Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

Posts

Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#1

Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

David Weaver

Due to some kid and work-related time sinks, I have only been making a few pencils per week, but there are two things that really interest me before i get into baking leads (and possibly buying a small used electric kiln to do it).

1) the high end pencils have cedar that's been treated somehow. The difference between their wood and mine is like the difference between oak and mahogany. The wood comes off in lovely clean ribbons - it's subtle, but it's a really nice thing.

2) high end pencils stay straight. My pencils - 1/2 are straight, but the others....this week, we had temperatures that dropped into the very low teens, perhaps single digits. Anything in my shop or office bows .......including my pencils. If I keep them for a couple of months, I could probably offer them in plain or banana on etsy.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#2

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

John in NM

Steam maybe? Well before cutting into pencil blanks I would think. Not sure how steaming stabilizes, but they do it to stabilize European Beech I believe.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#3

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

David Weaver

You're right - I thought of a couple of things (that I may have not remembered properly)

1) the guitar neck philosophy - cut pencils over size, let them move, trim them to final size after a seasonal cycle (then most of the movement will be done). This seems prohibitive in effort!!

2) toss the wood into the attic in the summer after cutting pencil thickness boards out of the large board, but put them under stress in some kind of press. They'll try to move but get stabilized by the heat. Probably won't work.

3) put the boards in a foil container with something sacrificial that will burn before the wood does and bake the wood at 380 degrees F. The burnt combustible item should limit the amount of oxygen in the foil (this is similar to torrefaction in current guitar woods - it works well. I'll bet the smell from incense cedar baking at a temperature where volatiles come out may cost as much as a divorce, though!!

4) oil/wax treatment - soak the wood in oil or wax to stabilize it, inhibiting its ability to transfer moisture from one area to another (or out). This apparently works well (for example, soaking the boards that will later be made into pencils in linseed oil and then letting it dry completely). The possible complication here is that glue strength is compromised (that's mentioned in a document I read about stabilization).

The high temperature thermal treatment seems to be the only guaranteed stabilizer (other than letting wood age a few decades) that will still glue well.

Or, i can just write with pencils that have some bow in them. 8)

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#4

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

John in NM

"Or, i can just write with pencils that have some bow in them. 8)"

I hope you're good at cursive!

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#5

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

rum

I might suggest two alternatives for your consideration.

Cut the coarse blanks then boil for one hour per inch and air dry for ~a week or two~. This is how some turners stabilize some difficult wood for bowls. I can't speak for how it will affect the perception of shavings but it would change them a bit (limited experience says to the better).

Soak the unfinished pencil in polycrylic. This might be a bit antithetical to your natural inclinations, but I've had really good luck with this stuff stabilizing some wood carving blanks. It seems to reduce the fuzzing dramatically, I'm not sure how much it would change deformation but it soaks in really well and plasticizes the top layer of wood (which would be .. a lot.. of the pencil) so I suspect it might well do fairly well at that.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#6

Some narratives that I've read...

David Weaver

...suggest the substance that makes pencils sharpen smoothly (the cedar) and not tear out and remain stable is actually wax.

The challenge then is to figure out how the wax isn't detrimental to the gluing, as one of the summary processes that I found suggested that the wood is treated before it's cut into slabs to house leads (thus before glue).

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#7

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

David Weaver

I'm inclined the try the wax first, but the boiling/steaming sounds like it's worth a try, too.

Whatever is done to the commercial pencils, they're actually more compliant with the blade of the sharpener. I'm hesitant to use a finish that hardens because it'll mutilate pencil sharpener blades.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#8

Another wax reference..

David Weaver

..in a 1978 book about wood selection for veneer, somehow a pencil reference got into the book.

"Dimensional Stability Nearn (49) showed that many heartwood extractives will partially stabilize the ... Pencil manufacturers recognize this advantage and add wax to incense-cedar pencil blanks to improve the whittling properties of the wood."

I'm guessing this is paraffin, so I've got something to try.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#9

Species

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Do you know what species of wood you are using, or where it grew?

