Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

Posts

carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#1

carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

Jeremy Osner

What are the differences in construction between a carpenter's/firmer gouge and a carving gouge of similar width and sweep? I guess a firmer gouge is roughly a #5 or #7 sweep?

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#2

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

david weaver

There are hooped heavy gouges for firmer type work and timberframing.

They're more or less made with a thicker cross section and stronger bolster to be tolerant of being hit. Think bulk work vs. fine work.

You can mallet carving tools, but not like the type you'd do running around a job site.

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#4

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

David Bassett

Uh, Swiss or London Pattern #5? Which manufacturer's implementation? (They seem to vary, even when "standardized".) Also, I can't find any reference defining #5 sweep (at least one Google has indexed under obvious key words), just charts showing different profiles.

I'm recalling Mary May's answer when a student ask what to do when a carving pattern didn't match the gouges they owned. She (basically) said scale the pattern up / down until it matches the bulk of your gouges and then use the closest gouge you have for each cut and modify the pattern to match. What are you doing that exactly requires a #5/10 gouge?

PS- I'm pretty sure I'd use the tool you have.

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#5

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

Wiley Horne

Firmer vs. non-firmer won’t change the profile. One thing to be aware of, and it may not matter for your task, is that an English #5 is the same sweep as a continental Europe #6. Or the other way around, a continental (Two Cherries for example) #5 is the same sweep as an English #4. Again, this distinction may not matter for your task.

Wiley

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#6

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

Jeremy Osner

Sounds good, thanks -- I was thinking I could probably use this gouge, sounds like I was on the right path...

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#7

Firmer gouge vs carving gouge

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Firmer gouges are much heavier in cross section and are designed for rough removal of material. If the width and curvature are important, you want a carving gouge.

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#8

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

John Aniano in Central NJ

Jeremy,

I learned this from Warren years ago when I asked a similar question: the sides of firmer gouges are parallel and the sides of carving gouges taper from wide at the edge to narrow near the bolster and tang.

In addition, this seems to hold true for straight firmer and carving chisels. Thus a number 1 sweep carving chisel (flat) has tapered sides and a similar width firmer chisel would have parallel sides.

John

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#9

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

Jeremy Osner

Interesting -- so a "straight" carver's gouge is slightly fishtail?

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#10

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Jeremy,

All traditional carving tools (well most...) are slightly fishtail in overall pattern. Not a true fishtail, which is more extreme and has the fishtail taper at the very front end of the cutting tool.

Note that the wonderful carvings done by Peter Follansbee are done with a mix of true carving tools and carpenter's firmer gouges. Peter doesn't seem to prefer one over the other - he seems to be more interested in the sweep and width since many of his patterns are derived solely from these two parameters. He's using both mallet and hand driving to do his work.

John


https://pfollansbee.wordpress.com

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#11

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

Charlie

https://grabovetskiy.com/school/

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#12

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

Charlie

https://www.grabovetskiy.com/portfolio-custom-wood-carving/

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#13

A few notes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A firmer gouge looks like a firmer chisel that has had its blade curved. It still has those flat side edges and is almost 1/8 thick.

Besides being much thinner, a carving chisel has rounded or tapered edges. In addition the corners are sometimes doctored in ways that would be difficult to describe. The result is that a carving gouge has much better clearance and is much more nimble.

Firmer gouges are usually sold in a limited number of sizes, and all have similar curvature. They are used with a mallet for roughing out mouldings and other rough work. Carving gouges are used both with a mallet and without a mallet.

Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#14

Thanks for a definition that makes sense.


Re: carpenter's gouge vs carving gouge

#15

Simpler still...

Jim Matthews

Carving gouges are the ones I break.