Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

"It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

Posts

"It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#1

"It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

David Weaver

I can't remember what the context was that I said that in, but I think it may have been ...who knows. I think making an iron came about in wanting certain properties out of O1.


I haven't made that many, I think these 5 are it (lots of other irons, but stanley irons are a lot of work for what they are).

I don't think they're a waste of time at this point if you're aiming at something you like and either can't or don't want to buy it (e.g., what if you want an O1 iron that's hard, but not hock hard?).

The 3rd iron is, of course, V11. The first iron at the top is the XHP mule that I tested against the O1 iron (far other end of the line) that lasted about the same as a hock O1 iron.

The second iron from the top is O1, slightly softer than the last, and the remaining two are XHP. I like the hole in the slot at the top end of the iron. It's easier to put the cap iron on the blade and take it off because it never goes over the end of the blade by accident. I think all irons should be made that way, and am not sure what stanley's reasoning was for putting the hole down near the business end of the iron.

Subjectively, I like XHP a little softer than the two new irons are (those are tempered at 375 degrees and are a little hard mannered. I'm not going to duration test every iron that I make, but I doubt they'd go much longer than the mule (which is probably 60 hardness or so, maybe ever so slightly higher) and the mule is twice as easy to sharpen.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#2

question- more details

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Subjectively, I like XHP a little softer than the two new irons are (those are tempered at 375 degrees and are a little hard mannered. I'm not going to duration test every iron that I make, but I doubt they'd go much longer than the mule (which is probably 60 hardness or so, maybe ever so slightly higher) and the mule is twice as easy to sharpen.

The 2 latest one's were tempered at 375 vs ?? for the original. Are you saying the two newest blades are harder?... (because?) ....And they are more resistant to abrasion in sharpening by 2X(estimated?)?

And you are speculating that in spite of the fact that these blades are 2X more difficult to sharpen by abrasion that they will last the same amount of feet when planing? Because they will chip? Or are you speculating that they will last so long you don't want to face testing them ;)

Only a few thousand feet separate us from some fundamental knowledge on the effect of hardness on edge life. >(

If they are too hard you will see chipping. Easy to test. Use them like a chisel and chop some end grain with each. Your dandy microscope will readily reveal if the edge is micro deforming or chipping.

Next visit one of your local machine shops and get some hardness data.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#3

Beyond chipping for ideal hardness

David Weaver

Obviously, there is a comfortable range that these irons will operate in. It's probably 58-63, though there's no guarantee in open atmosphere, my irons will get to the top of the range and be OK.

Also, chipping below a certain point is sort of subjective. An iron that goes from smooth edge to lines all over the place in 100 feet is probably too hard. But what about one that leaves a little line here or there, seemingly suffering nothing else. What I saw from these irons in the test, and with the two at 375 is they will leave little tiny lines, and then with a little wear, those lines go away. There are lots of reasons for this that may be more related to contaminants or material pinned on my diamond hones, etc, so I'm not sure about that.

But further than that yet is my desire to have something that rolls up a wire edge fairly easily because it is quicker to sharpen and easier to confirm that sharpening is done. That is a better iron to me - and I'm not sure what I give up in edge life, but it may be zero percent or it may be ten. I don't know. But I sure like sharpening the mule that went to 405 degrees temper than the other two that went to 375 temper.

Three irons doesn't really make for a good sample to draw conclusions from. It's still fairly difficult to get these irons to bright orange (really bright) and I pushed my second one of this bunch to the point that there were differing surfaces after heat treatment (did I cause some elements in the iron to surface? I don't know). So, the consistency that we'd want isn't there. After testing all three, though, the mule behaves really well and is a little softer. The other two irons are a little more hard tempered and indistinguishable in testing, and as I post this, they're already at 400 in the oven to see if they have the same pleasant behavior as the first iron.

By schedule, if I did things right, that may be 60-61. I don't use a machine shop around here, so I'm not aware of one without doing some footwork (if I was located where i grew up - rural - then machine shops and engine shops are easy to find - they're right in town.

I have the make process for one of these irons down to an hour and a half with my poor man's setup. It'd probably be easier for me to make you an iron to use and let you have it analzyed than it would be for me to track someone down close to here and drive back and forth to them.

I have the mule and one of the two to use, so I probably won't be making many more #4 sized irons, but I also have a record 8 and an old i sorby 7 to make irons for). The third iron here is headed out as a gift.

