Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

Posts

Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#1

Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

David Weaver

It appears with the two irons I had time to test tonight, a 30 degree bevel probably gives an extra amount of longevity of about 5-10% over 35 degrees.

I was able to do 1 micron diamonds and the black ark stones.

I don't think I'm going to waste time doing the 5 micron at 30 degrees, but we'll see tomorrow.

I'm not able to find my cache of submicron abrasives unless I have them stashed somewhere for razors.

I'll do the "cheat" method of washita on the bevel and 1 micron diamonds on the back bevel tomorrow as well as a 35 degree bevel test with 1 micron on wood polishing the edge as brightly as I can.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#2

Re: 1 micron diamond - 908 feet

David Weaver

No pictures posted with this. They look identical to the 35 degree pictures.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#3

Dans black arkansas - 738 feet

David Weaver

same as prior, the pictures look similar to the 35 degree pictures. I might've finished this edge ever so slightly better, but not sure. Not something that would affect this test.

Better meaning more photo perfect, not functionally better.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#4

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

Wiley Horne

David,

This is on the House O-1?

Wiley

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#5

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

Kees

Wait, I don’t understand. First a higher bevel angle lasted longer, now it is the other way around?

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#6

Conclusions of abrasive size experiment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Are these conclusions valid?

Conclusions:

1. The resulting surface from 5 micron front and back is unacceptable to someone planing for surface appearance. Surface planers should not further consider sharpening to only 5 micron or equivalent.

2. For both the less abrasion resistant "Ward" and the "Weaver O-1" , 5 micron front and back shaved about 200 feet from the life of the blade for a shaving lifter.

Speculation:

1. 5 micron front and back will leave the edge more venerable to initial wear than 5 micron bevel and polished back.

2. The price to be paid by a shaving lifter for stopping at 5 micron is an initial loss of 200 feet of edge life.

3. A more abrasion resistant steel might not suffer as much initial loss as a softer steel because of less scratch depth.

4. This initial loss of edge life could be 200 feet or less for any blade, and hence less meaningful for long life steel like V11.

5. A few passes on leather charged with abrasive could lessen the adverse impact of stopping at 5 micron. Ditto for a polished back that remains polished.

Why do I care? I can not go from 120 grit grinder to 1 micron without grinding perilously close to the worn edge. Hence, there is an intermediate step of "Fine" fixed diamond. Hence, I am using the advantage of cheap and fast cutting loose diamond on cast iron in the step where it is the least efficient. It would be best to use loose diamond after grinding.

Desirable would be grind at 120, xx micron diamond on cast iron, strop, Done. 5 micron would do the job removing metal and 3 might.

David's excellent work will cause me to move to PMV11 blades for all my shaving liftings . His work on abrasive size has encouraged me to resurface my cast iron plates and investigate 3 and 5 micron diamond followed by strop for sharpening.

Nobody here will care where I wind up but the furniture makers on the main board and elsewhere might. I will report David's work at our club meeting when we start up in the Fall

Thank you!

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#7

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

David Weaver

Yes.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#8

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

David Weaver

I would trust these results over those on the Norris plane. It's easier to just be the power source for this plane than it is with the Norris, which takes a little more influence from the user.

Given the small difference in both cases, I'd be more apt to say that in a range of 10 to 15 degree clearances, the edge finish matters more than the clearance.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#9

Re: Conclusions of abrasive size experiment

david weaver

It may be that I need to do a single run with V11 and 5 microns to see what the effect would be on it. I suspect that it's not just 200 feet, but that the shape of the wear starts differently and would guess that a percentage of edge life is a better application.

Beyond that, though, it is far more physical work to plane 75-80% of the edge life with the 5 micron edge, the shavings don't pick up at the beginning of the board as cleanly (which will lead to inaccuracy) and it's just generally a miserable experience.

I think that a 5 micron abrasives sets up the geometry well and the edge looks even, but some kind of cheat needs to be used at the edge if you don't want to do the full process. I think even for a shaving lifter, the accuracy gained by the sharpness, the duration and the ease of planing all point toward it being useful.

It'll be dependent on how much board thickness I have in this board. If I run through the heart and into the sap, the results won't be meaningful. If I switch boards, same. I didn't run multiple V11 tests in this wood, but we have a set of shavings with the house iron at the same setup as test 2 (the first beech test) and can guess that the results are reasonable to compare to the duration from that test (don't remember what it was - 1700 feet or something).

I think if you cut your bevel with 5 micron and then have some way just to even kiss the edge at a slightly higher angle on 1 micron, you'll gain most of the benefit.

I hope anyone reading the study once it's posted will be willing to try two things to compare them - I think in this case, even though it would take an hour or two, you might find interest in trying 1 micron against 5 to compare how they feel. 5 just comes up short. I culled the 2.5/3 results, they were not different enough from 5 and they're too fine, I think, to be considered as any option to remove wear.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#10

Something as simple as a charged buff ...

david weaver

...and the right touch may drastically improve the 5 micron results, as could 5 micron on the bevel and 1 on the back.

I was anticipating maybe using washita for that, but I think there's no great reason to introduce it in these tests.

Tonight when I check the "superfine" results, I'll try 5 micron on the bevel and 1 on the back bevel, though I'm not sure of the practicality of that (diligence would be needed to prevent 1 micron contamination.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#11

Re: 1 micron diamond - 908 feet

Warren in Lancaster, PA

How long does it take to sharpen the iron between tests?

