes in the top. Those were actually really neat, a tall guy like me could stack a short one on the regular bench and get to the right height, and then there was a really convenient place under it to place tools. You could also grab one of those short benches off another bench and use it as an assembly table or somewhere to plane as you needed to do.

Neither of these shops really approved of plane use - boss always thought it was slow.... boss didn't make anything though :D

You could probably make something like that short bench - those had 4x4 legs, 2x4 skirt, and a plywood top. Not too horrible heavy to stick in a corner until you need it.

Re: question planing case pieces

#3

Re: question planing case pieces

David Weaver

I put them on the floor butted up against something shorter, on a towel and with a buffer. My basement is carpeted and if the mrs isn't home, I've done it in there.

Re: question planing case pieces

#4

Re: question planing case pieces

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

Good for you! Coupla ideas:

1. Saw bench legs down by 3” or so.

2. Make bench legs adjustable height.

3. Make a raft out of 8-ft. 4x4’s to stand on.

4. What David said: get something cheap and flat, like a door or doubled plywood, on sawhorses, and butt it up against a wall. Disassemble when done.

Seems like this is going to come up again, which argues for a bench modification.

Wiley

Re: question planing case pieces

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

low bench

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill, I had a heavy ugly coffee table that I almost threw out til I noticed it was a perfect assembly table for chairmaking. I have since built a better version out of rough 4x4s and a rough board top.

Re: question planing case pieces

#6

Re: question planing case pieces

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In hand tool work, we do things in a different order. Tear out problems are taken care of in the trying plane stage, so joinery is done with stock that is already has a high degree of fine surface quality. Smoothing is done between joinery and gluing; just taking off a single thin layer to remove markings or scuffs. It would be clumsy to have to remove any appreciable amount from a glued up case, and usually none is done.

For something like a blanket chest, where we have through dovetails, we have to plane the box after gluing. It is nice to have a mat or a cloth or both, butt the box against the bench and work off the floor. Once again. however, it is not as if very much is taken off at this late stage.

Re: question planing case pieces

#7

Re: question planing case pieces

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would be clumsy to have to remove any appreciable amount from a glued up case, and usually none is done.

I confirmed that fact. I way underestimated how much planing I would have to do to remove a few rogue scratches from the abrasive sizing with the drum sander. I learn something new on every build, sometimes the hard way.

Re: question planing case pieces

#8

Re: question planing case pieces

David Weaver

I make far less than warren, but would agree with what he said about it being light work (and why it's not a big deal to do it on the floor). The only thing I'm planing off of a case (hopefully) is the lightest of marks. It stinks to work on the floor, but the amount of planing you're doing is little and it's just quick, work.

I don't know how a person not using a cap iron would be able to do it - any lifted grain would be catastrophic.

Re: question planing case pieces

#9

Re: question planing case pieces

Sgian Dubh

I suspect you machine plane glued up panels, which is the same as me. In a sort of parallel with what I think both Warren and David have said, I then hand plane the machined surface of the panel using smoothing planes. I usually have three smoothing planes on the go at the same time, each at different settings, one relatively coarse to take out the bulk of the machining marks, the next less coarse to take out any marks from the 'coarse' set plane, and the third one set very fine and extra sharp to take care of any odds and ends from earlier planing. Quite often I'll add a fourth plane to the mix, a block plane for little tweaks. Whether or not both sides of the panel get planed depends on what the panel's for. With cabinets I frequently only hand plane the money face, i.e., the show face, unless the inside face is also on show. For example, I usually only plane the outside face of a chest of drawers, but usually plane both faces of a panel of it's a display cabinet. That takes care of the basic planing.

Usually, there's a bit of final planing (and scraping and sanding) after the cabinet's assembled to take out odd dents and other small blemishes that develop through handling, joint cutting, and the like. And then there's what to do when dealing with through dovetails that need a bit of levelling off after assembly. I do much the same as others have already described and usually the carcase goes on to a blanket or packing foam on the floor, with another part of the carcase pushed up tight to the workbench, again cushioned with something between the carcase and the bench. Where I can I add a clamp or two to hold the cabinet firm, and plane as needed, sometimes standing on a stool, box, or anything else that puts me at the right height.

That's about it really, the idea being generally to minimise the amount of final prepping required of an already assembled cabinet. Slainte.

Re: question planing case pieces

#10

thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was overly optimistic that trivial planing would be required after assembly.

In the future I have a place to wedge a case piece against and plane on the floor. Somehow never thought of this way.

Re: question planing case pieces

#12

what a great idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

better late than never, especially with this good idea. Beats the large sheet of plywood I keep on hand for the task. And in my case, these small cases would have fit on such an arrangement just fine and dandy. Thanks!