Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

Posts

Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#1

Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

David Weaver

35 degree final angle, O1 steel this time (my iron, house made). Beech heartwood again, level grain. Abrasive works both sides of the bevel (ruler trick style shallow back bevel used again for speed). Wood used little and cast iron more this time. Disregard any ugliness in the 1 micron picture, the results speak for themselves. I may have a contaminating grit or some other bits (even wood dust) on the surface now as I did some actual real woodworking in the shop earlier today and there was dust in the air from hand sawing.

Bare leather strop is used enough to remove the entire wire edge.

I will do 30 degrees sometime in the next couple of days to see if it offers any improvement in durability for any of these three.

Posts with each type follow so that I can include pictures.

Re: Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#2

Re: 1 micron diamonds - 840 feet

David Weaver

picture of the edge off of the honing media:


at 100 passes (340 feet - tiny diagonal lines are just wiped oil)


at completion (840 feet - lots of wear, but very pretty. on a really fine media, the very edge of the iron rounds significantly as the iron is giving up. i saw this also when comparing this iron to the hock)


Re: Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#3

dans black - 700 feet

David Weaver

At the start (edge is finer than it looks. More stropping needed than with the diamonds, but not enough to round over the edge):


at 340 feet


At terminus - 700 feet - pretty again at the edge


The edge looked better in pictures here than in the ward (I didn't post those pictures) test at the outset of each (Before wear). This iron is slightly harder than the ward, and it seems to take a better edge off of the stone and with less deflection or ragged appearance from stropping.

Re: Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#4

Re: 5 micron diamond - 568 feet

David Weaver

after sharpening (looks good, but feels duller in the cut right away. The shaving is never really smooth and the surface much more dull looking).


after 100 strokes (340 feet)


at the terminus, (568 feet - also pretty. The O1 is very agreeable and wears evenly no matter what is used)


When this is all over, I'll be going back to this iron for use.

Re: Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#5

Other tests?

david weaver

I have limited wood to work with here in terms of the heart on this board, but look to have enough for a couple of other tests.

I was thinking (knowing that washita is probably going to fare between 5 micron diamond and black arkansas), that a cheating method might be useful.

Bill has expressed interest in simplification, and in my mind, one bevel above the grind and back work is a nice simplification. Obviously, the black stone works well, but it's a bit slow for the bevel without constant grinding. Slurrying it would yield less edge duration, though that would work.

The cheating method that I can think of is this:

* work the bevel off of the grinder on the washita

* finish the back with the 1 micron cast plate

that would be super quick because it's easy to freehand with a microbevel when you have only one. That's what is so attractive about the washita - the time saved sharpening that would lead to probably a 600 foot result in this test is worth it, and the speed of the stone leads to a greater chance of completing sharpening, but it's not so fast that it wastes iron. An example of a situation where I think the numbers just provided as feet don't really lead to more productivity.

I will try that if there's enough wood left. We're getting close to the end of testing - i'm getting tired of it, but I wouldn't mind taking a process improvement away from this.

Re: Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#6

Re: Other tests?

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

I feel your pain. However, would suggest one more extension to the test you’re running now.

You’ve pretty much convinced us that 1u is way better than 5u. Question: Is there advantage in going finer than 1u? If you ran the same test, using your O1 at 35 degrees, but with final hone being 1/4u or equal (such as the diamond on hardwood strop), you could locate the point where further edge refinement yields diminishing or no returns.

Wiley

Re: Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#7

Re: Other tests?

david weaver

I'll add that. I've been thinking about it, as there is some gain in sharpness in razors all the way to oxides that go below a tenth of a micron. 1 micron diamond on a razor would be unspeakable on all but the softest of backing (and that's precisely what iwasaki did - soft felt or something with one micron diamond).

I suspect that it will yield little in additional longevity, but I might as well prove it. The draw to 1 micron, though, is simple. It's fast, and it's a replacement of the finish stone rather than in place of. That makes it practical to complete the sharpening process, even when you're in a hurry. I found out when reworking the first back bevels that even with 1 micron diamond, you can't just spend 5 seconds of swashing back and forth and actually get all of the wear out. it's multiples of that. Smaller abrasives will add a step and be slower, but they may add material longevity.

Re: Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#8

Re: Other tests?

Jonathan Elliott

So is the washita faster than 1 micron diamond on cast? Is that why you wouldn't just use 1 micron on both sides?

I forgot, do you also use the bare leather strop after 1 micron on cast? How many strokes?

Why do you like the microbevel in addition to the hollow grind rather than just grinding at 33 and using the "microbevel" the hollow grind creates?

Thanks! Really enjoying following along with all of this. I know you're getting tired, but are we all going to talk about when you're done?? :D

Re: Duration by Abrasive - 2 - 35 degree

#9

Re: Other tests?

david weaver

Washita - yes, far faster than 1 micron on cast. the less resistant the steel is, the bigger the difference. It's fast enough to cut a single bevel on an iron after the grinder (1 micron really isn't) and refresh it several times. I'd say on 60 hardness O1, it's probably 5-10 times as fast cutting. Life span off a washita stone is several human lifetimes, too, but it wouldn't tolerate 3V and it's marginal with V11.

I like the additional bevel instead of honing on the primary bevel because it makes it a lot easier to control the geometry of the edge for someone who is just getting into that. As in, when you start planing to finish, you need to have a mild curvature to the blade that is on the order of a few thousandths higher at the edges. It's easier to control this with a secondary bevel. It's also easier to be sure that the sharpening job is completed with a smaller secondary bevel, especially when the steel gets tough, and you can sharpen more times before you go to the grinder.

Typical use before this test would've been use the washita and then chase the burr with something (a finer stone and then a strop or just alternating back and forth and then the strop. I think I'd probably refresh a smoother iron 5 or 6 times before seeing the grinder again, and grinding accuracy isn't as critical. I don't set a rest on the grinder, my rests are at 90 degrees, so the grinding is done basically by Kentucky windage.

Some stropping with 1 micron on bare leather, but not much. Strokes total maybe 10 with the final couple at very light pressure. you can draw an edge or deflect it with a strop (even leather) and heavy pressure.