Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

Posts

Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#1

Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

David Weaver

In the world of weirdo woods and guitars, I've been on a buying binge of guitars for the last two years. Until sales tax was added permanently (PA had an option if you didn't record your internet purchase to self-report use tax on a tabular basis), I was able to buy and sell guitars with total fees in the single digits, so I went through an incredible number of them before landing on the dozen or so I wanted to keep to have and to copy.

So, now i'm into building a bunch, which brings you to weirdo woods. Flatsawn cherry actually makes a nice guitar, but it's not traditional, and one thing I'd love to stock would be 18" wide 8/4 quartersawn honduran mahogany, same for sitka spruce, etc. None of those are particularly easy to find.

But, there are two vendors on ebay who have mahogany, and a bunch of other woods that aren't in great demand elsewhere (mahogany is, but not at the price of guitar blanks), and one of those is limba. Over the weekend, I figured I'd join some quartered limba for a guitar body blank - it's much in feel like light weight mahogany, and it has the giant pores like khaya does, and some honduran will have large pores from time to time.

(today, I scored a giant board of this stuff, so this may be the last two piece blank I need to make for a while - one-piece guitar backs are generally more desirable both for looks, and because it's just classier - just as a cabinet made of great old growth wide boards would be).

Holy surprise edge destroyer, though! The wood itself works off in great wide ribbons and has a wonderful sheen. It has ribboning like honduran mahogany, but a look at the first picture if you click up close - it seems like every nth pore is hiding a little chunk of silica. Wood like this is what sent me toward HSS years ago, because it tolerates these bits a little better - but the reality is, setting the cap properly and taking a thicker shaving gets through them easily, and you just suck it up and sharpen when you're done. You can still get a pleasing planed surface without much marking if just before you smooth plane, you vacuum the surface of the board to get most of the silica pieces out. The camera doesn't show this as clearly as it did with the rosewood, but these little bits are actually shiny, and at first, they leave you thinking maybe you laid the board in something contaminated with metal particles.


more and larger pictures in the entire gallery (easier to see the silica in the pores clicking through the surface image).

https://imgur.com/gallery/Gl6N7fw

The silica particles are easier to see in the dark spots on the limba, not so easy to see on the light parts.

There's no particular significance to the plane other than when I got it from England, the dealer had gotten it from a luthier. It was functional, but marginally so. I'm guessing the luthier was using it to rough wood because it wasn't very sharp.


It is, without a doubt, the best working panel plane of any type that I've tried. Just about perfect weight (7 1/2 pounds) for a do-all plane like this, the handle is wonderful and oriented properly and it's dead flat. The casting makes it less sticky on wood than all-steel dovetailed planes.


It's also the cheapest panel plane I ever got - by far, and about half of the cost of something like a lie nielsen plane.

You probably wouldn't use a single plane to dimension things, but this plane is an example of context. It can rough to smooth anything you'd make a guitar with - the billet is never big enough to need anything rougher, and it's only 15 minutes to work over both sides of something like this joined billet and then measure and hand thickness it so that it's within a hundredth anywhere you measure thickness on it. Since a luthier had it before and used it on guitars, then so will I.

I will, at some point, unload nearly all of my infill planes, but this is the panel plane that I will keep.

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#2

spectacular tearout...

David Weaver

the one other thing about limba, sort of like some mahogany, I guess - if you were a beginner, it would seem like a cross between a treat and a curse. It planes easily, but it's uncommon for a quartered board to give you the opportunity to plane downgrain across any significant area.

With the cap set, it planes easily. Without the cap set properly, the tearout can be spectacular and you can really chase your own tail trying to get rid of it. I remember those days. The 50 degree single iron jointer that I liked so much when i first started would just mangle this stuff.

The art of planing and finishing wood is practically dead on the guitar forums. Even many of the instructors will send students through outright stupid regimes trying to avoid tearout in wood like this when all you have to do is set the cap. Anyone employing the oft-advertised "just make it really sharp and take really thin shavings" could turn a 15 minute job with this into several hours chasing the fast dulling blade's inability to continue to cut a thin shaving.