I just checked the oven and the second and third XHP irons got to 415 in the oven instead of the 405 that I was targeting. I don't think that'll be a big deal (the tempering chart for XHP shows less sensitivity around 400 and slightly above than O1 - actually, it's really insensitive. They also state that they don't recommend tempering below 400 degrees or above 800 (as I recall, that's nearing the range where chromium will start to do bad things if it's left to congregate).

Supposing this is actually the same steel that is used in V11 irons, I'm sure LV did plenty of testing to find out what temper they liked, and I'm sure their work is more legitimate than mine. I'm making a lazy man's iron.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#4

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

Wiley Horne

David, this strikes me as a good time to start getting your arms around what you’ve already accomplished—which is a lot. This has been a fabulous experiment, with insights being thrown off like sparks. But if you keep expanding, it will be like that Tolstoy short story we read in high school literature about the fellow who was told he could have all the land he could walk around in one day—it ended badly.

Why not start tabulating and organizing your data and photos and observations-by-feel? You might think about whether it would be valid to assign a metric to your observations-by-feel, which have to do with (a) ease/difficulty of sharpening, (b) when you would have sharpened, i.e., when the iron stopped pulling itself positively into the wood, and (c) tactile behavior—how the iron felt in the cut, esp. in the early going.

For example, on all of these, you could adopt LV’s method of using two benchmarks—the best and the worst, assigning them 1 and 10 respectively, and arraying the others in between subjectively.

As the true scope of the results begins to take shape, it will likely occur to you that it would be good to go back and fill in this or that uncertainty or ambiguity. You have all the time in the world to do these fill-in studies, so if you start corralling the data and findings now, the fill-in studies will be aimed at bringing things to closure, rather than trying to walk around yet more land :) .

Wiley

P.S. If the thought of tables, charts, and text makes you a little ill, you can get some help and editorial assistance from the usual suspects :) .

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#5

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

David Weaver

Hi, Wiley. This stuff is excluded from the testing and publishing of information. It's an offshoot from the testing (which I think/hope is done and I'm writing ul the bits and pieces for) . The discussion here about iron behavior is pure preference on my part and I wouldn't subject anyone to it.

Plus, I don't want to put anywhere in external reference other than here that some speculate that v11 is xhp for the very simple reason that I don't want to see any of the high margin retailers throwing it in planes.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#6

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

Steve Voigt

Dave, that's impressive work. How are you forming the slot and keyhole, given that you don't have a mill (I seem to remember that you don't have a drill press either)?

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#7

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

David Weaver

I do have a drill press now. Home depot special. It's very inaccurate, but accuracy isn't needed. I would've made these with a milwaukee holeshooter just the same (Actually, that might be kind of fun and solve the issue of me potentially getting whacked by a rotating iron on the end of a large drill bit).

Anyway, I drill holes, then file through the waste on two holes until I can get a flat file in and then use the flat file to cut through the rest of the way. My favorite flat files for fast work are the simonds multi kut coated, they're something like $9 and they cut far faster than a normal single cut file. I can do probably half a dozen or 8 irons with one, and three of the XHP irons, I'd guess.

Once all of the holes have the in between waste cut out at file thickness, it's just a matter of putting the iron in the vise and filing down to the mark. I like filing kind of like I like planing. You can get good at it and then it's enjoyable.

XHP pins files a fair bit, though (not like brass does, marring a surface, but it leaves strange little film all over the file making it look exactly like it would if you filed something overhard and rounded the smartness off of all of the teeth all at once). A file card takes care of it very easily. The round parts are just cut out mostly round looking with the round file, light work just at the mark.

I have an OSS now (guitars) and could clean up the curved parts at the end so that nobody would instantly look at them and think "oh, hand filed. how untidy", but there's no need.

It's another nifty little mindless project and at this point now that I have a process figured out, it will preserve the original irons in the older planes. There aren't many I. Sorby 7s floating around, and the flatness level on my jointer would've literally fit within LN's spec easily. It's maybe the only vintage jointer that I ever got that would.

I file to the mark on the outside/width with a vixen (those are really great for unhardened steel. Fast, really pleasing to use), and then after rounding the back, half grind a bevel to try to tempt the steel to warp to the opposite side. So far, I've never had an iron warp with the cupping on the bevel side.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#8

Re: Definitely like the XHP a touch softer

David Weaver

XHP #2 and #3 got the oven again today, and got to 415F, I think I said that already.

AT that temper, they are subjectively less hard than a 380F temper, and sweeter in use. Incredible sharpness off of the washita, and as bright of a finish as I've seen off of carbon steel on any stone.


Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#9

more questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Impressive accomplishment.....

You talk of "filing to the mark". I gather somehow you have an outline of the final shape marked on the blank. How done?

When Smith made blades "oversized" plate was used and the heat treated blades surface ground to size and flatness. This process removed the surface layer altered during heat treatment. How are you getting rid of this altered surface?

When can we begin placing orders? :)

In response to Wiley's concern, blade making would be a valuable separate report.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#10

Re: more questions

david weaver

Dykem on the top of ground stock, trace a blade that fits, and you have your marks. Carbide scribe.

I have to admit on the decarb issue, I'm not really that well versed in how long it takes for it to be an issue and how much it matters. As far as the stock I'm using, it's already ground beforehand, and in the three blades, I've come to the conclusion that getting the blade to heat quickly in my case is important (open atmosphere) and pushing to get a tiny additional color change to get to more heat isn't helpful.

So, I heat quickly to try to limit decarb, relying on the mill grind to have full quality material at the surface. You can sand or deburr the scale/oxidation off of the outside of the iron, it's not that deep (but it is definitely hard at first). What's left behind doesn't take that long to flatten unless the blade warped significantly. My blades probably move with the adjuster a little less easily because the surface isn't as perfect. That can be countered by just loosening the lever cap screw a little bit.

I'm sure (i'm not really sure, but I'd guess), there's some performance loss for doing what I'm doing, but I'm trying to limit it because the value of making and feeling like I can horse something around (for some reason, I feel like i have to be more careful with things I buy, and even though I might like the V11 blade better if it was a point or two softer, I will sell it or give it away instead of heating it).

The experimenting is almost as valuable as the having the blade at the end for me. That the final versions are as workable as they are is a bit of a surprise. I wish I could get a picture of the surface brightness that all of these blades leave (v11 as well as the slightly softer XHP irons), it's unreal given the sharpening media (washita) as a finisher. On the softer ones (and probably the V11), the first few strokes seem to result in improvement in uniformity (maybe that happens with carbon steel) and brightness.

I thought while making the first one that there might be a significant expenditure on files and bits for these, negating any cost savings (which isn't important, anyway, or I'd be making irons out of foreign O1 - or...wait, smart thought, using that very inexpensive chinese iron in the first place), but the change in drilling holes to drilling each a little at a time (still allowing almost continuous drilling) and finding that the very dull looking teeth was actually an accumulation of material on a file brings the cost of gas and files probably to about $5 per blade.

One other side comment - when I had the blades harder tempered, at 375 or whatever it was, I checked the wear on one of the two new ones, and it had that same powdery look. I'll check the wear at the 415 degree temper with the scope after it's got some significant wear and see if it again has the same smooth looking wear that my test in sap beech showed.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#11

I may give a few away...

david weaver

I know you were kidding about orders, but I won't be selling any of these. I may give a few away, though.

I wish I had unlimited riches to have a hired hand to put the commercial iron and the softer mule through a stroke test to estimate how much durability I'm giving up by dropping hardness a little bit.

Based on the sap beech test, it's not enough to worry about, and it makes the iron very workable on a natural finisher. I can't make a comment about washita not cutting chromium (it's likely that it doesn't do much other than rub it) because normally I'd make a comment like that when a surface is subpar compared to carbon steel, but on a similar abrasive basis, the surface is brighter with XHP than it is with any of the carbon steel irons I've used in the tests (O1, Ward, Blue Steel).

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#13

Re: You are having WAY too much fun

david weaver

Experimentation that ends up yielding something that you actually like is always fun.

Absolute failures, not so much, but you can give good advice then to anyone else considering doing the same thing.

I didn't ask whether or not I should open atmosphere heat treat these irons or temper softer or fabricate blades with minimal tooling because it isn't "the right way" and I already know what answer most would give.

I think you would've said "you know, a machine shop can do all of that" :b

That's true. what'll happen if I experiment, though? How much performance will I lose. 10% of it or all of it?

The only thing i wish I could find is stock in .125 or .140, because then I could use that stock to make infill plane irons. Right now, the authorized distributor of XHP reminds me of Henry Ford's comment about Model T Colors.

you can have XHP in .093 ground, or you can get any of our other sizes that are also .093 ground stock.

(all three of my irons have the same feel on the stones and the same quality on wood, so i'm confident that I can purchase stock when its available and not waste the princely sum that just the bare stock costs (about $60-70 a pound).

