Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

Posts

Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#1

Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

David Weaver

https://imgur.com/gallery/g0seTCV

So, I've been on a tear in the last couple of years buying and selling guitars, pretty much breaking even but trying anything and everything that I might like to build.

I know it will generate some heat when I say this - I've been through about 100 guitars in that time, and have built 5 so far, and am looking to ramp up the build numbers once I get a few household demands out of the way. I'm willing to admit I would much rather do things like make chess pieces and make guitars than any furniture (add in a few tools and pencils).

At any rate, one thing I found is that certain guitars are cheap in japan relative to the US and you can get out from under them when you're done looking at them with no problem, and sometimes make up for a little bit of the losses on others. But, my proxy shipper has gone south and went from using guitar boxes to using boxes that are either too big or too little.

I found this out by getting one guitar in a giant box (which cost a $400 shipping upcharge due to its size) and another in a box that was too short - exactly the length of the guitar. Predictable results. This guitar neck is laminated maple - it must've hit hard. a traditional mahogany les paul would've broken clean (which wouldn't have been any better or worse, but it could've broken less neatly if it did that and continued to take abuse).


finish on these older guitars (1980 or so is when this one was made) in japan was usually polyurethane. I think this may have been salvageable with clear shellac, but I saw an opportunity to have a sheer neck finish. When I dribbled shellac into the finish crack that was left, the line didn't completely disappear and I wasn't look to experiment to be left with a gloss sticky neck finish. Modern repair with this is CA systems, which seems lowbrow - I don't need to sniff it and have no interest in belaboring repair on a guitar that's not not really worth very much.



So, I glued it together, and allowed french polish to fill in any bits of the crack that weren't perfect. Knowing that you can use oil in the process, I figured I'd help cover evidence of the crack by adding a brown stain (better to mismatch a lot than a little) as the oil in the process. I *think* this left behind the pigment, but most of the oil ended up on the surface of the guitar neck and got wiped off.


The result is sublime feeling compared to lacquer or polyurethane and the neck was ready for playing within an hour or two. The fact that stain and poly (oil based) doesn't dry quickly doesn't really matter. I thought there may be adhesion issues, but I could just scrape it off and redo if there were any. There aren't really any, though I did push it a little bit and pull off some of the shellac at the heel when I was adding alcohol and moving around the shellac. Not enough to redo anything, especially on a guitar that essentially had no value at the start.

total repair time including gluing, scraping and refinishing was a little over an hour. Use of the french polish process allowed darkening the neck, and doing the finish work on a bench that wasn't even cleaned off, and left behind a dry neck that you could touch at the end of the process (so I could pick the guitar up, and just set it aside for a couple of hours).




without learning the french polish, who would've known you could even try this, putting shellac and oil stain on the same rag, back and forth.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#2

what might not be clear in this case...

David Weaver

I started with the stain. The neck is laminated maple, so it didn't really soak in that well (and I want it to look older, not perfect) and was blotchy - no problem, I was hoping that it would at like a toner for the shellac.

What I did in this case was not wait for the stain to dry, but instead began adding shellac immediately. Garnet shellac that's not dewaxed. The adhesion of the shellac is surprisingly good (perhaps this is common - I'm experimenting because I have a free guitar to experiment with and at worst, I've been reimbursed for the damage and it can be stripped of parts and thrown away or sold for salvage).

The bit where I got greedy was to try to smooth a very thick layer (for french polish) with alcohol, and thus the resulting light spot at the guitar heel - something I can rebuild and repair easily if it's necessary - I don't think it is).

The finish doesn't look very thick - it's not thick compared to spray lacquer, but it's filling all of the pores and any bits of crack that escaped glue squeeze out. I didn't burnish it shiny because that's what i'm looking to avoid on a guitar - shiny and sticky is no good.

The mrs has me making a large cherry cabinet that will be stained. This process isn't fast like spraying, but the finish feel has a sublime quality and a supremely smooth level feel without having to do anything other than apply it, and if the stain doesn't take evenly, you continue to french polish the area, using the stain as the oil in the process- the result is that the color becomes more even and uniform. If I was worried about hiding all signs of the repair entirely, it would be easy to make the back of the neck darker (that's not important to me).

I'm really delighted with the results, and it satisfies my desire to tinker (i hate brush and padding marks, and especially bits and nibs and orange peel from spraying).

I recognize that others may not be as excited as I am!!

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#3

Re: what might not be clear in this case...

Wiley Horne

David,

You got my attention with the cherry cabinet finish. It would be great if you could show a photo sequence or video of exactly what you’re doing to the cherry. Effect on an offcut would be fine. If it doesn’t take you too far out of your way.....

