Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

More iron testing...

Posts

More iron testing...

#1

More iron testing...

david weaver

...before writing a final report. Hopefully my failing old computer is up to a few more pictures.

Over the weekend, I was planing a fingerboard blank for a guitar, after planing the neck out of the same billet. The neck is indian rosewood, which can be a little bit variable (but usually I find it just to be entirely agreeable).

I have the worst of the XHP irons that I've made in my smoother - a third one that I made where I held it in the heat far too long trying to chase temperature and I think it's no longer homogeneous. At any rate, this iron works well in regular hardwoods, it's abrasion resistant, but it was trashed by the rosewood in relatively short order. Not so short that it was unusable, but the behavior was different.

When I posted the results of the initial testing on here, one of the things that I noticed via email was about half a dozen or so independent questioners wondering if the iron would be a good "supersteel for bad wood". I really don't know the answer to that. The cheap chinese irons are good for that ,but V11/XHP do well in good wood without contaminants. In the original testing in maple, once something ugly shows up in wood, toughness comes into play and though it abrades carbon steel, there's less damage.

That leaves me no real choice at this point other than to make another neck out of rosewood (I have a twin of the blank) and plane it to thickness with the commercial V11 iron vs. house O1.

I've sent irons to wiley and steve. I'm not ever going to make irons for sale, so it's not a matter of touting anything, but they may find that my irons are subpar if they're pushed!!

I suppose I'll do a job of making a proper one for my smoother. I don't really notice the same failings in the jointer that did most of the work, but there will be people who read my final study document who instantly conclude they should buy an XHP/V11 iron when they want to plane sand, and I don't think it'll handle that well.

We shall see.

It's still my choice now for clean medium hardwoods, but lower toughness irons may also be dependent on those ideal test conditions (uncontaminated uniform wood without interrupted cuts) to really excel.

Re: More iron testing...

#2

toughness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Toughness data are readily available in the steel literature. By the technical measure of toughness XHP is not lacking and in fact is superior to any other metal you have tested, except 3V. Either what you are calling "toughness" is some other property or toughness is not the cause of the defect you are experiencing.

Re: More iron testing...

#3

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If by "bad wood" you mean abrasive wood, the turners have answered this question as did Kato and Kawai. Add more hard carbides to the steel. Vanadium and tungsten carbide will cut silica crystals deposited in wood. You already know what silica will do the carbon steel- sharpen it. If you can sharpen your XHP with an ARK stone you know what silica crystals will do to the edge.

Re: More iron testing...

#4

Re: PS

david weaver

Toughness is measured how, and is it always the same at 33 degrees at a tiny edge as it is on a 90 degree edge of a die?

Silica, yes. What I'm getting toward is that you mention toughness being better presumably than O1, but in maple, the two carbon steel irons took much less damage from the inclusions.

Is it silica causing the problem in rosewood? I don't know. There's no iron, no matter how much vanadium is added, that holds up well when there are little silica particles. Some holds up better than others, but the damage is nicking and not abrasion. Those green chinese blades do OK, but I've learned over the years that in really difficult wood, giving in to sharpening more often is generally far more productive. Increase the shaving thickness, set the cap, get most of the work done and use a fresh iron to do the final few passes.

Sometimes changing the method is better than changing the tools.

Fairly large chance that part of the issue here is the iron that I kept for myself (because I didn't like the way it looked after heating it too long - a good lesson learned, as it confirms that for household heat treating, get it hot and fast as quick as possible, then quench. Don't chase a little bit of extra brightness in the color hoping for additional hardness).

I could go down a rabbit hole here discussing what's preferable, but a test of O1 vs. the commercial V11 on some of this rosewood (hopefully the second billet is identical to the first) will settle it.

Re: More iron testing...

#5

Re: PS

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Toughness is sacrificed in pursuit of hardness. Tools that are more tempered will be tougher.

Re: More iron testing...

#6

Re: PS

david weaver

Yes, that's true, but there is a working range where some hardness will yield longevity. The chipout that I'm talking about isn't a matter of chips breaking off in an undesirable way (like would occur on an overhard tool), it's a punch out of a notch from silica particles.

It happens at any hardness, vs. overhard tools that will release the small chips even in good material.

The hardness of the iron that i'm using in rosewood here is not that high. its probably about 60. what I haven't compared is the same O1 iron that i used in testing, which is a bit above that, but shows very good toughness in particles that are probably similar composition (in the maple), but concentrated in a spot.

The overall issue here, away from the toughness issue (that's one where chart toughness, at least in my experience, doesn't always translate to performance in wood in every case), is whether or not the longevity relationship holds in less than ideal materials that don't immediately demolish an edge. I thicknessed and smoothed the guitar and fingerboard blanks without any real issue other than noticing that in this particular blank, the appearance of small lines occurred pretty quickly. By the time the iron saw the stone again there were a lot of small lines.

I will probably write no matter what in my report that searching for a tougher iron to plane bad material really isn't a good plan. I went down that road first, and found a change in practice (rather than a change in the plane iron) far more beneficial.

Re: More iron testing...

#7

That could've been less opaque

david weaver

Hardness isn't the issue in this case - the iron is about the same as a stock stanley (a good stanley, not a modern one) in hardness.

To me, it seems like the V11/XHP is a little bit less tolerant of defects or contaminants than plain carbon steel. Without a like comparison, seems like doesn't cut it, though.

I found the extremely hard plain blue steel japanese iron to hold up best on the mineral defect, which wasn't expected.