Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

How do you know whan a plane is dull

Posts

How do you know whan a plane is dull

#1

How do you know whan a plane is dull

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This question may appear so stupid no one may consider an answer. But bear with me.

A few times a day I pick up a plane, hit a few licks, and carry on with whatever I am doing. Using a plane this way I have no way of feeling it getting dull. The feed back is too far apart in time and the planing task is usually greatly different each occasion. I was planing the face of a bracket foot this morning, smoothing a sticking up dovetail pin this afternoon, mowing off the overhang of a facing strip later and just now leveling the edge of a drawer divider to prepare it for receiving a facing strip. These tasks last seconds.

So, suppose you visited my shop, and you were helping me building these cabinets and there came up a task for removing a few shavings of wood for some reason. You grabbed one of my planes and began to use it, smoothing and leveling the edge of a drawer divider, for example. If it was dull enough that could couldn't stand it, what would tell you it was dull? What would you feel or see?

To be clear we are not taking full shavings smoothing a top where the planed surface will be varnished without sanding. Almost always the shaving width will be but a fraction of the blade width, and variable task to task. Surface quality, excepting tear-out, is irrelevant. The surface is gong to be covered up or sanded.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#2

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

David Weaver

The plane needs to pick up the shaving easily at the start of a cut with no skip, and not skip through any part of the cut assuming that the surface is already flat.

that's pretty much it. You can actually see a wear bevel if you can manage to be in the direction where a light source is angling off of the reflective surface toward your eye, and when I ran the durability test, I found that this visible bevel (especially on the back of the iron) occurs fairly early - the more polished the iron is, the easier it is to see it. I could see it without magnification, even when the plane left behind a bright surface.

This is true on softer carbon steel irons that fail favorably, too - if you're using the eye test for a wear bevel, it just confirms that the iron is not fresh. Light source and eyesight make this variable (it was visible at 400 feet on V11 as I recall, despite V11 having no issues at all with sharpness and leaving a very bright surface at 400 feet).

During testing (and in regular use) if the plane doesn't stay in a cut under forward push from the rear handle only, it's dull. If you can't skew it slightly and get it started on a cut, it's dull.

if you're able to manipulate it for a few strokes and it gives you a good result (fatigue hardly applies to this), then it sounds like it's fine.

I know it sounds idiotic (but this is coming from someone who couldn't perceive the gigantic planed distance difference between O1 and V11 in actual heavy use), but making a small note about three or four trials with this situation where you say "it's working fine" but sharpen anyway and noting any perceptible differences may be helpful. that would give you good time proximity to compare what you're feeling or noticing.

There was a huge blessing that came out of testing all of the irons, etc, and I dreaded it, anyway because I didn't expect it - and that was the ability to observe exactly how the plane behaves in an identical situation over and over and over and feel in very close time proximity the differences that I would never have observed if they were hours or days apart. The biggest fallacy of all of them was planing with a plane that was starting to come out of the cut on its own. The number of surface ripples, etc, that appeared (even when experimenting with being more and more careful with the plane) led not only to more physical effort planing, but in the amount of follow-up work to planing that would've been required (the ridges in and out of the cut were visible even though they were undulations of only a few thousandths).

If you still can't notice anything in close time proximity, then there's seemingly nothing to solve.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#3

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill and all,

Test for sharp: Ease of starting a thin shaving, and then by the surface it leaves. Really smooth, glossy, and reflecting light=sharp.

Test for dull: Difficult to start a thin shaving, say 2 thousandths or less. Doesn’t want to stay in cut or yield full width—what David said. Surface not reflecting.

Wiley

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#4

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We constantly evaluate the performance of the tool as we use it. If one works with a high degree of concentration, he becomes sensitive to subtle changes as the tool wears. If you cannot notice these things you will not get good performance.

Some think they can evaluate sharpening by looking at the number on the box the stone came in, like "I sharpen to XX000 grit". Others think they can evaluate by some sharpness test they perform right after sharpening.

What is important is the performance over the entire sharpening cycle. And it is only through discerning this performance that one can learn those things that make for a good sharpening: just how long to spend on a stone, just how much pressure to use, use of the strop et cetera. Only by noticing these things can one learn to refine technique with a plane or chisel so that edge life and performance is enhanced.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#5

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

Sgian Dubh

"...suppose you visited my shop, and you were helping me building these cabinets and there came up a task for removing a few shavings of wood for some reason. You grabbed one of my planes and began to use it, smoothing and leveling the edge of a drawer divider, for example. If it was dull enough that could couldn't stand it, what would tell you it was dull? What would you feel or see?

Well, for me, it would simply be that it doesn't cut cleanly, e.g., tearout, chattering, hard to push, that sort of thing. Having picked up a lot of planes that weren't mine in a workshop situation and used them, the feedback from a ropy one has always been pretty instantaneous. Those workshop situations where that's been the case has most often been in college workshops, where I'd grab either workshop planes or a student's plane to demonstrate something.