Have a good Christmas! Everyone!

Wiley

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#4

Laziness..

David Weaver

Hi, Wiley - out of laziness and family time, I haven't put much together further, but I've been experimenting as my spouse isn't going to accept the level of tint with a simple oil stain. At least not on cherry.

My experimentation has gone from applying shellac right over wet stain, not even wiping all of the excess stain off (the french polish evens it out) to applying water based dye, then french polish and still using a different tint of oil stain as the oil for the process (dye too dark in this case to tell if that made any difference). Still worked well (oil directly into the damp dyed surface wouldn't have worked that well).

If I can get my ducks in a row, I'll make a video of polishing the front of one of the door panels.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#5

Bowing to the gods of laziness

David Weaver

I think I'll address this in video rather than trying to describe it. There's a short sequence of pictures here - the camera never shows things quite like I see them. There's probably a little blush of remaining oil on the tops of these, but they are gloss in person. The finish is very thin, but it doesn't look thin.

If they were to be real pieces, they'd get this first, sit for a couple of days to allow the finish to dry completely and get one more quick cycle to address any shrinkage that occurred in drying (resulting in a little bit of grain pattern on the surface of the shrunken finish).

I don't think there will be any converts to this, it's a physical process and stingy on finish and high on effort (each test piece takes about 20 minutes. I didn't make a proper pad, which will be needed for larger pieces - a door panel or cabinet side could probably still be done in 20 minutes with a larger pad). very handy for guitars, though.

https://imgur.com/gallery/hZTY30z

(again, I guess I have to apologize for the anti glare control on the phone camera - it eliminates reflectivity, which would be nice to see here).

Spouse says no to all of these - even without regard to blotch. Three too light, and the last dyed version too dark - she wants to see "no grain" on the finished piece and asked if we could milk paint it instead :( (no way)

A little bit more trying to trick the camera into seeing the glare instead of canceling it. The finish has a wonderful quality of looking very perfect from a distance, but when you get up close to it, it has minor imperfections that give it life. I realize that a lot of people will dispute that, but I've been playing guitar for a long time and the industry went through a period of heavy finishes and heavy buffing to try to make a thick perfect looking surface. It looks sterile to me, like the guitars have been encased in plastic. There are economic reasons in that case - a soft thick finish on guitars (water based or nitro with a lot of plasticizer in it) alleviates some of the skill needed for the buffer who could otherwise ruin a thin finish with one wrong pause on a guitar body.

https://i.imgur.com/D7pob88.jpg


Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#6

Re: Laziness..

Wiley Horne

David,

Let me see if I understand—I’ve never French-polished anything. I hear: the basic process is you have some shellac (Ithink you said not dewaxed), and you have an oil source—in your case the oil source is an oil-based stain product. And you have some kind of a rubber—like a piece of wool. So rather than get some oil and some shellac on the rubber, you are laying on a coat of oil/stain over the work piece, then picking up shellac on the rubber and working it into the oil finish in tight circles??? With plenty of elbow grease. And keep doing that til the surface develops a close-to-the-wood gloss finish. Is that close?

And you experiment with prestaining with another color water-based dye.

Wiley

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#7

Re: Laziness..

David Weaver

That's pretty much it. Apply the shellac right over wet stain or damp water based dye. No adhesion problems with either. Then use oil based stain as the oil for the process.

You can read about a more appropriate process pretty anywhere else (making a proper rubber to apply the shellac and using alcohol when the rubber starts to get dry).

I did use some 4f pumice to make a cake like layer to fill pores at the outset (when the oil based stain has more oil in the process than one would typically introduce intentionally).

No real elbow grease is needed, just circling and a charge of stain for the pad for every two of shellac or so. I skipped any alcohol in favor of a heavy cut of shellac and more oil.

I guess I'm most enamored just with how forgiving the process is right over a damp dyed surface or an oily stained surface, and there's no need for a clean shop as dirt gets rubbed off of the finish.

You can apply more elbow grease at the end if preferable to build a flat surface, but you can carry the leveling quality of the circles prior to that by adjusting the speed that you're moving the rubber. I recall George Wilson mentioning that the process is easier if you allow the rubber to move slow enough to do its job better.

I didn't use a proper rubber for these test pieces, just a scrap from a tshirt. On a larger panel, a harder bigger flatter rubber would probably speed things up and influence flatness better. The tighter and bigger the rubber, the less tendency it will have to reach into pores.

I plan to try this next on a mahogany and rosewood guitar.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#8

Re: Laziness..

