Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Got saw, modified saw, it works

Posts

Got saw, modified saw, it works

#1

Got saw, modified saw, it works

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The need is to saw these two dead end kerfs that will become a dovetail socket for a drawer divider.

Saw arrived. Saying it is limber understates the saw plate. And the teeth didn't go to the end. So I mowed the end of the saw off. I have used it to cut 3 dovetail sockets on the way to 8 more. It cuts faster than the rip saw I was using and my modified saw end cuts a dead end kerf to my satisfaction. I am satisfied it is good enough for now.

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

#2

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

1. The sawcut on the right looks OK, but the slanted cut on left is showing too much surface ragging for a 22-point saw. The advantage of a fine tooth crosscut saw for this purpose is that that there should be zero ragging of the exit which would be visible from the front of the finished piece. Maybe it’s just the geometry of the teeth when used on the slant, but I suggest trying (a) a very soft touch for the initial defining cut, or else (b) a light but quick cut, to try to get a cleaner result. Let the saw’s weight do the work. If you are of a mind, I will send you a hand-tensioned (and therefore stiffer) saw to use for these projects—email me.

2. If the saw is so floppy that you instantly hate it, here’s something to check. That saw plate is 20 thousandths thick. Check the thickness of the rip dozuki you showed in the very first photo. If they’re the same, then you could likely swap blades, and put the rip saw’s spine on the crosscut saw.

Am serious about sending you a saw—lemme know.

Wiley

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

#3

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

David Weaver

at the start of the cut, if the saw is wobbly, grab the spine, too, and pull it through the cut.

I get the sense that the ragged cut has a lot to do with making a stopped cut, and not the saw's potential.

I couldn't understand exactly what you were saying with your first question (in terms of what the cut would be), but it obviously makes sense now. it's an awkward cut, and I wonder if it might make more sense to mortise out some of the waste at the back of the cut by hand as you're making the cut to free things. Either way, I guess it doesn't matter too much.

Those small saws (as mentioned in my initial suggestion) don't have much conviction as far as stiffness goes until you go upmarket (and you don't want that for what you're doing), thus the spine recommendation. sans spine, it's perfectly acceptable to grab the back of the saw and make it a two handed operation until there's some cut depth. That'll leave a top line that's more crisp (and speed things up). More point and shoot, and less floppy saw plate.

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

#4

A bit more info *LINK*

Wiley Horne

Bill and all,

I’ve made some trial cuts like Bill’s. Pictures at link below. Wanted to see the cut quality for various tpi’s.

The photos below show cuts made with 3 katabas—18tpi, 24tpi, and 13tpi. Fence is 1” high, beveled at 15 degrees. Held saw blade against fence with 2 fingers, as shown in photos. Photos show plan and edge views.

Bill, will send you the 18tpi saw if you’d like. By Heiji.

Link: https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157712668996117/with/49385888452/


Three katabas

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

#5

Re: A bit more info

David Weaver

Wiley, I don't know how far removed you are from the Z and gyochuko saws. They both do wonderful work for the price and will cut a neater line than bills' first try (but that's all about familiarity, not a slight at bill's attempt).

But, they'll never do the fine work that your two saws on the right side did.

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

#6

Re: A bit more info

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

Any saw Bill uses will be pressed manually against the fence, so I believe his gyokucho should do just fine. Gyokuchos are plenty sharp, and the teeth are evenly set because the machine doesn’t make a mistake. Maybe that particular saw has a wide set.....? I’m overreacting a little because I gave encouragement to buy the saw.

Wiley

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

#7

Re: A bit more info

David Weaver

The machine set saws do have a little bit more set, but it's uniform, as you say. You can stone or squash it off, but there's not much there and you can easily go overboard and have a saw that binds.

I think the saw is a good choice, it'll just take two hands.

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

#8

It's prickly

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The teeth are prickly and prone to digging in on the first pull of the saw which pulls out fibers. However, what is shown is the first cut I ever made with it. The saw may be inherently much better than the person running it.

What I like, now that I cut the end off, is the ability to saw what is essentially a stopped saw cut quickly, much more quickly than the saw I previously used. The waste between these saw kerfs will be chiseled away. Then with the aid of a guide block the angled side of the half tail socket will be pared to 14 degrees. Hence, it matters not what this kerf looks like, it goes away and even what is pared gets covered by the dovetail.

I'm hell bent on getting the cases for these pieces together. Finished one today and will glue it tomorrow. Not concerned with fine points now, but will practice with the saw later to see what I can do with it. It will likely be useful for other jobs.

I'll practice

Re: Got saw, modified saw, it works

#9

Re: It's prickly

Wiley Horne

Great to hear it’s working out! Looking forward to the cases.

Wiley