I may have jumped the gun about the durability of the xhp iron in the rosewood neck blank.
This is the side of the peghead planed flat. If you enlarge the pictures and look at the pores, you can see that it's loaded with silica. No plane iron will tolerate a lot of this, but you can, of course, just sharpen more
Sure enough, when I blew up your pictures it was obviously silica crystals
At "lower magnification" the wood pores Look just like the SEM pictures from a K&K paper where one of the test specimens was loaded with silica. The solution to dealing with silica is to use a steel that contains carbides harder than silica. K&K found these steels deficient in other ways.
The moral of this story is if you are going to use 18th century tools you need to use 18th century wood On a more serious note, how did they deal with these abrasive woods back then?
I went the chinese steel route years ago to deal with cocobolo that was a lot worse than this rosewood (though the neck blank in this photo is pretty bad. It's like that end to end and through the entire thickness. You can't see the silica as well in person because the zoom and resolution brings it to a much more visible state. You just see the evidence of it in an iron that seems as if it's just coming apart too fast.
Since then, I've learned it's a whole lot more productive to change nothing, learn an efficient sharpening method and just work through it. But there will be no off-the-plane finish with this (there wouldn't be on a guitar neck, anyway).
It wears the burr off of a card scraper pretty quickly, too.
The other key points back to the cap iron - let it do its thing and set the shaving thickness up to minimize the number of passes.
The pernambuco and swartzia species I use for bows is supposed to be loaded with silica. Most bow makers deal with the squirrelly grain, the hardness of the wood and the silica inclusions by using a scraping tool (plane) with a high angle and high bevel angle. Up to 90 degrees for the former and a bevel angle around 45-60 degrees. It doesn't really toughen the edge of course, silica will still nick the edge, it just does it less in a blade bevel with more meat in it. So it lasts longer between sharpening.
Since the japanese planes are always fighting a very tight battle between bevel angle and clearance, this is, of course, something they suffer with.
And the fact that you're usually sharpening a large bevel by hand and trying to be precise makes it extra aggravating (my lazy man's sharpening method makes it no big deal - perhaps an extra 4 mintues of sharpening on a guitar neck like this one, sawn and roughed from a billet vs. a more agreeable wood, and then one follow-up sharpening to be fresh for nicer wood). At any rate, odate's advice for poorly behaved irons or planing teak is pretty much the same - add a bunch of back bevel to increase the edge cross section and limit the damage that occurs.
I do have a small thickness planer and could easily run one of these through, but I'd feel cheated. There are some things I can't do neatly by hand on these guitars (or not neatly enough within a reasonable amount of time), but maybe I'll solve that over time. The sawing and planing of the rosewood is really enjoyable.
It doesn't take an accomplished woodworker or craftsman to make a good one, either. More sanding and power router work on guitars than I do anywhere else in five years, though.
Yes - this is probably the third sample of wood that I've used like this (the particles sparkle making you think that perhaps some metallic dust is floating around and on the bottom of the plane).
The first sample of wood that i got like this was cocobolo and it was several multiples worse. You'd get a few good plane strokes from it and that was it before you were just smashing away at the wood.
That was the first piece of cocobolo I ever thicknessed with a plane, so I thought cocobolo was all like that. I've never had anything as bad since, but I'm sure that there are instances where wood has had a chance to pick up much more silica (and like the cocobolo billet I had - it just sparkles at you when it's completely loaded - it doesn't just look like it's sitting in the pores, it's clinging to everything in the wood, pores or not - but different type of wood, maybe it's deposited differently).
This is also the first piece of indian rosewood that I can recall having this kind of visible contamination. Indian rosewood is usually an absolute treat to work with hand tools. This wood is just the same (very pleasant) other than the silica - it comes off in nice smooth dark shavings. Like mahogany or teak, the fact that it planes so easily makes it a surprise if you don't look closely to see why the shavings start splitting fairly soon. My first reaction was that my iron wasn't that great.
I wouldn't want to make anything of any size with cocobolo as described above, but this rosewood is a very minor inconvenience. I took a picture of it because once in a while I mention my first experience with cocobolo and receive an accusation or two that no such thing really occurs and that it's just exaggeration.