Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

Posts

Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#1

Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

David Weaver

So, my graphite came in the mail saturday. before I start to mix it and try making leads, I thought I'd also ask if anyone here has a thing for clutch pencil leads beyond just putting them in clutch pencils.

Staedtler is kind of the standard as far as I can find (widely distributed, decent quality). Is there anything reasonably priced that's better?

Reasonable in the context of clutch leads is about 50 cents each.

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#2

Koh-I-Noor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These leads come in various hardness. I stocked up on 2B. They mark wood substantially darker than standard drafting leads at HB.

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#3

Re: Koh-I-Noor (must've gone overseas)

David Weaver

I've noticed in my accumulation of items along the way here:

* staedtler still has their stuff german marked

* blackwing pencils are marked japan (I think they were US made when they became famous, but the japanese versions acquit themselves very well - but they are expensive).

* another brand that's well thought of has become very inexpensive, and after I received them, I saw why (Tombow) - the package is written in japanese, but clearly marked on them is "made in vietnam". Great pencils

Waiting on mitsubishi hi-uni and a set of all hardness pencils (the latter for my daughter, who is taking an interest in drawing). Not sure where they'll be made.

The implication with staedtler and blackwing is that you're just not going to find them being cleared out anywhere - they're not made somewhere for $1 per dozen leaving tons of room for everyone else trying to make a check on them along the distribution channel.

If I were in japan, I'd buy the tombows at $4 a dozen - they're wonderful writing pencils, and for someone who likes to draw, they mark extremely well, are smooth and with strong points.

I spent 15 minutes yesterday looking for someone clearing out staedtler leads, and no real luck ($6-$7 per 12 is about as good as you can find unless you're willing to pick the hardness that's cheapest - HB is sometimes available for a dollar less). The vintage leads floating around on ebay are generally H and harder if they're there in quantity (knowing nothing about drafting, I'm guessing there is some preference for hard slow-wearing leads).

Fast forward to this morning, I found Koh-i-noor leads on ebay, and managed to get 96 leads for $25 shipped (from a distributor in russia). I'm guessing they must've gone overseas. Leads aren't rocket science from what i've read - more acquiring materials of the right spec and following process - so I'm assuming they'll be good.

In the case of someone like me making pencils, if the leads are good, I don't care where they're made.

Not that this seems to be anything new - we see it in tools, kitchen goods, etc, across the board, and tombow's pencils kind of match my recent experience with second and third world produced mid-grade tools. They're getting to be really good for the money (just watch out for the retailers who charge for the uneducated customer. The tombow 8900 pencils are available at an art store here individually for $2 each, probably 6-8 times the street price in japan).

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#4

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I prefer the 2mm metal-bodied Caran d'Ache Fixpencil 22. These have become something of a cult as it was the daddy of clutch pencils.

The lead is sharpened with a Gedess Lead Pointer, which I believe once won an award for design in the 1930s. The one I have dates to the 1950s. Insert the pencil and swivel it around the abrasive stone inside.


However, I now mostly use a 0.5mm Zebra Delguard with its own brand lead ...


These simply do not break, and the thin lead does not need to be sharpened.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#5

Drafting...

John in NM

There was a preference for hard lead in drafting, I have tons of 2H through 6H pencils and leads. The reason wasn't long wearing, it was easy correction. Light lines until everything is right, then 2H for relatively dark lines followed by a clean overlay in ink. I still have many Kohinoor pens as well. Drafting maps on the side helped get me through college :D Even in the late 1980's early 1990's it was still cheaper to pay a student than a computer draftsman.

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#6

For use vs. for making

David Weaver

I get the preference for the zebra (and almost fortunately, staples carries Zebra brand here...

.....unfortunately, they don't carry that pencil). I like a 0.5MM pencil in the shop and have gotten by with some decent versions.

I need 2mm leads in this case, though, to make pencils. So far, the leads aren't as good for writing and drawing as what you'd find in a blackwing or tombow, but there may be some adulteration that I can do to correct that (soaking in melted beeswax, for example).

I'm looking to make the pencils and, just like one would do making a plane (if they're serious), really nail all of the little details that make a blackwing pearl so special. The feel of the finish on the barrel, the feel of the lead, its ability to take a point and hold it, but still write more smoothly than anything else.

The pencils as they are right now are a delight to use. The staedtler leads are strong, good quality, and in 2b, write fairly dark (their HBs are a bit hard/harsh).

Still thinking about erasers, too, and may not install any (tombow monos and hi-unis have no erasers, and both are supposedly wonderful -I have some of the monos, and am waiting on the hi-unis).

So, yes, I agree that an ideal mechanical pencil is probably all that's needed for fine woodworking (other than rough marking of boards), but this is more about the making for now. I won't be using these in the shop for the most part. The kids loot my marking drawer in the bench because they like to draw in the shop.

(the black version of the blackwing pencils, which must be 4B or something, makes for the finest rough marking pencil I've ever used - but at the price, it doesn't feel like a consumable)

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#7

Re: Drafting...

David Weaver

Thanks for the clarification, John. Erasing makes sense.

I'd imagine the "no 2" (HB) pencil requirement for bubble sheet tests now is something that most people have never thought about much.

I couldn't quite understand why a 2B pencil wouldn't be better as it marks easier, and then read that when people take tests with softer lead, sometimes the erasing isn't as complete to the scanner.

I wonder if writers have the same goofy type of debates that we do about sharpening stones when they talk about lead hardness. The three levels of hardness provided in the blackwing common pencils (which seem to me like HB, 2B and 4B or thereabouts) kind of cover anything anyone would want to use for writing. 4B is a wonderful exercise in laziness, but sharpness of the pencil point is very transient, HB doesn't satisfy my laziness, and 2B seems about right.

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#8

Re: For use vs. for making

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, what you are doing takes my breathe away. My offerings of what I use are really just a reminder to other mortals that there are pencils for purchase that work well.

The downside to ALL pencils and lead holders is that the pointy end rounds off, and this leads to inaccurate markings. Sharpening is one of those habits that is suited to someone less lazy, or less hyperfocussed on the task, that I. The 0.5mm lead is so fine that it essentially never needs sharpening to produce a fine line. The problem in the past has been that these blasted fine leads generally break after one or two strokes, and usually in the middle of a line. The Zebra Delguard is the first (and perhaps only) make that does not break. In part, the design of this propelling pencil is such that it has a shock absorber for the lead. In part, the lead itself appears stronger, less brittle.

Keep going with your work. It is fascinating!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Clutch Pencil Leads - Better than Staedtler?

#9

Have you tried...

John in NM

A Uniball Kuru Toga? They have a similarly springy mechanism that is designed to use the up and down spring motion to rotate the lead a bit each time. I like them for general drawing, don't recall the lead breaking ever. For shop use I stick to Ticonderogas for various reasons, but I'm still a sucker for mechanical pencils (have been since I had a red Scripto 1.1.mm in the 4th grade :D )