Which reminds me of a tale from long ago where a student wanted a plane and went to the plane cupboard, grabbed one, and walked towards the bench at which he was working. I said, "That plane's blunt." So the student turned around, went back to the cabinet, replaced the plane and grabbed another one, and again started walking back to the bench. "That one's blunt as well," I said.

Back he went to the cabinet to grab a third one, at which point I said, "They're all blunt. If you want to use one of those planes, you'll have to sharpen one."

Peed off by now, the student testily said, "How do you know they're all blunt, you tosser?" or some other uncomplimentary addition. To which I replied roughly along the lines of, "Well, I'm not the plane sharpening technician. I could sharpen them all, easy-peasy but it's not my job. Anyway, you're the furniture student, so you need to know how to sharpen and set the tools because you can guarantee that almost every other furniture student around here does just like you and grabs a plane in the hope that it'll work without doing any sharpening and setting, and then when they're done, they just, if they can be arsed, dump the plane back in the cabinet, all nicely blunt, and possibly chipped as well. So next time you grab a plane, grab the oilstone whilst you're at it, and sharpen the damn thing as I've shown you three or four times before, if you ever, that is, really want to be the skilled furniture designer maker your hoped for eventual degree in the subject will say you are."

There followed a bit of huffing and puffing from the student, plus some additional disparaging comments about my general persona, followed by some reluctant and desultory sharpening of the plane iron ... good enough anyway to just about see him through the task he'd set himself, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#6

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

Charlie

You can't let it go at that Richard.

A solid-gold classic for the ages:

http://www.richardjonesfurniture.com/Articles/lesson-in-sharpen/lesson-in-sharpening.html

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#7

You have provided some useful insights

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What I want to avoid- unanticipated inability to successfully perform some planing task. This goal means I must be able to anticipate a plane blade approaching failure for the most demanding task I might call upon it to do (which will be less demanding than what many of you require for your needs).

For example, real life situation when I am building. I'm hell bent on getting the bracket feet installed before being called to my lunch of roast beef on rye. I see a blemish that must be removed from the show face before installation because it will be impossible to get at it once the leg is attached to the frame. The last 2 times I used the plane was for jobs so undemanding that a very dull plane would have been successful- knocking off a high dovetail pin, planing the 1/8” overhang of applied facing. Each of these tasks could have damaged the blade and I doubt any of you could detect wear occurring from this kind of planing. From this previous use I have not had any tactile feedback to tell me the plane is approaching too dull to plane this foot.

What I have been told is wear bevel and tactile feedback are what signals you all to sharpen. So how do I use this wisdom?

Wear bevels show up long before I need to sharpen for anything I do with a plane. However, if I looked at enough at them developing over the course of using the plane I likely could anticipate failure from this observing the developing wear bevel. I'll start making this observation for I am optimist this observation will give me the data I need.

In my real life situations failure to pick up a shaving is not a reliable indication of dullness. What I am planing my not be flat. I just experienced this problem planing a divider face. The intersection of the divider was high against the frame but the plane would not engage. Solution, use a shorter plane. Aha, but David has provided a solution. Suppose I keep on hand a test piece of wood as David used for his plane blade testing. Now I have a repeatable surface to test the blade against. Before and after using the plane for productive work I could take a shaving off this test piece. I think before long feedback off this test piece would give me the data I desire. I could sharpen at my convenience and not unexpectedly or more often than necessary.

Thanks to all that provided information I can use.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#8

Communist planes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Entertaining story. And it makes a compelling case for each student owning their own plane. I find it surprising, if not astonishing, that the students would not own their own hand tools for these classes for the reason you describe. What nobody owns nobody cares for.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#9

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

rum

Is it difficult to push/use? Then it's not sharp or not set right.

Is the cut as expected for the type of plane? If not then it's not sharp or not set right.

Perception of sharp is highly subjective based on previous exposure to sharp. As I've gotten better at doing and thus at judging (not necessarily good) my standards have gone up accordingly because I've generally found it to be less work and faster to do so. I suspect there's a lot of runway left at the end of the concourse.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#10

Re: You have provided some useful insights

Sgian Dubh

"Suppose I keep on hand a test piece of wood as David used for his plane blade testing. Now I have a repeatable surface to test the blade against. Before and after using the plane for productive work I could take a shaving off this test piece."

That will no doubt help you determine the fitness of a plane for work. I've never done anything like it because I tend to remember what state my planes are from the last time I used them, even if the gap between uses is many weeks, or even months. I don't always recall, but I seem to in about 90%+ of cases, but I'm not sure why.

