by that, I mean board and all (pieces). I'm not a huge fan of turning, but do like to turn small things, and think it might be fun to make a chess set. Guitar neck blanks leave me with enough rosewood offcuts to make black pieces, and I'm sure I can come up with something interesting for white.
Not a full set but I've done replacement pieces for a couple of sets. Getting exact duplicates of existing pieces is in some ways harder than getting exact duplicates of a completely new design. Making shadow patterns to match against can help, at least for sizing the elements correctly.
That's something i pondered doing - either making templates for comparison, or finding common elements and just making a couple of quick tools to make those elements (pattern beads or the heads of the pawns, etc) because it will be apparent if all of the pieces are done by eye and not exactly matching.
If done really well by eye and very minor variations exist, the result (in my opinion) is very nice and lively, especially if the crispness of the work is good. If the matching is poor, it just looks like cobbled junk.
The danger of making profile tools is that they will not cut as cleanly as a skew and there could be some breakout on sharp elements.
Yeah I have avoided pattern scraping for the most part, somewhat on principal (it started as a forcer for skills building, continued as skills building, and still is skills building .. despite my anticipation of getting to where that wasn't as interesting - I think you can appreciate the overlap with other discussions here hehe).
You can however get a pretty good surface with sort of a negative rake setup like DRS's beading tools:
Doing that for a more complex profile would be somewhat more challenging to lay out, but certainly not impossible (easier than a molding plane blade design by a smidge).
I think, that like a lot of similar work, unless you're doing a LOT of them its generally still more efficient to just "get better" at turning and be able to get close enough to matching sets by hand. My big problems with that are mostly solved with gauges, dividers, marking tools (aka nails in boards, pencil marks on a board, etc..), and shadow patterns cut out of plastic /cardboard (I've tried to love the various profile gauges but don't mostly because they lack the resolution I generally want). As you say slight variation works pretty well, and doesn't really detract much (or perhaps enhances) from the final appearance.
Having said that the last "match a pawn" I did I had to make 8 of them before I was happy.. The guy I did them for was happy with 5 of the 8, apparently we had different standards of where we were happy
About twenty years ago, I was demonstrating the pole lathe and I made pawns from hard maple. It was a nice demonstration because I could make one from start to finish within a modest attention span. Like Rum, I would say by the time you make a dozen they start to get pretty uniform. And it is not like you are wasting a lot of material. The other pieces are not so critical for uniformity because they are not lined up in a neat little row.
I have an old chess set that was my grandmother's, boxwood and ebony. Stuff like this and rosewood etc could be scraped; these are what Holtzapffel called hardwoods. Stuff like hard maple and beech, "softwoods" in Holtzapffel lingo, really out to be cut with chisel and gouge for a nice surface.
I should probably read holtzapffel's text regarding small conical work like chest pieces. I have a couple of text versions but originally purchased them due to the sharpening literature (more archival and less for instruction, just because they have an interesting discussion for razor and tool abrasives).
I should've thought to read it first. I'd have guessed anything that carves wonderfully (boxwood, ebony) would be better for scraping since at least in ebony, the wood doesn't seem to have any conviction to long grain much more significant than it does to side grain.
I'm assuming that most or all of the large boxwood available now is turkish boxwood? Maybe that's always been the case.
There are a lot of species of boxwood (genus Buxus) native from England to Japan. There is variation in form, shrub to small tree, but the species I have seen have similar wood.
If I were going to use native wood for chess pieces I would try dogwood and persimmon. Both are dense and fine grained; both have a terrific luster off the tool.
Persimmon is not common in Pennsylvania, but there are records from Adams and Allegheny counties (and others).
had some persimmon trees in his grove near Lebanon, PA (northeast of mystertown, more or less). My wife doesn't know anything about it other than that she thinks the fruit is disgusting.
My mother has a boatload of dogwood, too, but her trees are higher value to her than my father and I, so no luck there.
I also have a box full of persimmon that someone sent me for boxing on planes, and it's good, but too thin for chess pieces, and is pretty dark for persimmon.
Leading me to ebay, where there are several nice light colored listings of persimmon, so it wins. Thanks for the suggestion.
Boxwood at this point looks prohibitive at best, unavailable in any significant quantities at the worst. I'll leave it for the people fixing expensive antiques.
I will second Waren's recommendation of dogwood, Cornus florida. It is a similar color to sugar maple heartwood. I get most of mine from standing dead trees. It is much more difficult to find than it used to be due to Anthracnose blight killing most of the native trees, but can still be found. It is an understory tree that tends to grow at the edges of woodlots. There are varieties of pink dogwood, usually with varietal names starting with "Cherokee" that are planted as ornamentals because they are more resistant to the fungus. Some of them have a light pink tone to the wood but most are white. You can still find them as standing snags, because the fungus still kills some of them.
