Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

Posts

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#26

yes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Another advantage of the sandpaper method is that it provides beginners with an inexpensive way to get started.

That is why our club stocked the necessary stuff so it was easy for people to start. Easy to start, high probability of success. The method provides a reference when trying other means of sharpening. I still keep two 12 x 12 plates loaded with a progression of paper because I still use this technique for some tasks.

We should be encouraging woodworkers to start by promoting cheap and easy to learn techniques, and then mentor growth in whatever direction they choose.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#27

Re: The original "Scary Sharp" post (1995)

Steve Voigt

The substantial advantage of sheet abrasive is the opportunity to proceed with small steps in particle size so that only a few strokes are necessary on each grit size. Much faster than using 2-3 stones of widely spaced particle size.

This makes no sense to me, and I've done it both ways. I can freehand a chisel on stones in less than a minute when all cylinders are firing, and I don't consider myself particularly fast. I'd guess most sandpaper users would be hard pressed to install and remove the chisel from the sharpening jig in that amount of time.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#28

Re: yes

Steve Voigt

Another advantage of the sandpaper method is that it provides beginners with an inexpensive way to get started.

.....

We should be encouraging woodworkers to start by promoting cheap and easy to learn techniques, and then mentor growth in whatever direction they choose.

I absolutely agree with encouraging beginners to start with cheap and easy techniques. The sandpaper technique helped me many years ago. But I think it's also good to suggest to non-beginners, like the OP, that there are better ways to sharpen.

Dave Weaver has done some good videos exploring cheap ways to start. I don't remember his exact methods, but for example, an India stone, and a piece of mdf with green paste or autosol polish. Or the India stone plus a hard (not trans or hard black) arkansas. Someone could easily get started for $30 to $50. By the time you've obtained glass, different grits of paper, spray adhesive, and mineral spirits, you haven't saved much money, and you're facing constant recurring costs on everything but the sandpaper.

On top of that, there is the hassle of replacing the paper (what started this thread in the first place). It limits your technique--you can't push or round a corner without ruining the paper. And no matter how careful you are, you will tear and ruin some paper. And the method more or less binds you to using a jig--it's tough to freehand this way. So when you want to use some skew irons, or a gouge, or a molding plane, you're out of luck. All of these are reasons--and there are more-- why the sandpaper method is limited and limiting.

So yes, let's encourage people to get started woodworking for not a lot of money. But there are much better ways to do that than using "scary sharp."

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#29

Re: The original "Scary Sharp" post (1995)

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I can freehand an edge probably as fast as you, Steve, but could you do that the very first time you tried it? I couldn’t, and that was roughly 60 years ago on a very dished out oilstone.

Everyone has to start someplace, and if they can’t succeed in a short amount of time, they frequently don’t do it again. I gave a demo to three rank beginners on Tuesday, one a retired airline pilot and the two others were mid-aged women with zero experience. Not only that but they didn’t want to spend even $5 to get started. A sheet of 400 or 600 paper and a piece of scrap glass will do the trick. Once we get them rolling, we can move on to other methods.

The very best woodworker I’ve ever seen or even heard of uses a single 800 King stone. He says if you need more than that you don’t know what you’re doing.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#30

the one minute sharpening

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't doubt what you claim, or anything else you or other planing enthusiasts say, but there is some qualification. You would not sharpen one of my plane blades in a minute, or a chisel.

Some background. Wiley's plane blade that David used for testing detoured through me on its way back to CA. Presumably David hit his planing end point, which he stated was way past where he would sharpen, and sent it to me without any further intervention. I could see, what was to me, a minuscule amount of wear so I presume the situation is as described.

So I says to myself, what do these people consider dull. Keep in mind that I live in remote TN and have never personally worked with anyone that eschews sand paper. I have no stake in the ground to reference what you all call dull. I may not even have a stake in the ground for sharp, but this conjecture is less certain. I did not experience any unusual plane performance in the sharp blade David sent to me.

For curiosity I mounted the blade in a LN 4 1/2, adjusted for a typical wood removal shaving thickness and planed some cherry. By my experience it planed just fine, which is to say I pushed and wood went away. That is my measure of success. I am clueless how I would have decided it was time to sharpen this blade by David's judgment, considering the short planing sessions I typically experience. I would have kept using this blade until it became substantially duller, push and wood would not go away. And that decision is where our worlds of sharpening differ.

For this discussion whether my planing is ignorant or not is irrelevant. The point is that by the time I sharpen I need to remove way more than 1 minute of metal on a fine stone. My whole quest of a sharpening technique has been driven by how to remove a bunch of metal as quick as possible so that I can get to where I can refine an edge on a finish "stone".

