Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

When you list an infill plane..

Posts

When you list an infill plane..

#1

When you list an infill plane..

david weaver

....make double what you paid for it, and Jim Bode is the ebay buyer who bought the plane, what does that suggest?

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#2

Re: When you list an infill plane..

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Someone could have set the price a tad higher?

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#3

Re: When you list an infill plane..

david weaver

I'd imagine that Jim will !!

I reconditioned the plane after buying it (it was a spiers infill with a half-used ward iron), so that's the secret about how it doubled in value.

The person who listed it in England also made the mistake of making the main picture the logo on the ward iron, so it looked only like an iron for sale. They probably wondered why it didn't sell, but for all I know, they also may have gotten it from a little old lady for 10 pounds.

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#4

Re: When you list an infill plane..

Jim Matthews

Do these prized planes ever see lumber?

There seems an inverse relationship between prices paid, and frequency of use.

The BCTW tool shaped objets d'arte are more valuable if still sealed.

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#5

Re: When you list an infill plane..

David Weaver

Mine are all older and only one was expensive (a 15 1/2 inch a13). The only ones that haven't had their soles heated up in a brisk session are the couple that haven't been set up yet.

Avg cost is probably about LN price, only that high due to the a13.

I try to buy them from English listings so they're cheaper.

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#6

Re: When you list an infill plane..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Jim, it is relative. A Holtey for one is a LN for another. But that is with regard to those who use their tools to make things. There is another group who like collecting tools for display, and the tools here could be anything, from BCTW to a full set of random (low value) Stanley Bailey planes.

I often get comments (about the tools I build) that run along the lines, "I would be scared to use that if it was mine". I say, why build ugly? - build them gorgeous and enjoy using them.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#7

I do have some prized tools

Jim Matthews

I have a single iron Jack from a former Williamsburg tool maker and a deft "block" plane with an insert forged from drop bear hide - simple treasures.

I certainly understand the appeal of USING beautifully made things.

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#8

The plane in question

David Weaver


Years ago when I was feeling around for what kind of tools I wanted to use, I considered buying one really nice premium infill and using it all the time.

Then I got into planemaking and bought a bunch because I want to make them (still do, but they're backed up behind guitars right now - i've made a couple, but would like to build perhaps 20).

The plane above was $127 from the UK. It had pitting on the sides but the cap iron is matching. It's been used. I draw filed the pitting off and flushed the wood to the metal and filled in any gaps that had appeared with sawdust and shellac or sawdust and epoxy or something, I can't remember). It didn't take more than two hours total for it to look like it does in this picture. It is a surprisingly GREAT user, but with a quirk. Tensioning the lever cap leads to a little bit more cut depth, so a user needs to learn its personality so that you can set it shy of what you want and tighten the lever cap and use it as a light adjustment.

I have a slater infill (less valuable) that has a wedge and a retaining pin/brass fixture integral with the pin. It's fine to use - in the trade of relieving the shelves of some weight, it wins the contest to stay because I want at least some of the builds in the future to be wedged infills.

I'm in the middle of dimensioning a bunch of wood for a large case, and this is a nice reminder that I have the chance to get these out post-jack work. When you get them waxed up and set the cut to something thicker than tissue, they're really a treat to use.

I don't have the BCTW stuff, anything from any premium maker (well, not counting norris) or anything I'd be afraid to drop in the shop. I like something a little interesting while dimensioning, so even my bailey jointers are an older record 8 and an I. Sorby.

I got a marples 4 1/2 this week (red one) from the UK. It's fun play. The two jointers cost me a lot of money for that type of plane ($500 together), but most of the rest of the stuff is pretty easy to buy and unload without losing much. It's harder for me to find something like this spiers (where it was listed poorly with poor pictures and I knew I could at the very worst rob the iron from it and put it in a norris. Turns out to be a much better plane than I expected. I hope it doesn't get marked up too much and the next person gets a chance to heat the sole up on it).

I just looked at my two A13s (I have a complete beater of a smoother A13 to go along with the expensive panel plane - one of only two planes I've ever bought that was close to $1000 - the panel plane that is ,the smoother was $200). They both have light surface rust on them - very light, but it's a reminder why I don't buy nicer planes. I can't have them upstairs in my house, my basement is dry, but we still have transition here before the A/C is running much that a couple of humid days will make for some light surface rust.

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#9

About guys like bode..

David Weaver

when jim bode first showed up, I wasn't a fan. I've bought a couple of things off of him since then, but nothing significant (ward chisels - sometimes he has something good for a user without it being a $125 paring chisel).

He's come back toward the market a lot since then in terms of prices on many things.