I'm pretty sure Holtzapffel would classify it as hard.
There is also a Korean dogwood, Cornus kousa that blooms a little later than the native C. florida, that you might experiment with, but I don't have any experience turning it or any of the other Cornus species.
I have two dogwoods at the end of my back yard that have been blooming there for at least 45 years. No, you can't have them! However, just last week, I started processing one trunk of a two trunk specimen that was growing across the street. The other trunk is still alive and blooms every year, so if you are out driving in the country in early May (maybe a little later where you live) and see one in bloom, you might investigate whether there is another available dead trunk on the same tree that you can appropriate. Don't leave the rescued trunks laying on the ground; they spalt very quickly. I have another dead one standing on another piece of property we own, but I haven't cut it up, so I don't yet know the condition of the wood. It has been dead longer than the one I just got, so I don't know whether the wood is rotten beyond usefulness yet.
I have a significant quantity of boxwood, holly and persimmon. Some of the pieces are spalted but others nice color. Should you want some I would consider selling enough for your set but would need to know how many square feet, assuming BF does not make sense. P.
Where is the Colonel when we need him?! It seems to me George Dart made a chess set (board or table with storage for the pieces included) for each of his many kids. He often posted them here. I scanned through the Shop Shots, but don't see that any of those ever made it there (although other works of his did). Sadly, George passed on a few years ago, or I am sure he'd reply, with pictures, puns, and a twinkle in his eye! Yet another reason to miss him!
Would you like to try turning some Goumi (Elaeagnus multiflora)? I harvested some a few years ago with lots of help from Brian Holcombe. Goumi is what the Japanese use for making chisel handles and it is nearly as hard as boxwood and is very similarly colored. I've made handles for carving tools from it. A similar specie is the "autumn olive" (Elaeagnus angustifolia) which grows wild in my region of NJ. An uninvited non-native fruiting bush. But the wood is very similar to both Goumi and boxwood.
Hi, John - I'd love to try it. Should I send you an email to arrange it?
I've got some chisels with gumi handles, it's much like boxwood, as you say. Handles are probably an ideal target for that bushy stuff because the center of the branch is valuable to have in them.
That reminds me - there are two dogwood trees in my neighbor's yard (and we're not on large lots). A good branch would be interesting to turn, and I might see if they'll let me mooch one. Here in the burbs, lower branches head down for the sun and can be a nuisance.
I have a better chance than I would with a stray one in the woods at my mom's house. As she gets older, it gets harder to negotiate with her!
I've cleared alll the E. angustifolia out of my field while converting it to a dog track. Most of it was too small and/or crooked to be useful, but I saved one long straight trunk, about 2-1/2 " diameter. I haven't gotten around to making any handles from it yet, but I have noticed that as it dries it does not check. So, unlike dogwood, you can use the whole trunk for a handle, mounting the iron centered in the pith. This is as you revealed in a previous conversation. With dogwood, whether you are making a handle or a set of chessmen, you need to start with a much larger section of trunk, spit it through the pith and remove the juvenile wood.
David,
For chessmen, if you start by drilling a hole in the base, and use a mandrel as your drive center, you can later use the hole to mount a metal weight and then cover it with sticky back felt. Chessmen are much more pleasant to play with if they are counterweighted.
Re: E. multiflora, E. angustifolia or Amer. Holly?
John Aniano in Central NJ
David,
Just send me your mailing address and I can put some Goumi pieces in the mail. Is there a minimum diameter round that you need? These are chess pieces after all...
Also, have you considered American Holly? A super white wood, but not as dense as box or Goumi. I think around 0.6g/cc or so. I might be able to send you some of that as well. I've got some rounds with tight growth rings. I cut them over 25 years ago. Would be nice for something to be made from this material...
Re: E. multiflora, E. angustifolia or Amer. Holly?
David Weaver
Hi, John - I'll send you an email. No need for any holly. I have persimmon blanks coming also to compare, though the grain looks more coarse than gumi.
Thanks for offering. Not sure about the piece size - it'll depend on what I can get. I managed to find some nice gabon ebony guitar neck blanks today, so that'll give me some offcuts to make the black pieces out of either ebony or rosewood.
Thanks for the offer, Philip. I'll keep you in mind. I've got persimmon coming in bright turning blanks, and will hold off on any true boxwood as my turning skills and ability to make crisp pieces may not quite be what i'm hoping.
If I can manage to make a really good first set, though, I will be looking for boxwood or something very similar on the second.
Might I suggest (ducks) hard rock maple.. for some test/practice turning
It actually works pretty well for this sort of use case, and is imho a bit easier than some of the more brittle stuff like ebony. Cherry is also quite nice but I think rock maple might be very slightly easier in this use case as cherry can bruise a bit easier if you don't have the bevel floating nack as much yet.