Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

Posts

Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#1

Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi All -

It's been a VERY long time since my last post, and I could use some help from the community. I've pulled out my Stanley #80 for a project. I acquired it at a flea market a while ago but I've not used it before - and now I've got three symptoms for whatever my problem is: (1) it chatters no matter how little or how much I tighten the screw, or in what direction I push it (2) it's producing dust, not shavings, and (3) the dust is collecting behind the blade.

So what I have I done - in addition to watching half a dozen YouTube videos on sharpening and using a Stanley 80? I've flattened the back to a mirror polish. I've put a 45 bevel on it also sharpened that to a mirror polish as well. I've positioned the side of the blade without the bevel to point in the direction that I'm scraping. And I've flattened the bed of the scraper.

What am I, or have I done wrong or omitted?

Any help would be appreciated.

Dave

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#2

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Dave, I believe that the problem lies with the blade preparation. Simply, this scraper needs a hook on the blade, and it appears that you have only honed the edge ala a plane blade. The chatter is caused by its "dullness".

Generally, the bevel edge is 45 degrees (Some prefer even steeper). From the bevel side, gently roll a 5 degree burr/hook, and then roll a 10 degree hook. I prefer to do this in two sections (5, then 10 degrees) rather than one (straight to 10 degrees) as the steel is less likely to fracture and the hook will be stronger.

Heavy pressure when turning the hook will create a large cutting edge, which is increasingly fragile as it gets larger. It does make larger shavings. I always prefer a finer hook - less pressure - as this offers more control.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#3

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, Derek. I'll give the burr/hook a try. Appreciate the feedback.

Dave

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#4

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I attended a seminar by Paul Hamler. He might be called the scraper Guru. He put the most durable edge on a scraper I have ever seen demonstrated and it was quick to establish this edge with just a file and burnisher. Shavings rolled off like a hand plane and it kept going for more than 1/8" depth of material removal. He has a video that is comprehensive.

A scraper with just a bevel will roll off shavings. Derek himself demonstrated this fact with a plane blade or something similar. In spite of your best efforts I think your scraper blade was simply dull.

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#5

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

AlanWS

Two other things to consider are the tensioning screw, and using the blade hand-held to understand how it cuts.

Rather than by bedding perfectly, a scraper blade gets some rigidity by being curved. Tightening the tension screw behind the center of the blade serves the same purpose as your thumbs in a hand-held scraper: curving the blade to stiffen it, and focusing your scraping on a narrower path. These will help to avoid chatter. It takes a finer touch to get it to work well with less curvature, so it may be helpful to get it working with significant tension first, and to gradually back off if you want a flatter surface.

The other thing I find helpful when sharpening any scraper blade is to try it on wood without the plane. This gives me a lot more feedback on how it is cutting, and I can easily adjust the attack angle as I go, to find where it works best. Some scraper planes allow you to vary that angle, so this allows you to select a good place to start before fine tuning. With a Stanley 80, I would check to see that the angle where the blade works well is close to that enforced by the plane. If not, try changing the sharpening procedure as Derek suggested.

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#6

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

Don Stephan

Your explanation has helped me much better understand scraper planes. Thank you.

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#7

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

Bill White

Don't forget the fact that a very heavy cut is a no-no. 45 degree, burr, light cut with a slight bow in the iron......you're I business.

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#8

Thank you all!

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Sorry for the delay getting back to you all. I was away this weekend spending time with a couple of our college kids before they hit finals and papers due.

I burnished the blade and messed around with both the blade and the plane some and when I tried next I got nice shavings. I'm inclined to chalk it up to burnishing the blade, but there could have been (easily) some user error involved, as well..

In any case, it's working fine now and I'm quite pleased. Thank you all for your comments and helpful suggestions. Now I can pick back up where I was on the project.

Dave

Re: Troubleshooting a Stanley #80

#9

Re: Thank you all!

Joe Rogers North East West Virginia

Way to stay in the game Dave. Good to see you post!

Joe