But the thing is, he can build a customer list and sometimes that's even good for someone like me. That reconditioned spiers was $250. The infill fad is sort of over for anything but custom orders, though that doesn't always show on ebay. But the days of common norris planes being $500+ in unrestored shape is over. I remember a user on woodnet who bought gobs of older planes, and he's probably out a lot for it. It was 3 digit or 4 digits in the number of planes that he had.

So, the result is, I can list a plane like this on ebay at $250, which I did, and it will sit at that for a month. Nobody knows who I am, and who I am isn't that important - I'm a nobody - but when I sell a working plane, it means working, not marginal. If someone buys a plane, they tend to buy the next couple I post.

What Jim can do, though, is probably get close to twice what I can for this plane and if he can't, he probably has somewhere in his inventory an $800 norris no 2 that's just missing a ward iron. This plane probably loses less value, swap the irons, do whatever.

I don't have that customer list.

When I was younger, I had a valuable guitar - a jem 10th. I'm older now and I don't like that kind of ripper guitar, but it was a nice guitar. I played it a lot. They were $1999 new. They can touch 5 figures now if they're unplayed and $5K even with playwear, more from the right dealer.

When I went to sell my guitar in the early 2000s, I had it listed all over the place for $2950 - used. I had tire kickers from all over the place, but nobody really wanted to buy. All of them complained loudly about a dealer from a place who sold only jems. He must've had a dandy of a customer list, because he ended up buying the guitar, paying to ship me packing and packing materials, he said he didn't have one of the type in stock (they were a limited run) and he likes to have one of everything, so he'd list it high "Because that's what you do when you only have one". I sent it to him, he gave me some grief about it having more playwear than expected (I think that was just part of his gimmick, I didn't deceive on the description), he said "thanks, you're the first person who ever actually packed the guitar the way I asked", he listed it for $4950 and it sold before the end of the day.

(to this day, I've had about 100 guitars - that's the only one that ever sold for more used than new. This is the only infill that I've had that sold for double what I paid, too, I guess -strange that in both cases, the items went to dealers to be resold).

I just don't have the personality to try to start reconditioning these planes, doubling the prices and curating a list of customers willing to pay. That curated list is the key if someone wants to make money. and I've never had an issue with anything that I've gotten from bode, though I've had a lot of problems with auction lots from MJD.

I'll bet over the years, I've lost $50k on tools, guitars and stones. It's part of the process. I'm a lot better at breaking even now, but the hobby is pretty cheap compared to some.

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#10

Priceless Bode quote

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

He was unpackaging boxes at a MCTC event from an estate he bought in FL. I was chatting with him about stuff when he began unpacking a box with countless scrapers. After about the 10th he remarked mostly to himself,

"I deconstruct the compulsive obsessive".

I found him to be a nice person. Someone (not a dealer) unpacked a Norris for sale for some price I don't remember, maybe $200. I always wanted to try one but knew nothing about them. Jim was nearby and I took the plane over to him and asked him about it. He examined it, declared it to be in good shape and told me what he paid for them, which was $25 more than the person was asking. I thought that was kind from a dealer of his stature.

I bought it, didn't do anything for my pedestrian planing and sold it to my ride to this event.

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#11

What's changed...

David Weaver

My understanding of it. When bode came into the business of selling, he'd come from the car business, at least that's my understanding. Could be rumor.

What's not, though, was the decorum among other sellers and collectors. I remember walt quadrato saying that at auctions, nobody tried to take everything as a matter of deference, but bode sort of took everything if he got to it first, and at the time, his prices were excessive to say the least. He's come back to earth. Walt never mentioned that it was bode, but we knew who he was talking about.

Shortly after, an infill collector died in England and we expected to see reasonable prices in the us, but bode flew over and bought the stuff. While I can find a Norris 2 or something similar from time to time for 200 pounds, once Jim gets something like that, the market only sees it again at 3 times that.

I decided I'd just start to build what I want, instead and buy if something shows up reasonable elsewhere. If not, no big deal.

Re: When you list an infill plane..

#12

Curious about the time lag..

david weaver

..I don't normally go to bode's page to look for tools (though his unmarked tools and other tools a little off the beaten path - e.g., unmarked slater infills, etc - they're reasonable now, whereas they used to not be).

He adds tools each day, but I'm guessing like a blog writer, he's got a backlog of tools so that he can remain consistent and satisfy people who come to the page each day to see new tools.

He won't need to do much or anything to the plane that I sold - an enterprising individual might pad a light coat of shellac on the wood to spice it up. It'll be interesting to see how long it takes for the plane to land on the new tools feed.