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#3

The significance of limba (korina)

David Weaver

At one point in the past, Gibson screwed around with various woods, trying to keep their supply in order (and probably due partly to budget as they were never really on sound financial footing when they were making their most iconic guitars - an era that stopped in 1968 when they began making adjustments to guitar designs (some due to difficulty in finding good stock, and some probably due to thinking that modernizing techniques - like laminating wood together - would also provide better stability).

Before any of that, one of the woods that they tried was limba (korina), and its early use was in this guitar - the early flying V.

https://reverb.com/item/26820492-gibson-orig-korina-flying-v-58-1964-korina

You can see the price - vintage guitar stores with well-heeled customers will sometimes get closer to half a million dollars for one.

I am too cheap to pay an extra $100 for a given guitar to find white limba (which is just the same wood without the dark markings in it), but gibson eventually claimed that the wood was unstable, prone to cracking and very difficult to work. Compared to most of what we use for cabinet work (other than honduran mahogany), that's not true. I think they just didn't want to use it and couldn't get a good lead on a constant supply. As honduran gets harder to secure in good quality, korina is starting to show up in large boards.

Some of you guys may have been around in 1958. Back in the 1960s, our own George Wilson was an authorized repair person for Gibson, and did work to guitars that got damaged in shops locally. Those days are long gone, but he remembers these guitars coming out. I only ever picked one up once - you can't sit with them and play them and the upper fret access isn't really that great. seemed dumb to me. George said when they came out, you could buy an add on to stick on the guitar or on your lap (can't remember which) so that between you and the guitar, you had a geometric contraption that allowed playing while sitting down.

One of the reasons they're so valuable now is probably because they were a flop.

I will never have anything from the real original gibson company, and that's OK, but the magic of the internet has made it so that really hard to find woods (locally) are now available at relatively little expense as long as one has a mailing address and a mouse.

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#4

Tone wood and aesthetics

Wiley Horne

David,

1. What attributes make a good tone wood? Or do you just know it when you hear it?

2. Were/are guitar woods picked for tone, ease of working, availability, or aesthetics of the finished piece?

Wiley

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#5

Re: Tone wood and aesthetics

David Weaver

These are my opinions....

...warren often talks about woods that are dead vs. woods that are musical. Beech would probably be a terrible tone wood. Maple is not a great tool wood because it transmits vibrations, but it was walked into accidentally because leo fender was cheap, and also because it does make a wonderful violin neck.

For the purpose of electric guitars, though, it was considered unsuitable for a time (that's obviously not true, though).

Stepping aside from that, what makes the various musical woods good, I think, is just a matter of whether or not people can do an A-B comparison of an instrument and like one better than another. In electric guitars, mahogany bodies and necks seem to go better with shorter scale instruments when you want nice mid presence. harder woods like maple do better on a longer scale, and for whatever reason, alder of the same density of mahogany will make an electric guitar that's ever so slightly more punchy and bright and with less mids. The differences are small, but those are all nice sounding woods. Use on the neck of a guitar seems to make the biggest difference.

When you go to the low side of the market, you tend to find things like basswood and paulownia and some types of ash that are fast growing - they make guitars that are decent, but don't sound quite as good. Acoustically (for instruments that don't plug in), they're soft and dead and no good.

The discussion is different types of woods for things like flat top acoustic guitars (generally some kind of harder spruce for picked guitars, softer tops or very hard tops for finger picked guitars - depending on the wants - they're voiced differently) and then back and side wood that does something specific. Mahogany makes for a guitar that's got a more fundamental punchy sound, rosewood makes for an acoustic guitar that's more complex and has more overtones (especially the often referenced brazilian rosewood), and maple (which has become more popular) does something in between. Lots of woods are acceptable or even desirable - bent ash makes for a nice (but ugly) acoustic. Locust makes for a nice sounding guitar (horribly ugly) and cherry can make for a nice acoustic guitar (spruce tops on all of these, just change the sides).

All of them have some musical property when you tap them whereas something like beech sounds like a thud. The lighter cheaper woods sound like a thud, too - they don't have enough conviction to carry much vibration.

