Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

Posts

Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#1

Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They are calling the bevel angle wedge angle. They studied, without cap iron, effect of wedge angle in range of 26 to 35 degrees, on planing force and surface quality. Bedding at 50 degrees and shaving thickness 50 micron(.002"). Steel is Kigami.

Between 26 and 32 degrees there was not much difference in cutting forces or tip wear. Cutting resistance went up as blade dulled ( or blade dulled) at a greater rate at 35 degrees.

At 35 degrees normal force went positive at 50 meters vs 150 m for lower angles when planing a wood with density of 0.43, Beihi.

Don't have translation of wood surface description but pictures look all about the same to me.

This seems to be the first disagreement between your work and K&K. For a shaving lifter it would seem that 35 degrees is bad news. The angle should be kept under 32. From 26 to 32 data look nearly the same. It is little wonder all the rest of the Japanese papers use 30 degrees.

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#2

The wood

Wiley Horne

Wood density has a lot to do with the dulling rate of plane blades. Here is a chart of wood densities:

https://cedarstripkayak.wordpress.com/lumber-selection/162-2/

K&K used a wood of density 0.43. Inspection of the chart shows this to be in the range of redwood, pine, spruce. Beech, that David used, is rated in a range of 0.7-0.9, almost twice the density of the K&K species.

Do you think that the woods typically planed—needle wood, say, vs. temperate zone hardwoods—would have a bearing on included angle?

Similarly, the species of steel—say, Ward iron vs. PM V11–might matter.

Why would there be one single included angle that would be optimum over the full range of wood/steel combinations. Typical for Japanese kanna irons would be 25.

Wiley

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#3

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

david weaver

Surface is similar between both, quality slightly less uniform at 30 degrees but nothing that would bother someone who was going to scrape and sand or just sand. 35 degrees with 10 of clearance may result in slightly more bright surface. Larry always insisted that we were burnishing grain with common pitch planes. Maybe there is a little bit of truth to it.

As far as cutting force differing 30 to 35, I just can't perceive it with the cap iron set. Does the cap have anything to do with it? I don't know. Does the bronze sole of the LN plane have something to do with it (it's stick)? Not sure.

My takeaway from what I've done so far is that for the average person, 35 degrees will extend the time between sessions to the grinder and is probably a little easier for the average person to complete (unless the primary bevel is driven much shallower). 33 is the angle I manage to hit training myself to avoid edge quality issues. 35 freehand seems steep to me by hand, but the final bevel angle is a small tertiary bevel, not a full bevel. That may impact these results, or it may not. The length of the tertiary bevel is probably ...guessing....between a quarter and half micron at the most.

Secondary bevel in the charlesworth method, at least with my jigs, is 32 degrees.

I'm waffling about whether or not to use the guide to set an angle at 32 to see if it betters both of the others, but it really doesn't matter. It's unlikely to be anywhere close to the significance of the abrasive finish unless clearance is narrowed further.

The purpose off of the top of my head (getting lost in teh details a little bit) of measuring at 30 degrees was less about picking the perfect angle, but more about providing an alternate data point to keep people from reading the results and saying "pshawww...this test was done at 35 degrees. I know the results would be much different at 30"

I'm a later convert to these kinds of angles (30+), though, due to quality problems with A2, and knowing that I didn't observe them at 35º with the charlesworth method, and subsequent reading of Elliot's work confirming that he saw the same thing with alloy steels. Quality problems at that time outweighed any search for an extra 10 percent of planed wood, plus I realized that an undamaged iron without microchipping just made sharpening and subsequent quality easier to finish and attain, respectively. The microscope is telling me that perhaps I have sharpened 90% of the wear out sometimes, but not 100%. With an undamaged edge, you can hardly tell the difference between the two.

At any rate, I can assure you that the perceived force differences with the plane set up as I have it is very little, and that in both cases, the last 200 feet feel similar, while the gradual lowering of clearance before then also feels very similar. is my feel that accurate? i don't know. If not, ignorance is bliss.

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#4

Re: The wood

david weaver

There is probably a case for beech being beating up a 26 degree plane iron edge, and softwood not doing it.

i don't work much with softwoods and one of the things that I had some displeasure with was using japanese planes for a while and finding that keeping the edges free of defects in even cherry was not always easy. in an 8/10bu plane, if you go to 30 degrees total angle, you're already butting up against clearance-related longevity issues (though it's better than honing out damage).

I vaguely recall some of the old stanley instructions suggesting 25 degrees, and some suggesting 30. The soft irons in some of the early planes probably wouldn't have fared well at 25 degrees (I have a pack of NOS 18 block plane irons, and they are definitely on the soft side), but in pine, it may not have been a big problem.

All of this is why I can only claim to have observed things in this test with this wood and with the plane used, and because I have done all of this testing with the house O1 in the LN smoother rather than suddenly switching to the hock iron. Hock's iron is a bit harder, and mine is a bit tougher. In beech, it seems that they're an even match.

if bill wants to test the iron I've made for hardness, I can send it when done here (I have another one and won't go through withdrawal). Otherwise, I can guess at it in the paper.

