Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

Posts

One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#1

One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

David Weaver

hand honed bevel side (probably mid 30s in terms of angle) and 1 micron diamond back bevel.

Another lazy man's special that suggests pairing a very fine diamond finish on the back with a medium natural stone produces a pretty good edge duration.

I love the washita, the way it feels and am not looking to give it up in favor of a diamond hone.

Curious as to what I would do in a "Real life" scenario maintaining a single secondary bevel with one stone, but trying to cheat by improving the finish on the back of the iron with 1 micron diamonds (ruler trick in this case because the back bevel is there).

768 feet. I think that's pretty favorable. This is a relatively fine washita, but it would cut the bevel on the O1 iron four times before needing to go back to the grinder, and the feeling of using it vs. a diamond plate is heavenly.

Avoiding a second angle with 1 micron diamonds on the bottom prevents more steepness, adding it just on the back seems to add a considerable amount as the stone is less fine and much faster than the black ark.

This is also well ahead of any of the trials that I threw out with the 2.5 micron diamond (and much sharper feeling and smoother in the cut - less effort).

Cycle time with this would be similar to the 1 1/2 minutes that I refer to elsewhere.

Surface finish is behind the black ark and well behind the 1 micron diamond in terms of brightness, but still good and uniform. No marks, no strange edge failures, just pleasant planing.

Re: One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#2

1200 grit diamond bevel, 1 micron back - 527 feet

David Weaver

same cycle time as the washita stone for the bevel on the iron (freehand), same overall cycle time.

Tested only to see if the benefit would be better than expected with diamond (few will use washita with V11. It can be made to work, but eventually, you'd tire of it). Works great with O1.

The worn out 1200 ezelap is still, too unrefined to offer much benefit here relative to the others.

Not to say that it won't take a thin shaving - you can read through two of the thinnest shavings that this method will make, but they have a lower quality than thin shavings from a more refined method, and duration suffers, too.

Re: One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#3

washita only, both sides, freehand - 901 feet

David Weaver

This is a relatively unexpected result - the washita used with the 1 micron diamond, but carefully sharpened freehand (somewhere between 30 and 35 degrees) and then stropped briskly on bare leather.

901 feet.

This isn't a lilywhite washita, it's a little harder and finer (and more dense) and fairly close to a translucent in edge quality, just not quite as bright of a polish.

This is the center of the board and the heart is just changing over to sap right at the end of this test, so maybe that aided it some.

This is one of my favorite stones to use because of the seeming sharpness but ability to use one stone and leather, so now, maybe by chance, the test ends with results justifying use of one of my favorite stones. Better than I expected.

I also expected this to better the 1 micron diamond polish on the back.

No real idea what grit equivalent this stone would be but it cuts no matter how settled in it gets, just gets a little slower. It has a hand written card in it noting that it was used by a carver and later factory supervisor for a furniture factory in indiana, circa 1915 as the date given for its use.

Now, how could it do better than the black stone? I think the most likely culprit is hand honing and being less than 35 degrees, but enough of a bevel so that there was no early chipping.

Re: One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#4

reaffirming the same conclusions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

More edge refinement leads to more feet.

For me it will be a damn site faster to refine another step than to sharpen the whole regime twice as often.

Re: One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#5

The other benefit....

David Weaver

accurate planing depends on starting a cut, taking the cut evenly and finishing the cut. The less perfect a surface is to start, the more important this is (if you're planing high spots, you don't want to be fighting the plane to stay in the cut or start it over and over).

Edge refinement leads to a far longer period of time where the plane is easily keeping itself in the cut vs. just keeping itself in the cut tolerably. That leads to forgiveness planing edges, etc. I can tell as the test goes on, even when a plane is staying in the cut, say, 60 percent through the strokes and on from there, you have to pay more attention because the plane doesn't stay in the cut as easily.

For a refined edge like the longer results here, there is a period of planing that the less refined results don't ever experience. For example, the 5 micron diamond edge does not enter the cut easily (it will enter, but the cut resistance is high) and it will leave the cut at the ends of the board more easily.

