Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

Posts

A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#1

A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Attended Midwest Tool Collectors regional meet in Raleigh this weekend. For those unfamiliar with these events they are attended by numerous tool dealers and individuals selling old tools, in this case 50 of them comprising about 75- 4 x 8 tables worth. It is a boggling array of everything from $1000+ Stanley #1 planes to perfect working order #4's for $30. It is common for a dealer to bring the results of an Estate purchase to unpack and sell as was the case with two dealers occupying numerous tables each. It is an excellent place to get user tools, or collector tools if that is an interest. I bought an excellent #3 and #6 for a friend for a total of $90.

Demonstrating was someone I never heard of, Paul Hamler.



In addition to making Lilliputian tools and producing videos he has developed scraper inserts for Stanley planes. The talk was on scrapers of all kinds. I am not a stranger to scrapers. I scraped 250 sqft of new installation oak floor some time ago and regularly use card scrapers.

My use of scrapers is much like my use of planes. They are a reliable means of removing wood and I don't care about the resulting finish if it is smooth enough to sand. My problem with scrapers is that they don't remove wood fast enough and they dull quickly. I got enlightened. When Paul removed 1/4" depth of wood with a straight "Chair Scraper" it got my attention. With a plane mounted scraper he rolled off the equivalent of coarse plane shavings, or fine shavings if set fine.

Derek recently described making a scraper from a thick plane blade. I was unable to repeat this success with my grinder and a piece of M2. Don't question Derek's results but they may not be achievable without his grinding set up and tougher carbon steel. These results could pale beside what Paul did with a piece of 0.042" "blue" 1095 spring steel mounted various ways.

The secret, I think, was the edge preparation. Vastly less fiddly than what I have seen demonstrated. He went from a cut off piece of 1095 to removing 1/4" depth of wood from the edge of a short section of a board in about 2 minutes. Clearly his edges were vastly more aggressive and durable than what I have achieved. A web site video explains the preparation. To summarize- the steps are draw file edge at 45 degrees, polish face to remove filing burr, roll burr, clean area under the burr, straighten burr, re-roll burr, clean burr. He claimed this process produced a tough long lasting burr and the results confirmed the claim.

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#2

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

John Aniano in Central NJ

Bill,

Can you share the website link for Hamler's video?

John

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#3

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

David Weaver

What you're describing is typically how (at least these days) to sharpen a scraper plane with a burr. The bevel (At 45 degrees) allows for a fairly large burr, and the shaving that comes off of a scraper set up like that can be thick and with good edge longevity. Thick like leaving scallops if the scraper is narrow like the LN #212 small bronze scraper.

If you have a scraper fixture that can vary angles (#112, 212), when the scraper starts to lose its ability to work well, you can adjust the angle and continue to work a little bit longer (IIRC, lean the iron forward more - I no longer have a plane like that - you already know what killed fooling around with them).

Completely different than using a card scraper or a rigid version of the same thing like derek was showing. The plane fixture allows more stability (under high pressure) than hands would.

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#4

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

Jim Matthews

Hamler makes specific note about work-hardening the edge and proper burnisher selection. The pertinent video never shows any actual use of the tool.

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#5

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler *LINK*

Larry Barrett

Mr Google found this link to a talk that Paul gave to a group of woodworkers on how to set up and use scrapers.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TiC15vRQv_4

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#6

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Paul Hamler's scraper inserts for bench planes were discussed on this forum in 2007, and a number of times since.

I think it is much more productive to learn how to use a double iron plane. I stopped using scrapers in 1976.

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#7

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't have any opinion on scraper "planes". I don't have any use for them so I am not motivated to learn about them. They did strike me as gimmicky.

What I was impressed by was the edge life of his scraping. It was likely some combination of technique and metal, though he claimed any old saw blade or commercial 1095 "blue" steel was a good choice.

He was finicky about "cleaning" the burr after establishing it. And the roll-straighten-roll again sequence was new to me. I have only used "work the edge and then roll". And I have been way more fiddly about establishing the initial edge than his quick technique of draw filing.

I am thinking about scraping another floor and these sharpening tips will be employed.

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#8

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

david weaver

I don't think the tips will work well with a floor because they introduce a lot of resistance (which is OK at bench level) and without an actual plane to keep the angle perfect, you are better off doing coarse work on a floor with a beveled edge with no burr. The burr isn't bad, it's just that it changes the orientation of the edge to be less aggressive on a tool like a pull scraper.

I never quantified how long the A2 irons with a burr rolled the way you describe worked (I'm sure my process wasn't identical, but edge prep like a plane iron and then keeping the burr proper without jags on it is also important so that the surface looks good), but it was surprisingly long.

I would guess that without having to do more than just smoothing, the process takes about twice as much work as a good plane or two. I have a stack of curly maple panels from a never-finished blanket chest that I used high angle planes and scrapers on. I managed to scrape a couple of them after glue one evening and the next day, I wanted to scrape the remainder. two had cupped and the limitation of that type of scraper became clear - you can quickly fix a cupped board like that with a plane, but not a scraper. I left the shop with sore wrists and because I was using a large plane, went and purchased the smaller LN 212, which was narrow enough to finish the job. I still intend to finish the blanket chest, but that little scraper left scallops and finishing the blanket chest will include stripping all of the shellac off of the finished panels and planing the surfaces to be ex-scallops.

I haven't used every type of scraper for floors or boxes, but do like the stanley 82 scraper.

I actually rolled a burr on mine and used it to finish a hallway floor, but you're the one who mentioned to me after I did so that it would be far more aggressive without a burr (and it is). Without the burr, it can tear the surface of the floor a fair amount, though, but it's sure far more interesting than sanding.

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#9

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

david weaver

Thanks for that, Larry. I've never seen paul talk about his scrapers, but it appears (as one would guess) that a lot of the focus is on getting some pressure on the burr and making it very large compared to what we'd normally put on a card scraper.

Re: A scraper seminar with Paul Hamler

#10

Re: Hamler's blog...

david weaver

there's an address on the board in that video...it looks like it hasn't been updated in several years.

But he does have an active instagram and smugmug (no clue what smugmug is).

https://hamlertools.smugmug.com/

I remember walt quadrato carrying his scraper inserts or having a link to him and him (Paul) ceasing to make inserts at some point.

I can see by his library of work why that may have been - it looks like he chose making things he wants to make, and lots of it is quite spectacular. I think the sidetrack into scrapers above and beyond what was historically used may have been a waste of his talents - he's got more to offer than that.

Few of us don't end up in a rabbit hole somewhere, though.