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#10

Re: Species

David Weaver

incense cedar, which is the standard for pencils. Not sure where it grew, and i'm sure it's likely that texture is affected based on growth rate, etc, but the wax treatment in the high-dollar pencils goes above and beyond the differences. I didn't think at first that they'd actually be waxed since it lessens glue adhesion, but I guess it's a matter of finding what level of wax stabilizes the wood without interfering too much with the glue.

Not exactly a high stress glue application once the barrel is compressed around the lead.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#11

Re: Species

John in NM

The wax must be carried in with a solvent - easy to control how much wax that way too. Given that the paint sticks to pencils ok, I bet the amount of wax is pretty small and that it won't be much of a problem for glue either.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#12

Re: Species

David Weaver

I'm thinking the same (not much wax and somehow distributed uniformly) - there's no noticeable difference in density or weight of the pencils vs. mine, but the working properties of the wood are different and they definitely don't move with the seasons like mine do.

A couple of my pencils could be used to estimate dew point in the last 24 hours. Only some amount just under 50% actually stay straight. That'd be a high cull rate!!

I haven't gotten far enough in petroski's book if he covers this, but he probably does.

I wonder if Bill could advise on what would be a good inexpensive solvent to transport paraffin into wood.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#13

Re: Species

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Eastern redcedar Juniperus virginiana has a long history of use for pencils as well. Once the most used species. Native to Pennsylvania including Adams County. I think you might give it a try.

There are lots of solvents for wax, including mineral spirits, but it is not difficult to melt it.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#14

Re: Species

David Weaver

Yes on the red cedar. I'd noticed either somewhere on the internet or in petroski's book that red cedar was more common early on (and at one point, we had an entire line of red cedar trees just behind the house where I grew up), but for reasons I can't recall, the standard went from that to incense cedar.

I have stuck with incense because it yields the familiar "pencil smell" when you sharpen a pencil, but will eventually make pencils of other softwoods to see how they turn out.

I'm guessing that it's probably less expensive and more widely available than red cedar.

Thanks for the suggestion of mineral spirits - I'll admit that I haven't looked at all yet, but i'm hoping to get as little wax in the wood as possible on the first couple of attempts, thus solvent delivery rather than soaking in melted paraffin (if I recall correctly, the paraffin melting point is something like 120 degrees F)

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#15

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

Rum

The polycrylic doesn't really "harden" in the same way that say a polyurethane does. Its more of a "soft plastic" or "almost wax" feel. I've used it mostly as a stabilizer for the surface of wood that was giving me fits for light relief carving and have carved through it without any real evidence that it's harder on blades than raw wood (much less hard on blades than some wood for sure anyway hehe but ever compared to pretty easy stuff like butternut).

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#16

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

David Weaver

does it penetrate? I've got a solid coat of french polish on the pencils, but the sharpened end will always give up the moisture. I suspect that's got to be the problem with the bending - the business end drying differentially.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#17

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

Rum

Penetration is moderately good... at least with the ancient can I have stashed under the workbench.. they may well have changed the formulation but not that I've heard.. Saturated on top of a piece I've had it go in maybe 1/8". Not sure what it would do on cedar but I think it should penetrate reasonably well compared to most woods.

I can likely dig up a piece of Western Red to try it on... maybe sunday.,

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#18

Redcedar

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The Textbook of Wood Technology (1949) states:

For example, eastern red cedar (Juniperus virginiana L.) is

the premier pencil wood of the world for a number of reasons, among

others because of its fineness and evenness of texture, and because of its

compactness (body), which is traceable to the quality of its cells (thick-

walled tracheids).

Later it states that incense cedar (Calcocedrus decurrens) was being used for most production because of the scarcity of suitable redcedar material. I think what happened was that as production became more automated it was more of a nuisance to sort through the redcedar which tends to have defects. For someone who is not making pencils by the million, I think the redcedar would be the way to go.

Western red cedar (Thuja plicata) is a very different timber with coarse wood unsuitable for pencils.

Re: Pencil Update - Turned to Bananas

#19

Re: Redcedar

David Weaver

Thanks, Warren. I'll look for some higher quality cedar than what's available at home depot here.