Wiley Horne

David,

Great description and very helpful. You’ve convinced me that one can get a pretty good French-polished surface without a lot of hands-on instruction. ‘Forgiving process.’

Can you estimate or put a ballpark on the shellac cut? And also, do you think waxed vs. dewaxed shellac an important choice?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#9

Re: Laziness..

David Weaver

2 to 3 pound cut. I don't think it's critical. A heavier curt may require a little bit more oil when building.

I used shellac that wasn't dewaxed, but I don't think it's critical either way.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#10

Interesting idea David...

John in NM

Never even thought of trying such a thing, but I like the concept. I don't use a lot of shellac, but I could see using this one on cherry or walnut when one has a lot of color variation to even out.

I recently tried out some button lac for refinishing an old beech gunstock I had fixed. Orange button was about the right color, so I figured I'd give it a try. Seems like it dissolved a lot better than dewaxed, and I found it applied differently - seemed a bit more forgiving but it also wouldn't really gloss up the way I've done with dewaxed.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#11

Re: Interesting idea David...

David Weaver

I don't know if it's true or not, but George told me at one point that he's found button lac to hold its gloss better over time even though I've seen references that the gloss is less to start with.

The shellac I used this go around is some old garnet flake that I got from rockler at least a decade ago, probably dewaxed. It was slow to dissolve but ultimately did in about two days. I'm not as quick to throw something like that away despite some guidance online that it should be tossed due to age.

This is going to be the entire finish on my cabinet, so I'm going to go to button lac that I've bought and see how it works. Rockler wants something like $40 per 250g of flakes, and is about 2 miles from me, but that price level is way beyond good taste no matter the coupon offer!

I'm encouraged to use shellac more after touching up two shelves I made for the kids. It was almost effortless.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#12

Re: Bowing to the gods of laziness

Robert Hazelwood

Nice save on that Yamaha. Looks like the way a violin neck is done (left conspicuously lighter than the body and scroll).

I've done a similar finish with padded shellac over linseed oil and was about as surprised and pleased as you are with the results and how forgiving it is. Never thought to use stain, but those results on cherry are pretty impressive.

It's kind of a high-effort finish, and in terms of direct labor you might spend more time on each piece than with the usual methods. But, on the other hand the total elapsed time is very low, since there is only one "coat", and no real drying time. My favorite part is that there is no need for sanding (I have a pretty irrational hatred of sanding...). Finish plane/scrape, burnish, then oil and shellac. I've never done a finish that has a nicer sheen or a nicer feel to the touch.

I'll be interested in your cabinet build. To me this kind of finish requires doing the interior and door panels prior to assembly since there is no hope of getting to inside corners neatly. That can add a lot of logistical challenge. I considered doing this finish for a crib I recently made but ended up using Osmo PolyX gloss since it is easily applied after assembly, and I didn't want to stage 50+ parts for prefinishing. I was impressed by the Osmo, but it is not quite as nice as the shellac over oil.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#13

Re: Bowing to the gods of laziness

Jonathan Elliott

I'm definitely interested in your video David if you are able to get around to it. It sounds like a really interesting and worthy finish and will likely be easier to understand fully seeing it in action. Thanks for sharing your experiences.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#14

Will do...

David Weaver

How long before is the question...but sometime in the next week or two, I'll do it.

Re: Adventure with a Guitar and French Polish

#15

We share the same irks...

David Weaver

I do some sanding on guitar necks and fingerboards. When they're quartered rosewood, sometimes it's easy to get dead nuts on everything using a form with sandpaper in it (as in, fret slots already cut, plane everything close and then true it up completely with a radius guide and sandpaper. I've done otherwise, just plane and scrape, and functionally, it's fine, but I lose a little more fret height when leveling all of the frets)....but there's always a consequence of some dust in the snoot unless you really go bonkers about sanding or fans or, etc, and that's not that practical in my shop in the winter.

Every finish that I've used seems to work well if you take the time to follow the details with it, but some of it is nuisance work if temp, humidity and cleanliness of the area isn't on your side. French polish eliminates all of that. No clean workspace required, temp and humidity affect it a little bit, and the process feels good.

Small bits appear from old texts to have been finished with brush or other application if they are hard to get to with the process, but you're right about the doors - they will need to be done panel first and then assembled. In addition to hating sanding, I hate masking things off. Masking things off to oblivion is ultra popular in the guitar world, but I despise it, so I'll have to figure something out, like application of padded shellac without rubbing out on surfaces that aren't flat, brushing in small details (like beads) and polish on flat surfaces.

Once I can get back to guitars, there will be less challenge because they don't really have much for inside surfaces that you can't get a rubber on.