It's often said that planing a board from end to end results in a board with relieved ends, but when I plane, I experience the opposite. If the plane is working well, the board stays flat. As the plan begins to fail to stay in the cut easily, the ends of a board get proud for me and I plane it hollow. This leads to an acceleration of the problem and you can get a small bump by taking another plane and retruing an edge, but the dulling plane will create the situation again.

after doing all of this, I can't defend not refining an edge, and I'm not surprised that for ease, warren and brian have gone both to high edge refinement and fairly early resharpening.

Re: One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#6

Re: The other benefit....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I ended up doing 800 feet with my iron (and still working) before I sharpened it. It took extra time to sharpen the iron, much duller than it has ever been since I acquired it.

As a professional, it is much more economical to sharpen several times in this amount of work rather than to put it off for so long. Sharpening is much faster when it is done often, but more importantly the tool works much better, so it is faster to true up an edge. And you don't have to worry about starting off Monday morning with a sore elbow or shoulder or something.

Re: One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#7

Re: The other benefit....

Brian Holcombe

I certainly agree with that, while I understand and appreciate the rational behind David’s testing. It is interesting to learn about ultimate longevity even if I do not employ it.

Warren brings up an excellent point, in practice it’s important to work your method around keeping yourself intact. It’s tough to do fine work with your tongue hanging out.

Re: One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#8

Re: washita only, both sides, freehand - 901 feet

Rum

Additional Unproven Hypothesis:

Freehand sharpening inevitably gives you a bit of variation on the edge causing a slightly convex bevel. This should (in theory) ease the entry somewhat compared to a small secondary bevel increasing the apparent edge life - in the context of its ability to stick in the wood (unscientific support for the theory here: http://site.baryonyxknife.com/blog/2014/08/11/why-convex-edges-are-awesome-its-not-why-you-think/ ).

How much that has an effect (if at all) versus simply a finer edge .. could be tricky to ascertain.

Re: One more wildcard- Washita and 1 micron-768 feet

#9

Other unpublished results

David Weaver

I tried a couple of two step freehand step-up type methods, and the results were pretty much in favor of the flat bevel, but probably because chasing subsequent grits in the interest of the microscope (e.g., photo and edge perfect needed) chased the bevel up to or past the flat bevel.

This was the only result that turned out better than expected, but the reason is probably simple - the method takes one bevel above the grind, and it's very easy to control geometry.

I'm out of heart on this board, so I can't run any more follow-up tests (e.g., finishing this iron with the guide on the washita stone), but those are things people can do and post the results of. I think if the flat bevel is as good or better for planes, but there MANY cases with knives and chisels where a small convex bevel can bail you out. They center (to me, I learned to describe this by listening to cliff stamp) around dealing with steel that is tough enough everywhere except the edge. rounding the bevel a little bit without doing it to a considerable amount of steel preserves the geometry (important for good slicing with a knife - you want the thin bevel geometry), but protects the edge by moving the failure point elsewhere (further from the edge).

This is useful on chisels. Most people would call it a microbevel, but I like a tiny rounded bevel for that. IT doesn't threaten later sharpening sessions and doesn't solve a tip problem by modifying the entire bevel.

This stone is deceptively fine. There is something about washitas that make them really favorable at cutting for their fineness. I've also had probably 20 washitas and this is the second finest of them all, at least of the ones that cut well. The other one was in a barber box with a strop top box, and this one was used by a carver, so it's maybe more favorable than one would get with other washitas. I also never recondition the surface of a washita for no reason, so this one is settled in.

The last condition that makes one squint a little looking at this result is it's where the heart is transitioning to sap and I didn't weigh the shavings or take pictures (just had enough of that). If I'd have weighed the shavings for all of these, it might find that I took a bunch of thinner shavings in the middle of this. Rotating planes and weighing the shavings allowed me to make sure nothing was slipping under the radar.

All that said, a slightly rounded bevel is fine, but I did catch myself with these results trying to imitate the three bevel method and probably limiting clearance a little bit. Of course, the cycle time was half as much, so is it important that on those tests, I lost about 20% of the edge life? Probably not. I would be sharpening before there was a problem, anyway, and spending half as long freehanding.