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#5

wood density

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The pine like wood (d=0.43) just did what the denser wood Makamba (density 0.65) did but at a slower rate.

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#6

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My takeaway from what I've done so far is that for the average person, 35 degrees will extend the time between sessions to the grinder and

To repeat, the K&K data under their conditions concludes that beyond 29 degrees the blade dulls and lifts substantially faster. They predict more trips to the grinder. I do not doubt either data set. What I conclude is that this experiment is sensitive to variables we may not even recognize and the "best" angle can not be stated with certainty. Personally I am going to stick with 30 degrees because I don't see evidence of chipping with the blades I use.

There is NO evidence of burnishing in the SEM surface pictures. Cells seem to be cleanly cut. There is no apparent chipping (SEM PIC's)even at 26 degrees in the dense wood, even up to 200 meters.

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#7

Re: wood density

Wiley Horne

I just went and checked 4 planes. They were all 29-31. Never checked before. So 35 now seems steep to me.

I checked by putting each iron in an LV jig and finding the projection where it first began to pick up a shaving. Then put the LV calibration tool on the jig to discover the angle.

Wiley

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#8

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

David Weaver

You're thinking of time to the grinder as primary bevel equals final angle.

I have a primary bevel that's probably about 25-28 degrees. If I hone at 30, I will return to the grinder soon because the final bevel approaches the grind faster. I don't hone on the hollow, so the difference between primary and secondary bevels has some correlation to decreasing the frequency of grinding.

I have purchased several older wooden planes that haven't been in use for quite some time that I expect were used for site work, but I can't confirm that. They had long very shallow primary bevels, perhaps between 15 and 20 degrees, and then a secondary bevel more like 30-35 honed on them. Someone was extending the time between grinder trips. That's not where I learned that trick, but it was interesting to see that someone else did it.

I wouldn't grind a 35 degree primary on a plane iron and then hone on the primary. Maybe it's just my imagination, but I imagine that having only a very small bevel at the final angle is probably better for clearance, and it's certainly insurance against the bevel creeping above 35.

The strength of this final bevel may be what just punished me testing endgrain, though. It was brutal and my shoulder is sore.

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#9

length of the wear...

David Weaver

..did the wear bevel on the k&K work exceed half a millimeter on the board side of the bevel? I'll measure my bevels.

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#10

Bevel angle

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I did experiments with clearance angles in the 1970s. What I found was that at 12 degree clearance there were no problems and that at 8 degrees of clearance there were definite problems. The range between these values was hard to discern, and would have been slightly different for different qualities of timber. For a 30 degree bevel, that equates to a minimum cutting angle between 38 and 42. For a 35 degree bevel, it equates a minimum cutting angle between 43 and 47.

I have a beech Sandusky trying plane with a 44 degree bed. The taper on the iron makes for a .67 degree adjustment, so the cutting angle is about 43.3; the jack plane I made in 1978 also has a cutting angle around 43. And I have a smoothing plane altered to cut around 42 degrees. I would not want to go too much over 30 degree bevel angle for these workhorse planes.

Years ago Larry Williams claimed that bedding needed to be 50 or more to avoid clearance problems. I wondered about this for quite some time. When I saw him honing it all made sense. He hones at about 40 degrees.

Re: Kato and Kawai on "wedge angle"

#11

Re: Bevel angle

david weaver

all of those figures give me clarity regarding why I'm choosing a 33 degree angle on most planes, and you're choosing slightly less.

Thanks for providing that detail.

My wooden planes are common pitch, plus or minus a degree for user-making. I am probably leaving them around 10 degrees of clearance, and 12 with stanley planes.

I tried something at one point years ago with seven degrees of clearance and it was problematic early on. I also tried 5 or 6 on a japanese plane after nicking an edge and getting irritated with the 8 to 10 minute process of heavy work that's involved to repair such a thing on a large japanese smoother, and that was also a very short lived cycle of work between sharpening, and also not very pleasing.

I often wonder how much (as definitively as larry stated his opinions) actual testing larry did to check his assertions. I don't think it was much. Like his claim that iron width in a double iron plane has to be limited to avoid the wedge fingers due to a "shaving trap", it took very little work from someone who didn't know that much about planes in general at the time (me) when I started making them to make a plane that didn't have any such issue. It took no time thereafter to diagnose and solve trapping problems in older planes and make them perform just like mine. In every trying plane that I've made, that is the last test before cambering the iron - leaving it straight, biasing a cut toward the fingers and inducing a clogs. It takes very little work to adjust the parts of the plane involved and eliminate the issue and ensure a very nice working plane for someone else to use. Time is not kind to the planes, and just pulling an old plane out where the cheeks have been adjusted or the wedge replaced with something that doesn't fit, or anything else that threatens the critical parts - of course the results will not be good.

It would be the same thing if I picked up a poorly fitted single iron plane with a large mouth and decried the shortcomings of all single iron planes. Single iron planes can be precisely made and work well for smoothing. They're just a factor of two behind a double iron plane for actual work in anything other than perfect wood, and they're still behind even in that.