Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Question for the Metalworkers

Posts

Question for the Metalworkers

#1

Question for the Metalworkers

david weaver

So, I have a nice norseman set of jobber bits. They are "nice for a woodworker", and in my opinion, nice all around.

I burned the tip of one yesterday in a context with the XHP, realizing that i could grind it back at some point. I'm assuming that HSS bits will air harden and retain some hardening.

But, I have a ruined tip that needs to come off of the bit. I can regrind and resharpen freehand, but I'm not as clear about method of getting something like a quarter inch off of a fairly large bit.

Will the bit be OK if I cut the end off with a cutoff wheel and then grind off a little bit and regrind? If i'm the kind of person who would completely ignore the heat treat schedule on XHP, heat it really hot and dip it in oil and then throw it in the oven, am I being overly hesitant to even ask this question? :\

I didn't see anyone who did what I did with XHP, but I'm sure fixing messed up drill bits is more common (or is that something people hire out, too?).

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#2

I believe these are M2

david weaver

They are just the golden colored HSS bits that come in a jobber bit set, no special coatings, no cobalt, etc.

I have to make more irons to see if I can duplicate what I did (plus, maybe the picture of the shaving pile in the other thread is just due to really favorable wood, just as I think the washita result was probably due to the cutting being done near the heart/sap contrast, and after reading something about heartwood, it would seem that sap at the transition is just waiting to become heart, and heart at the transition may not be fully filled with the junk that accumulates in heartwood.

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#3

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

John in NM

We generally replace wrecked bits at work. I got the machinist a Drill Doctor for the dull ones, but he doesn't bother with stuff like you're describing. So unless you are really wanting to keep to a specific brand, my advice is replace it (in part because I can't answer the actual question you asked :D ). McMaster or MSC are good places to get quality replacements. I like MSC a hair better because they tell you the brand name of what you're buying and where it came from.

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#4

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

E Phillip Smith

Are you sure it's dead? Why not just regrind the point and see it will drill metal. M2 tempers around 1000F which should be red. Did the bit turn red when drilling and did it stop cutting chips?

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#5

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

david weaver

Red, continued to cut when cool, but obviously operation at red (in frustration, trying to win a one hole war of the red metals) ends up hot filing or whatever you'd refer to it as, the end of the bit.

Even the "minor diameter" created at the end continued to cut, so I figured that it can not only lose its temper, but regain hardness once it cools again by air hardening, probably at some cost of the structure in the metal.

At any rate, if it does reharden, I should be able to cut off the point and grind some off then (at a "not" high temperature) and turn this into a semi-garbage bit for this kind of thing in the future.

This is what happens when you introduce a carbon steel user to stuff that does things carbon steel doesn't. Good quality bits, carbon steel, a dot of fluid (or even none) and you can drill right through.

I re-looked at XHPs tempering schedule again today and it's 3 C-scale points softer at 800 degrees than it is at 400. I'm guessing the only way to anneal it again is to get well above a thousand degrees and then force it to cool slowly. Something I'm not prepared to do.

Next go around will involve much more fluid.

(Of course, I'm aware that this stuff can be sent to a shop that does this stuff well, but the draw of trying things out is too strong).

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#6

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

david weaver

If this was a workplace, at the $7 per bit cost, it wouldn't be worth the trouble.

I did actually buy a partial jobber set of the smaller 2/3rds of bits to make up for the two bungled bits as well as one I bungled before, and three small ones that I've lost over the years.

So, this is more of a salvage operation of want rather than need.

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#7

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

William Duffield

I have the same question as Phil's.

i have colored M2 HSSS drill blanks while grinding them into turning tools without ruining the hardness. This was on a low speed grinder with the white wheel that came with the grinder. Since people I gave the tools to didn't necessarily know about that property of M2, I always cleaned off the colors with steel wool before giving them away.

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#8

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

david weaver

I turned this one orange, but the reality is these bits will drill mostly wood. They reharden when they cool, and probably enough that it doesn't matter (i freehand sharpen them on a grinder or belt grinder, so it's a lot like wood plane irons - I'm not offended by a short life iron).

It seems like (as you say with the colors, just remove them), I should be able to get away with cutting the ends off of these bits and regrinding a new tip on them. I'll just do it and confirm.

The only crying point is that the factory tip and flutes that come on these bits are to die for. they will cut your fingers.

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#9

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

William Duffield

Ah! black body radiation orange, 2000°K or so. That's a lot hotter than I've gotten M2, so it's totally outside my experience. I limit my annealing, hardening and tempering to O-1.

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

#10

Re: Question for the Metalworkers

david weaver

It's something you see only by accident (and then maybe in anger and curiosity).

This is my first experience with something that air hardens. It taught me a lesson. Since this is stainless steel, I will probably cool it with water. A "professional" and not a hack would have some type of machine to drill this slot at slow speed with liquid or high speed with liquid - something that would keep the temperature low.

XHP has a wonderful characteristic in that you can heat it above carbon steel's quench temperature, but it's not absurdly high and you can get there quick and quench. It also has the wonderful characteristic of tempering at cupcake temperature in the oven more or less.

What I failed to realize is that just because my two end points are similar, it doesn't mean that I can assume that I can just anneal the metal easily or heat it to blue and get a good result. Rather, what it does is:

* temper at high hardness at a low temperature (unlike HSS)

* lose very little hardness at accidental edge burning or over-tempering (unlike carbon steel)

It's also like grease through wood, or kryptonite to an uncooled drill bit.

As a professor of mine used to say in college, "learning hurts".