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#12

Re: 1 micron diamond - 908 feet

david weaver

Well, i'm compromised by using the jig to keep specific angles recorded. So about twice as long as it normally would take me because i'm faffing with garbage.

I'd say 3-4 minutes. It's somewhat intolerable.

Out of the plane to planing again normally is probably 2 minutes. I hate giving up hand control of the nuances of sharpening and maintaining curvature. All of those things can be done with a jig, but you just do not have the full range of touch with the jig - it's like going back to black and white television after having color.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#13

(freehand)

david weaver

if I was able to do freehand, I wouldn't have the ruler trick, I'd probably use two stones (a single diamond hone and the cast plate with 1 micron) and I think the sharpening time would be very comparable to oilstones, but, as you're aware, I don't want someone to question my ability to freehand hone at a specific angle even though you know as well as I do, it's probably not tolerable to vary the edge by more than a degree because it doesn't feel right.

I thought about freehanding one for this test, but it just wouldn't add anything to the data other than prove that i wouldn't lose edge life freehanding. I'll probably add a comment to the article about the sharpening method and make it clear that I wouldn't suggest it for someone in the long term - it makes people frustrated to hear it, but a guide is, in my mind, something to be left behind for anyone who is going to do more than one sharpening per shop session. It's a serious hindrance to sharpening things that aren't straight edged, too. It's important to develop the neurons, brain and hand.

if I asked you how you sharpened knives, or chisels or plane irons, etc, once you have the neural development, it's all the same. You decide what you want for geometry and just do it. You receive feedback from what's been sharpened, and you make adjustments and settle into what's idea for your use. I know there are machinists and engineers who don't believe that you can give up that precision, but they're camping in neurotic territory instead of developing neural capability. I choose neural development over neurotic thinking.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#14

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

Wiley Horne

The higher bevel angle lasted longer on the Ward &Payne vintage iron. These figures are for David’s homemade O-1.

Wiley

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#15

Extra comment...

david weaver

One extra comment - the ward iron had slightly lower surface quality at 30 degrees. It could be a matter of the diamond or stropping to try to get rid of the wire edge that caused an issue. I just didn't get an edge under the scope that looked as good, but I also didn't want to faff with the iron lots longer.

I expected that 30 degrees would yield slightly better edge life, or about the same, but not 1 1/2 times 35 degrees as some might guess due to clearance.

Like I said in the other post, I'd trust the result from this setup more. This piece of wood is also a little more consistent. The heart on the last piece at the bottom seemed to get harder just in the middle of the 30 degree test, which may have influenced things.

One thing I'd like to gather from the angle tests, though, isn't which is better (30 or 35), but that within a reasonable range, is there any reason to believe one is far better, and I think the answer is no. My freehand measures 33 or so. It may be better than either of these if I hook up the iron in the guide and make it precisely that, but I don't think it's critical. Will there be more quality issues at 30 degrees, and could it be the case that some irons hold up better at 35? Maybe. A2 has a reputation for dropping bits out of the edge unless it's close to 35. It may wear worse because of it.

It could be legitimate with the ward iron, too, that it just prefers 35 over 30, but I did this test before properly finishing the back of the iron and got 500 feet at 35 degrees and 550 at 30 on that go-around. Finishing the back properly added some durability.

Long story short, don't read too much into that one ward result, because even the ward got two different numbers. Now, to complicate that even further, I was a little bit more careful with the unprepped iron on the 30 degree test in that case.

Draws back toward finish level being more important. Final bevel angle seems like something I couldn't get that excited about, but something that perhaps Larry would've argued more about (I think I remember him showing a stanley guide at one point and insisting that there was a definite right answer, etc).

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#16

Re: Extra comment...

Kees

Ok, I understand now. Things get a bit complicated with al the variouos tests and posts....

You might want to test 25 degrees too ;)

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#17

No thanks!!

david weaver

I did contemplate 32 degrees since I already have an angle gauge setup for that from the old days (it's the secondary bevel before the tertiary finisher).

But, I'll leave well enough alone.

I have Big/Little smoothing to compare, I guess I'll add that on the end. An illustration of how doing most of the work at 4 thousandths instead of two for initial smoothing or planer mark removal does a lot to negate the need for more wear resistance than the most plain irons I've tested (ward being that - I think it's water hardening, and the durability sort of confirms it likely is).

I want to see if big/little smoothing with O1 can beat V11 in volume of shavings removed if V11 stays at the test spec shaving.

(and endgrain)

I hope I don't get hit by a bus before i manage to write up all of this stuff.

Re: Duration by Abrasive 2 - 30 degrees

#18

Warren - cycle time...

david weaver

Using the method with the guides, off of the grinder (so potentially 30 seconds faster than an edge not straight off of the grinder, I'd guess).

3 minutes and 45 seconds from lifting the lever cap off of the plane to setting the iron.

I had a separate plane that I used to plane the filthy end off of the endgrain test board. A stanley with another O1 iron that i made, similar to the one in this test, perhaps ever so slightly softer, but not much.

1 minutes and 20 seconds cycle time with a "1200 grit" diamond plate and 1 micron cast iron, plus a short bit of time on the bare leather strop. 1 minute and 40 seconds total out of the plane to back in with a normal smoother set of the cap iron. That iron was not freshly ground, but it matters little when I'm freehanding. I can bring more to bear on the initial work on the cutting stone, and have much more control ensuring that every stroke works the entire edge from corner to corner.

No back bevel on my regular user plane. The edge from each process is indistinguishable, but it's difficult to specify this method for a test like this when I don't hone the entire bevel or measure the secondary that I create.