"Your" sharpening techniques depend on frequent sharpening. I will accept that this is the "correct" way to do woodworking. But if one is not doing woodworking this way then getting a burr on "Tindall dull" requires some step that removes a lot of metal, ideally quickly. Anyone else that sharpens when the wear can be seen without squinting needs to take the one minute claim with a grain of aluminum oxide.

Before others do I will hasten to add that we need to mend our ways and sharpen more often, and a whole lot of other things. But until we do the speed of 100 grit zirconia paper removing metal can be advantageous.

So where do we land? It seems that recommending sharpening must be informed by what is being sharpened and what state it is in when it is decided to sharpen.

I am currently "rice" carving some parts for the corner cupboard. I don't carve much but I carve enough to know the drill. Frequent polishing on leather and green stuff. Carving only works at all when the gouge is optimum. I would claim I can sharpen a gouge in 30 seconds. I recently turned some flat grain knobs and the grain orientation required a plane-blade sharp tool. I diamond honed (M4) after every knob. I would claim I could sharpen this lath tool in 30 seconds. I hone my hunting knife after every kill, maybe a minute. Kitchen knives, by the time I get to them are 5 minutes or more. Without context these time statements could be misleading.

PS: I have never torn a piece of paper. I don't think it is possible to tear a piece of the paper I use (Klingspor P33)

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#31

Re: a better idea

David Weaver

I'm sure there is some deviation from that, but I'm in agreement after having used just about everything that practical predictable use pushes me back toward finishing with natural stones. Touch and control counts for far more than speed for grit size.

For example, when a was setting up and selling a lot of razors, I found natural stones one step coarser to be faster than a step finer synthetic. The control with razors was preferable, and natural stones at that slight of an angle cause fewer strange failures. The idea that natural stones should be discarded because they're not as fas per particle size is a false dilemma. Just step up the particle size one notch, the sharpening time will be the same.

The exception that I can think of with users is George. He likes spydercos, but they behave a lot like natural stones. He's done a lot of incredibly fine work with synthetic stones.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#32

Spyderco—you got my attention

Wiley Horne

David,

What is the abrasive in spyderco stones?

Wiley

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#33

Probably ceramic aluminum oxide

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Performance would suggest ceramic(seeded gel) aluminum oxide. If this rock is patented and someone can get me the patent number I will find out. And if it is not patented it supports the ceramic guess.

Both in coated and vitrified abrasive formats ceramic abrasives have shown long life and fast material removal. If you don't subscribe to the claim that natural abrasives have a role other than removing metal then long life and fast are the metrics to pursue as science develops new ways to scratch metal. And where you may wind up is ceramic for an "inexpensive" material that can be fashioned into something that looks like a traditional sharpening stone.

I was given some ceramic 6" paper disks to use on my ROS. Life and material removal rate was better than anything I had previously used. I have not tried a vitrified product, stone or wheel.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#34

Re: Spyderco—you got my attention

David Weaver

They're ceramic, probably not dissimilar vs. what's in a shapton, but the difference is my understanding is that the binder is ceramic, or the matrix is uniform - one or the other. They're not ceramic in a resin matrix or something designed to shed particles.

I tried them and recognized them to be similar to natural stones in that they become slower as they wear, but I prefer natural stones for finishing despite that.

They were, for a long time, made by coorstek (former ceramic company owned by or related to coors brewing, but with far more reach than brewing related support). Not sure if someone else is making them now, as I've seen coorstek sharpening stones.

Bill could clarify, but I'm not aware of too much difference between many of the ceramics used for structure and wear parts and perhaps a more closely graded particle sized slab being used for sharpening.

They do not wear much at all and the porous nature of the medium stones (Think bottom of a coffee cup where it's unglazed) makes them slow down and load. I believe george uses his medium after a diamond stone, then the fine, and then strops on a loaded strop.

All that said, I'd resign them to fine work if you find you like them, but I like oilstones better (even for V11) and would rather have 1 micron diamonds in an oilstone if giving said stone a difficult assignment.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#35

Re: Spyderco—you got my attention

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I tried them and recognized them to be similar to natural stones in that they become slower as they wear ..

David, George turned me on to Spyderco several years ago, and I have used them equally alongside my Shapton/Sigma set. For all, stones should never be used dry (as Spyderco state they may), since swarf is needed to be moved off the surface. A little liquid soap in a spritz of water works well.

Even so, the Spyderco will load. What I have found works so well, and very quickly, is a little Simple Green and a scouring pad.This makes a noticeable difference to their cutting power.

