Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

I'm underestimating planing

Posts

I'm underestimating planing

#1

I'm underestimating planing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

David's work made me think more about planing. I was fitting a door today. I began to keep track of plane strokes. It didn't seem like much. Swish swish here and a swish swish there. Test fit. More swishing. More testing. Add a relief bevel. About a 1000' feet when I got done! I had no idea. I would have guessed I didn't plane 1000' is 6 months. It's no wonder my plane blades get unexpectedly dull.

It took about a second to plane the length of the 44"door. That's a surprising(to me) less than 300 seconds of actual planing to do 1000'. I had no idea! Never thought about it before. An hour of planing would log some serious miles.

Re: I'm underestimating planing

#2

Re: I'm underestimating planing

david weaver

Strokes to plane the 41-48 inch boards were also about 1 second each. combining this and the other thread, it adds up.

I'm curious still about the heat at the tip level, not anywhere else in the plane, but at the, however you'd say it, few atoms thick level right at the tip of the iron. I've seen assertions that stropping razors does something for various reasons, but one of them is heat at the tip. A razor is so thin and light that there's really no residual heat.

Whatever the case, two things are true.

* get the sharpening cycle time down as low as possible without forgoing quality (less likely to skip it then)

* it's more fun to use the plane when you learn to use its capabilities (cap iron especially) and have just a couple that you're very familiar with (even if you have a whole bunch of others like me - those can be play toys once in a while)

Both of those are far above iron durability in terms of enjoyment and productivity.

As far as the heat goes, though, even if heat is part of it here, we assumed early on that XHP/V11 were not high speed steels just because they don't have the same hot hardness, but looking at the tempering schedule for XHP, and I'm going to assume they're the same not on someone else's analysis - but based on making three irons now and feeling the same thing on the stone and wood with them...Anyway, looking at the tempering schedule, XHP loses some hardness after 350/400F, but it retains a lot of hardness still at 800. So a little bit of overheating doesn't have that much of an effect on it compared to other metals that temper for use around the same 350/400. I think it would have a significant advantage with heat.

The real way to test heat in practicality is to run a test board, though (i'm not going to do it). Once at about 1/4 speed and once at normal planing speed....1/4 speed planing would be torturous. Then take a full speed shaving with both each 200 feet because a plane coming out of the cut behaves slightly different in transition from downward force to no downward force on a slow shaving.

Re: I'm underestimating planing

#3

Sound advice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As usual you provide sage advice that I can understand.

I don't recommend the plane speed test. The result would be convoluted with impact "damage/wear" and the unknown fact (to me) whether abrasive wear is velocity related beyond temperature. Now if K&K had put an infra red camera on the blade tip and got a temperature profile back from the tip, neighbor Mark could calculate the temperature at the tip. Actually, given that the profile here is linear, two temperatures would enable a slope and intercept to be calculated and anybody could calculate the temperature anywhere along the bevel length near the tip. . We wistfully contemplated that experiment.

It was interesting that the heat profiles from tip back to the bulk of the blade were such simple mathematical functions. Sometimes science is elegant in its simplicity.

The heat flux at the very tip my not be as great as that back a bit. Studying the K&K video there is some parting of the grain ahead of the tip so the frictional heating may start in earnest back a few microns.

With doors fit, and it ended well, today is affixing the crown molding and sanding to prepare for staining. The end is near for the corner cupboard.

Re: I'm underestimating planing

#4

The volume of shavings is shocking

Jim Matthews

In the "original packaging" shavings are tightly packed.

Once liberated, they occupy a shocking amount of space.

My last major project was a timberframe approach to a shed roof.

(Think Pergola, attached to a rim joist on one side.)

All green, local Pine.

Rough from the sawmill, it was too large to machine plane.

I used a Marples transitional plane on all the surfaces people might touch.

It filled a quarter of my backyard, one inch deep.