Limba is very similar to lighter weight mahogany from what I understand, and because it's actually available, I'm going to give it a shot. It'll probably make a telecaster that doesn't quite sound right, but I have a set of pickups that I want to use that would benefit from an altered scale for the strings and a softer more mid-focused body wood. Even though the effect of body wood is really small. This is a surprisingly contentious thing with guitars, but mostly because there were a lot of makers who way oversold differences to sell guitars to uneducated buyers. The musical quality of a particular type of wood makes a difference, but then the density of the wood for guitars also makes some difference.

Not to go too far afield, but taking advantage of these things or not is also part of bridge design, etc, in guitars. If you want a guitar to sustain a lot and not show too much wood characteristic, you exaggerate what the more dense woods would've done by adding a heavy bridge and in some cases, even a brass block under it (that's no longer fashionable). If you want a guitar that has a lot of sonic decay and has more of a woody sound - more punchy, like an archtop acoustic, then you get a wood that vibrates well and use a light weight bridge to get as much of the string energy to the guitar top itself as posible - much like a cello, violin or banjo bridge - those are more extreme.

If you listen to this guitar, you can hear the initial note is very strong and doesn't last long. Some of that is not just the guitar (but the amp and mix setup), but a lot is the guitar. The bridge is rosewood instead of brass or zinc.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpOaYo4noTQ

I picked this because I have one of these guitars. They're hand carved in china by someone who is an excellent maker, but I ran across one that someone dented on the bottom edge with a guitar cable. They're not that expensive if they're not new and perfect and they're way beyond my skill level to build at this point, so I wanted to have one to look at. They're really loud acoustically if you want them to be because the energy is dumped into a top that is really resonant.

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#6

#2

David Weaver

woods are picked for all of the items you mentioned.

honduran mahogany spoils people just like it does cabinetmakers. aside from tearout on ribboning, it's really tolerant of machines and doesn't suffer large failures.

Gibson tried a whole bunch of things when they decided what would be in a les paul, from lighter wood all the way to attaching strings to a piece of railroad track or an i beam. They tried all maple, but didn't like the way it sounded. They tried all mahogany but thought it was a little bit dark sounding, and tried an in-between, which is mahogany neck and body with a maple cap on top, and thus we have the les paul.

They spent a great deal of uncompensated time doing all of this, paying professional designers and getting the opinions of professional players (other than les paul).

I don't know how leo fender picked what he did. I think alder and maple were inexpensive and tolerable, and cost was more of an issue as he considered parts to be interchangeable and disposable on his guitars. That way, if you wore out the frets on a guitar, you could, in theory, just get another neck rather than pay the expensive cost of someone refretting a guitar by hand. This is sacrilege now, of course. Alder is a pretty good middle-of-the-road wood, as is mid-density ash, so I'm sure that it wasn't just cheapness.

Alder also has little in pores, is tolerant to working with a heavy hand, and takes an automotive paint job well (which is something leo figured people would like - the ability to pick bright colors with automotive paint style finishes - he was right, people liked it).

In the numbers of guitars that gibson was making in the 1950s (like just a couple of hundred burst les pauls, and all the way up to 1968 where gibson was making a les paul custom (actually a production guitar), I read earlier that the last of those "real" ones only numbered 433 that year.

Many fakes and converted guitars are out there! Often being sold or oversold by supposed reputable dealers.

Workability would've been a concern early on with Gibson as they were using power carving machines for tops long before the les paul was ever around, thus hard maple was a good choice because it works well with machines and they liked the sound of it.

I have a feeling they don't like khaya or limba because it's not as tolerant of fast working, and even when they were making guitars as people operating machines (now, it's mostly someone putting guitars in forms to be run over with a CNC), the guy running the carving machine or routing the sides/edges won't like it if he has to change his mindless repetitive task or slow down.

