Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated..

Posts

Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated..

#1

Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated..

David Weaver

...planing work.

Sometimes you need to know what you're looking for, but I started woodworking with David C's sharpening video. I think the method is cumbersome now, but it allows someone who has never sharpened before to follow paint by numbers and get better edges than many experienced woodworkers (based on my purchasing of used planes that were in use, some professionally).

When I first went to freehand, I honed at 30 degrees. There were edge quality issues for someone who wanted to finish plane on something harder than softwoods. Add A2 into the mix, and the edge quality issues were greater, even with LN's wonderful A2.

I gradually adjusted my freehand up to what turns out to be about 33 until quality issues went away. I am fascinated with this not just for longevity, but because retaining edge quality makes sharpening easier the next round, and if you should happen to come up short (which probably isn't often), the remaining edge is quality and you can continue to work, anyway. At 30 degrees, this doesn't really happen.

What did I find at Steve's page? Confirmation of this, but done more carefully. Steve found that chipping was an issue with A2 at 32 degrees. with other steels, there was good longevity at 30 degrees total, but quality suffered.

How many people know that steve did this? I know Brian Holcombe encountered this because he brought it up years ago when he was using an LN plane with A2 and we all know that Brian makes wonderful planed surfaces. These little nits wouldn't bother a shaving lifter, but Brian is a surface gazer extraordinaire to the power of infinity. I'm not surprised that he found this. He brought this up right after I went through the same experimenting. I know he's moved on from there, and that's no surprise. Surface gazers sharpen a lot, quality is paramount, longevity is second. Proper wood prep or good equipment makes smoothing a low grams of wood experience, anyway.

I don't know what Brian does now, but he can hold his trade secrets close.

That brings us back to Steve. It was very nice to see confirmation of what I was seeing. I'd still be wondering maybe had I not seen that. There's a lot of information floating around that other steels hold up fine at 30 degrees, but it depends on what your expectations are. Even removing the wire edge at 30 degrees seems to be a bit more threatening than at 35. It should be simple to guess at why that is. I found the same thing even on the ward iron, that getting a photo perfect picture off of cast iron was more difficult with the 30 degree bevel. the back bevel on cast creates a small wire edge, removal of it leaves evidence.

I know this edge angle poll came up before. I'm fairly sure warren answered it, though like me, he may have had to have measured to figure out what he's actually using. Something that works is most important, what it is is secondary. If warren has found a little more than 30 is ideal, I wouldn't be surprised.

TLDR some of this, but just to say, Thanks, Steve. It may seem sometimes like not many people are reading your work, but I have seen most of it at least once, and some when looking for something that matches my own experience.

Re: Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated..

#2

Re: Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated.

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

Great to see Steve’s work getting some visibility. Your testing and Steve’s are complementary, as you point out. Steve actually has 2 websites:

Comparison Teats of Plane Blades

http://bladetest.infillplane.com/index.html

And,

Testing and Tuning Infill Planes

http://planetuning.infillplane.com/

There are some gems at both sites. One of my real favorites at the ‘Comparison Tests of Plane Blades’, under subhead ‘Steel and Sharpness’, is titled ‘Wear Profiles’, where he shows progressive dulling based on actual experiments. He shows initial wear on the upper surface, then the critical wear at the bevel taking over and leading to clearance loss which ends the planing cycle:

http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/wear_profiles.html

This is a stunning experiment in my view, and have not seen its like elsewhere.

All of which is to say that David and Steve make good company

Wiley

Re: Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated..

#3

Sharpening angle

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have sharpened plane irons and chisels at 30 degrees at least since 1975. Full flat bevel. I do not have trouble with chipping, even with harder woods. I think the 45 and 47.5 degree planes were designed around a 30 degree bevel. A 40 degree plane and 30 degree bevel theoretically gives clearance, but more clearance is needed so a sloppy craftsman who sharpens well above 30 degrees will stay out of trouble.

About 30 years ago I was got the impression from reading that a slightly higher bevel was favorable for mortise chisels. I tried to increase the angle gradually, so as to keep a flat bevel, but was not able to get it over 31 degrees. I am back to 30.

I watched a video Rob Millard posted of his sharpening. He said he sharpened at 30 degrees, but in the video I thought it looked a lot more like 40 degrees. He must have gotten the same impression from looking at the video himself, because the next day he reported that his tool was really 39 degrees. Larry Williams video claims about 30 degrees, then he raises the tool "one or two degrees". But it is really raised more like eight degrees and is also around 40. Paul Sellers claims about 30 degrees, also appears to be 40 or more.

Re: Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated..

#4

Re: Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated.

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! I have no trade secrets really, I show everyone as much as possible since I feel that encouraging people into plane finishing is better for the group as a whole. If I have any secret at all it's that I've gained a great deal of insight by going back and reading old posts over the years.

I'm not sure I'd even be capable of finish planing, if not for the collective knowledge shared here, SMC and through Chris Hall's blog. If I were still it would have taken me much much longer to get to the point I'm at currently.

For O1, I'm not sure my actual angle. I grind at like 22 degrees and then lift a certain amount and put a finished edge on. Trick is to constantly resharpen and to knock it apart and resharpen if you're having any trouble. People suffer through a dull edge much longer than necessary in my estimation where I sharpen often as possible. It just keeps your mind sharp and your skills sharp all around.

Re: Steve Elliot's Wonderful and Underappreciated..

#5

Re: Sharpening angle

david weaver

Thanks, Warren. I also get the sense that some of the guys calling out angles should probably make an attempt to measure them. The bulk of their bevel might be less steep than 35+, but from watching them (like sellers' rolling) lift or roll, the lift looks more significant.

I landed at 33 (Above 30, which is where I started), probably due to the fact that I had and still have one or two - more highly alloyed irons in planes. They like a little extra. It's so stuck as what feels right that 35 or 30 feels unbelievably steep or shallow. It's probably difficult to deviate more than a degree. I use the same angle for everything and with generally two bevels - one grind, one lift. The grind is generally about 5 degrees shy of the lift, but it's not for a functional reason. The honing angle is the same every time no matter what the grind is. Less pronounced and faster to refresh on chisels - I've never measured them. They may not be quite as steep.