Wylie, the Spyderco come in 8' x 2" stones and therefore do not suit a honing guide. The Medium s about 2000 grit and the Ultra Fine about 6000-8000 grit, in my estimation. Spyderco do not publish the grits.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#36

Re: Spyderco—you got my attention

David Weaver

At one point, Spyderco mentioned that the particles in the stones was 3-5 microns or something of the sort. I don't remember if that was the UF and F and not the medium, but it really doesn't matter. I think they had said that the UF and F were the same material, but the UF had a finer surface finish.

The magic is that they hold the particles in place and allow them to dull, and there's little or no air in them, so the particle size isn't critical.

I had used barkeeper's friend for a little bit and done some other things to keep the white stones clean but never had an issue with those, just the brown medium, which is more of a medium/fine stone.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#37

Re: Spyderco—you got my attention

rum

From the spyderco literature:

"Spyderco stones are made by combining a ceramic bonding agent with alumina particles (synthetic sapphires 15 to 25 microns in size). The ceramic matrix is shaped into triangles or other forms, then kiln-fired at temperatures exceeding 3000 degrees F (1649°C). The stones' hardness gradient is measured on the Mohs hardness scale with alumina ceramic measuring 9 (out of 10)."

I use the fine a lot for some stuff. The main downsides are that it showed up pretty not flat and needs a diamond plate to flatten it (I expected this so wasn't super disappointed but it does take more work than I'd anticipated to grind it flat), and its not the fastest stone ever. On the plus sides it wears very slowly (for better or worse I suppose), cuts pretty much any steel well, is super hard, and puts on a pretty decent edge that a little chromium compound takes to plenty good enough in my book pretty quickly. IMHO where this stone really shines is for sharpening small detail carving tools as they're just easy to work on it. I'd be less excited with it for larger plane blades. It doesn't have the "texture" that a nice washita has, but for some stuff I like the smoother feel. ymmv of course. I also bought the UF just to try but wouldn't waste the money again, the edge isn't meaningfully different than the F and needed about as much work to get usable (at which point maybe it lots the UF character? not sure.. wouldn't bother again anyway). I never tried the medium because it overlapped with enough other crap I had there wasn't.a compelling reason to try it. If it glazes to badly a couple minutes with a diamond plate brings back up a fresh surface although as David noted it works in some so the edge is a bit more brash for the first bit after that (could be desired or not - more not in my usage), usually a scrub under water is more than enough to clean it. I also tried one with oil instead of water+detergent while sharpening (because why not heh) and that also worked quite well to remove the swarf in use.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#38

Descripting written by marketing Department

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

From what I have read about the process the writer got most of the words right but they had no idea what they were trying to describe. As I understand the process a colloid of alumina is "magically" assembled into shaped larger particles of desirable shape, which in turn are fused into hard shaped particles of aluminum oxide. These particles are then assembled into some shape for use -grindstone or sharpening stone.

The unique feature of the shaped particle is that bits chip off its surface restoring sharp edges that mill shavings from hard metal while preserving the bulk particle size. Bottom line fast, cool material removal with shape preservation (as it applies to grinding wheels).

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#39

Re: Descripting written by marketing Department

david weaver

The breaking off of material sounds a lot more like silicon carbide or something going on with wheels (are we still talking about the spyderco stones?).

What happens with spydercos is actually very similar to natural stones, though with a harder abrasive than all except 15-20% of what's in japanese natural stones (aluminum oxide from settled volcanic ash).

I regard them as being similar to oilstones in that unless you're abrading the surface fairly often, they will become fairly slow (in my mind, a good thing on a fine stone if you're sharpening freehand). If they're abraded, just like an oilstone, they will cut many multiples as fast and raise a wire edge.

They present with a feel of a dulling surface rather than one getting finer with fractured particles.

Not sure who makes the stones for them, but it was coorstek before, so I wouldn't trust any of their advertising about process - it may be someone else's process with little incentive to really get the description right.

they do make a 1/4" thick 8x3 ultra fine stone that is a real bear to get flat if it's not perfectly dead flat when new -FAR harder to get flat than any natural oilstone. I always wondered how guide users get along with a stone like that as guide use sort of dictates the need for a faster finish stone due to the inability to bias angles.

Re: Scary sharp: replacing sandpaper

#40

Re: Descripting written by marketing Department

Rum

Yeah for small carving tools I like the slow part, it gives me time to reflect on my errors before they become to large. The fact its super hard also means that

My biggest complaint is how unflat they were and how difficult they were to flatten although I also realize that the latter attribute is part of why I like them in use so.. trade offs.