That carries on now. When I made a solid spruce telecaster last year, I was told two things:

* you'll never plane it (it planes wonderfully)

* you'll have problems with splintering and you'll never do it again

It does splinter a little bit more. I don't have a set routine, so it wasn't that hard to work with. Most of the boutique makers now are very precise router and sander users.

you can get kicked off of guitar forums pretty easily if you insist that the dogma doesn't have to be followed and show process in opposition ("that's misleading to people, you're making it out like that's easy and it's a bad message that will lead new builders to failure and you'll be banned if you continue".)

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#7

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

Don Stephan

Would you take a moment to describe a properly set plane iron cap, please.

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#8

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

David Weaver

Try to set the cap as close to the edge as you can visibly see it. Then back it off what seem like as small of an amount as you can. Tap the screw or do it however you'd like. You should be able to see a small sliver of light from the back of the iron when you angle it toward the light just right.

Put it in the plane and take a reasonably heavy smoother shaving. It should straighten up a little bit, and if it does, you're good to go. If it doesn't and you get appreciable tearout, you need to set it a little closer. If it jams, you need to set it a little further from the edge.

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#10

Re: Cap iron set

Steve Voigt

After going round and round on this for years now, I've started to think that most of the folks who've tried--but not yet succeeded--to learn the cap iron are having more problems with tuning than with distance. I've run into a lot of people who say they've set the cap super close, but didn't get the hoped for result. On questioning, it turns out that one of the following applies:

- there's no steeper microbevel on their LN/LV/Hock cap iron.

- the cap iron is too blunt or has a flat on the tip.

- the cap iron doesn't mate with the back of the cutter properly, so shavings jam.

- the mouth is too tight, perhaps combined with an overly large or steep microbevel on the cap, so shavings jam.

I guess this is progress though. We used to fight with people who insisted it was impossible to set the cap close enough to make a difference. That mostly seems to have gone away. Now it seems that folks, like Don in the previous post, just genuinely want to know, and don't bring a lot of preconceptions to the table. I'll take it.

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#11

Easy method I use

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

I was an early skeptic. And a late adopter. It seemed like a lot of hassle. So I offer this simplified method, as a starting point for others who may think double-iron is just too much bother. I am not preaching atcha—I still use and enjoy single iron planes. But I do keep an LN5-1/2, LN4, and Bedrock 605 set-up with double irons.

Anyway. Here is my easy start up method in 4 photos:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157712771326328/with/49420680461/

Photo 1. First, get a board with reversing grain. The photo shows a stick of soft maple from the Borg, which had reversing grain down the whole length. I ran a plane over it and got a bunch of tearout. The photo shows the worst place.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49420215323/in/album-72157712771326328/

Photo 2. This is a quick set-up. Like David, I assume your plane will already take a good shaving. I use a rounded 60-degree bevel on the cap-iron. I wanted about an 8-thou setback on the iron, as a starting point. I took two Post-It notes, each 3-1/2 thou. You don’t have to mic the Post-it—they’re all 3.5-4 thou thick. Anyway, my two Post-its are 7 thou thick. That’s good enough to get started. Stand the blade/capiron pair straight-up on the Post-its, with the screw loosened. Then tap the blade, so it goes thru the post-its, and bottoms out on the benchtop. Then tighten the screw—that’s it.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49420215168/in/album-72157712771326328/

Photo 3. This is what 7-thou looks like.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49420214968/in/album-72157712771326328/

Photo 4. I then planed the tear-out shown in Photo 1. Took 6 or 7 passes to clear the tear-out. The shavings, like the one shown in the plane, were 3.5 thou. But you don’t need to mic shavings—you only want to know if your initial setting is about right. Turns out mine was. So I’m done for now, and will make adjustments like David describes, if trouble crops up on another board.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/49420680461/in/album-72157712771326328/

You also don’t need any particular numerical setback—I use two post-its because that’s the right ballpark for what I do. i just like numbers too, but you don’t need numbers. You just need to start somewhere—this is merely one way to get started.

FWIW,

Wiley

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#12

Re: Easy method I use

Howard Pollack

Very clever! -Howard

Re: Another Edge Killer - Black Limba

#13

Re: Easy method I use

Jonathan Elliott

Thanks Steve and Wiley (and David for your article), these are very succinct and helpful explanations for those of us just starting out.

Jonathan