Incidentally, I should have mentioned in my last response that a well set up plane in use has a nice sound as you plane a piece of wood, whether it's a narrow edge or a board wider than the plane. The sound is what I can best describe as a sort of hiss or whistle. On the other hand, if the first pass results in a sort of grinding noise, or maybe it could be described as a sort of rumbly noise that, coupled with the other symptoms of 'not good', I mentioned earlier suggest it's time to resharpen and set the tool up well. Slainte.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#11

When making...

David Weaver

...planes or refitting older ones, I like to think of a word that my dad would've used for someone who talks too much or too loudly.

"mouthy"

"that person is mouthy".

The old woodies that have been cast aside and perhaps put on the market with a wedge that doesn't fit the original plane often make such a loud noise that they can be irritating. It's the sound of bad fitting.

unfortunately, for beginners, some things that are due to bad fit or sharpening, either one, leave the same evidence (skipping, interrupted cuts, etc).

For dealing with beginners year after year, we almost need to name you "Slainte the Saint" or "Saint Slainte".

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#12

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull *LINK*

Sgian Dubh

Ha, ha, Charlie. Yes that hoary old chestnut has been around for a long time. Nice of you to remember it and put up a link. It surprises me how often that old story gets a mention in various places. The link below might be better, because it should be a direct one, which yours doesn't seem to be. Anyway, thanks for reminding people of the story. Slainte.


A Lesson in Sharpening

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#13

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

Charlie

It's such a fun read and so true as well...

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#14

Re: You have provided some useful insights

Charlie

If there's enough doubt that you feel compelled to take a test shaving on something, then you might as well just hone up and remove all doubt.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#15

Re: When making...

Sgian Dubh

'For dealing with beginners year after year, we almost need to name you "Slainte the Saint" or "Saint Slainte".'

Ha, ha. Nice thought, David. The only problem is that it doesn't really rhyme because slainte is pronounced roughly like slanjuh.

I don't have to deal with students very often now: my teaching commitments have rather tapered off over the last five or so years, and most of what I do nowadays is actually building furniture, or rattling out multiples of the same part on regular 3 phase woodworking machines and sometimes the CNC too, or joinery (generally pretty boring lick and stick glue and screw stuff for other people, nearly all undertaken on an hourly self-employed basis - the latest ongoing job (interesting and rather challenging) is hand cutting, matching and laying about 50 m² (~500+ ft²) of walnut veneer on MDF using a bagpress for a large bedroom suite (doors, panels and curved pilasters). A bit of teaching comes in from time to time, but that's about it now.

Still, maybe I've been a bit 'saintly' with learners in the past, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

#16

Re: How do you know whan a plane is dull

TomD

This may have been said, but if you waited till your plane is dull, you have waited too long to touch it up. The key is to have planes that are fast to cycle, and blades that whatever they are, and your sharpening method is, you do not resist the need to turn to the task of sharpening them. If it is all a huge chore, you may well want a metric that lets you know when you have left it too long.

I once published some tests here on how long it took me to remove a plane blade and put it back in and take a first test cut. The plane I used was a Japanese traditional type plane, though as made by me. It was something like 5 or 10 seconds. That is the time to release the blade, re-insert it, and take a measured shaving. It surprised even me. A working shaving of around 1 thou. To get a super finishing shaving, like 4 tens would take about twice the time. I am being honest here, but possibly forgetful. I certainly don't think it took much more than 20 seconds. And I think that it was more like 10. It certainly was nowhere near a minute.

The other thing about the Japanese planes is that nothing in the process hurts. I find Bailey planes often leave me with sore fingers. I can't be alone because some of the new and improved models have replaced the levers with somewhat kinder, sharply knurled knobs.

Two other things about the Japanese planes are that, like most trad wood plane the blade set is actually faster than with all the knob things. People avoid these planes because they think they will have trouble getting the proper operating projection without knobs. It is actually easier with wedges, though conceptually you might be able to find a zero backlash system with a fixed reference to the blade edge that worked quickly. That is not the traditional system on a metal plane.

The other is that the sharpening part of Japanese planes is a bit of a sweat even after 45 years. So I would probably wait till it was too late, if I didn't know better.

-----------------------------

The idea that if dull you waited too late, does not apply to grinding under power, buffing, all that jazz. I can grind the whole 25 degree bevel on a piece of 01 in a few seconds, and without a jig, other than to check. But if we are talking hand sharpening, dull is waiting too long.

--------------------------------

Note:

The Japanese plane mentioned is a single blade unit, which is how I use it, and therefore there is not a sublade to set.

-----------------------

How can you possibly remove and reset a blade in 5 seconds? Starting with the plane in hand and the mallet, you give it a whack, the blade is out and held in your plane hand finger. Separate it from the plane, and then drop it back in. It bottoms out in the tapered slot, a measured tap, while feeling with your fingers, and you can take a shaving. If it is 1 thou ish, you are done. It is basically two taps, or so, between which you have moved your hands apart. Not a biggie.