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#14

forgot the hand held metal bandsaw..

david weaver

.or whatever you'd call it. The kind of saw that someone would use to cut tube on a worksite. It's not good like a "real metal bandsaw" would be, but it does do the roughing a lot easier than a handsaw.

I already had that, though, and will use it again in the future at some point to waste material from infill plane side and bottom dovetail sockets.

So, as it turns out, I don't have the "right" tools do make irons, but I have a lot of tools. I think the bandsaw probably cuts 15 minutes off of the process of making an iron and saves fighting a hand hacksaw in thin long pieces of steel. It has limited cut depth, but you can't have everything for $99.

The important draw that's left is doing something by hand - filing to a line, floating to width with a vixen, etc. Both very satisfying. Nothing difficult like learning to use a machine tool, and no sense of observing work vs. being in the middle of it.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#15

Re: forgot the hand held metal bandsaw..

Wiley Horne

David,

How do you avoid work hardening when drilling and sawing? I think you said on drilling that you rotate around....

Wiley

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#16

Re: forgot the hand held metal bandsaw..

david weaver

A second or two of drilling each hole and then just do the same thing on the holes in order, like repeatedly walking up a ladder until the holes are through.

Though water isn't the right thing to use, I like to dribble it into the drilled holes because it cools the metal and acts as a canary when drilling. It steams off quickly, then you move to the next hole.

For cutting, if you keep it moving, it cuts fine. I'm sure an assistant dribbling water or fluid on it could also keep the temp down, but that's not something I want to figure out. If you stop to regrip while sawing, it'll harden wherever you stop, but not deep - a bimetal blade will get through it within a second or two and you're on your way again. I don't notice much change in sharpness with the blade (one of the type marketed by dewalt for about $7 each in packs of 3).

The whole process would be scoffed at by a real metalworker, but it yields plane irons pretty quickly (relatively) and at low expense.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#17

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

Steve Voigt

Thanks for the info on files; I've never tried the Simmons. I've also never used a Vixen on steel, though I often use them on brass. I'll have to try that.

Btw, I smiled at your comment "I like filing like I like planing." Same here. There is so much more to it than just pushing the file over metal.

I'm curious though, if you've tried threading a hacksaw blade through the keyhole (setting it on the 45° pins) and cutting away part of the waste between holes. I would think that would be faster (but then I've never made an iron this way so i don't really know).

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#18

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

david weaver

I think hacksawing would also work if you were willing to do a shortened version of what I do down the iron slot. Not sure if the cut temperature at a hacksaw blade edge could create any problems or how long the teeth would last on thin material, but it should be doable slotting just part of the length and drilling the large hole at whatever end it's on.

I haven't tried it yet, but should.

Vixens are great (the type that go on a backer and are intended to be flexible for car work) just screwed onto a wooden stick. You don't want one with a conventional handle to work metal, though. Sometimes, it's nice to be able to go parallel along the length of something.

There's a little learning curve with not allowing a tooth to catch along the edge of something, but for a person with no real metalworking tools, they are a good material remover - faster than a file, but slow enough that you don't blow past marks. maybe three times as fast as draw filing. When they catch, a tooth can go deep into the corner of something and spoil it, but my opinion is that they are well worth learning.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#19

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

david weaver

By the way, the simonds files come from someone close to you (leesport), at least relatively. They're imported, but somehow still good quality. The interrupted tooth is very helpful for flat filing. I have yet to run through enough to send them to get water honed, but that's next (along with the vixens).

301223944085

I just looked up vixens and I don't know if I'd use them on metal at new price. Somehow, I've managed to find them on ebay in packs of five (NOS) for $5-$8 each. I've made two infill planes and a whole bunch of other stuff and I'm not sure if I've gone through one yet - perhaps may be on the second one. It would grate my senses a little bit to abuse a pferd body file that costs $50.

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#20

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

Steve Voigt

Thanks for the link. I haven't bought a vixen in a few years, but I got them from yardstore.com.

https://www.yardstore.com/hand-tools/miscellaneous/hand-files-vixen/new

Looks like they sell the flexible ones for $16, IIRC shipping is around 10 bucks (not sure if that's still true though).

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

#21

Re: "It's a waste of time to make stanley irons"

david weaver

that's a tolerable price given how long they last. We'll see how well they come out after a boggs treatment. a couple of them could end up being a lifetime supply.

10" is a good size, too. No need for them to be gigantic. Not sure why they work so well, probably the amount of force on each tooth allowing the use of a more dull tooth, and they sure don't pin.