Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

final bevel angle poll

Posts

final bevel angle poll

#1

final bevel angle poll

David Weaver

I hope bill doesn't mind me sharing his thoughts, but he's somewhat concerned that the 35 degree tertiary microbevel that I'm using isn't really reflective of typical plane use.

Over the years, I have (by results, not by measurement) come to freehand hone to about 33 degrees for my final work because it seems to yield better edge strength and fewer strange defects. I haven't looked around much at what other people are doing since then.

Part of the abrasive experiment is to see in a common pitch plane if I'm giving up any edge life due to use of 33 or 35 degrees or whatever it is, and it doesn't appear to be any or much in the iterations I've done.

What's your final angle, especially if you use a guide and know what it is?

If you're using a grinder angle and then lifting the iron slightly on your final stone, add 2 or 3 degrees or whatever you think is appropriate. You can reply in the subject line for ease.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#2

33 degrees final final bevel


Re: final bevel angle poll

#3

Re: 33 degrees final final bevel

E Phillip Smith

I hollow grind at 30 degrees and freehand sharpen at 30 degrees with diamond. This is with CPM M4 plane iron.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#4

Re: final bevel angle poll

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, I hollow grind at 30 degrees, and then freehand on the hollow - so 30 degrees. I use this angle for all steels in BD planes.

When I was testing PM-V11 vs A2 shooting end grain with the LN #51, I did try the PM-V11 at 25 degrees. It did not fare well. Changing up to 30 degrees produced a significant improvement.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: final bevel angle poll

#5

Re: final bevel angle poll

Oskar

I´m above 30 I´m sure but I don´t know exactly, could be just shy of 35. Maybe I can measure later. I always freehand.

My experience so far is that one can go even higher, maybe 35 or 40 since when clearance runs out its time to sharpen anyway. That is, dullness become an issue before clearance does.

I´ve been reading a lot here lately, thanks for posting this flood of interesting observations David!

Re: final bevel angle poll

#6

Re: final bevel angle poll

david weaver

Thanks for the data point, Oskar. I'm in your camp as far as clearance goes. I could probably get a little more and push bevel angle, but I want predictability. I end up about 33 freehand, but probably don't get better edge duration than 35 as a final microbevel in a guide.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#8

Re: Jigged 32*

david weaver

Thanks, chuck.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#9

Re: final bevel angle poll

Sgian Dubh

I haven't a precise answer. I generally freehand grind on a grindstone of one sort or another at an angle that 'looks' about right, then freehand the honing angle, which is basically the grinding angle, and up a bit. My freehand grinding is probably somewhere near 30º, but I've never measured to find out. I guess that's because the guy, more than one actually, that taught me how to do the job a few decades ago didn't bother with setting anything to get a preferred angle, and I just followed suit.

Perhaps none of the previous is of much help to you, ha, ha, but my planes and chisels all work, and that's all that matters to me. Slainte.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#10

I'll pencil you in as 90º then!

david weaver

In all seriousness, I can't imagine why you'd ever have to measure.

When I first started, I was all over all of the angles, making jigs, and an engineering friend of mine made diagrams. They are actually still on the wall (more proof that I am not one to clean up anything unless forced, and they occupy a space that just isn't used).

When I started to work mostly by hand, I kind of rebelled against measuring things that didn't need to be measured (including workpieces - if able, set out the basic dimensions from the start then mark off the piece and measure as little as possible).

Until this topic came up here a year or two ago, I didn't have a clue what my final angle was, but was afraid I'd be embarrassed to find that it was 28 degrees or 38 degrees or something. It ended up being precisely in the middle. Proven good through use of tools. The results are there - other than discussion, that eliminates the need to measure.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#11

I forgot to say...there's much value..

david weaver

..in what you said. We don't have to measure everything and overanalyze. This study wasn't really something I wanted to do, but I figured that I'd like to know more about the process than others might disclose, and I wanted to control variables.

In the process, I've bought a stick of CarTech XHP to make a few bits and bobs that I'll never really need. Curiosity can lead me to waste time.

The value in what you've said is something that I should put in print in my final write-up. If you are not measuring what you're doing, but you're getting the results you want, measuring is more likely to waste your time and send you down paths you don't need to go down than it is to improve anything.

I don't set the rest on my grinder any longer, either, and haven't for quite a while. There's no need to - it's set at 90 degrees and I can then grind to whatever seems appropriate rather than worrying about adjusting it for this or that tool that's thicker or thinner than the last.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#12

Re: Probably closer to 86.25º

Sgian Dubh

Well, I'm a little surprised, but also pleased my contribution added something of value for you.

In truth, I've been watching your series of threads and posts on steels, burrs and sharpening with some interest. Most of what you've discussed has been more technical than I've been willing to put serious time into developing a good understanding of on my part.

I've known for a number of years that different makers use different steels for plane irons and chisels, but I've never really thought about how one type of steel compares to another in terms of sharpening, edge retention, and the like. In the case of my own tools, most of which are aged many years, decades, and some even a century or more old, I know them all well enough to sharpen as and when needed.

On the other hand, when I'm in, for example, a teaching situation, I am frequently presented with all sorts of chisels, planes, and other tools by the learner owners, and then there's whatever kit is kicking around in the learning facility's tool cupboards. In that situation if a need to sharpen presents itself, I just get on and do the same as I always do, i.e., just 'Sharp'n'Go' as I describe it, using whatever kind of sharpening stone(s) and grinding kit is available - many examples of which are a much abused. The point I'm getting to is that I've never really noticed difficulty sharpening plane irons from brands I've not really come across before, with the same applying to various makes of chisels. One thing I have observed is that some plane irons and chisels seem to be made out of what I call monkey metal: soft, won't really come to a fine edge in the first place, and then either chip easily, or fold over in use. Slainte.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#13

Re: Probably closer to 86.25º

david weaver

Monkey metal, rubber steel, pure carbides...

.. I think if one wasn't told about various sharpening regimes and carbides, etc, they might not think about it too much.

the poor man's M2 in the chinese iron will get your attention if you attempt to flatten it, but it sharpened perfectly fine on an india stone, arkansas stone and strop. Would it fail to last like it does with diamonds? I'm sure it would lose some edge life.

what's the goal is the question, I guess? I will probably sink back to my normal habits within a month. That is, if something doesn't seem to last long enough, increase shaving thickness, sharpen as quickly as possible. I do like the cast on diamonds, though - it's very practical. Perhaps not necessary and demanding (the plate that phil sent to me to evaluate his iron is actually pin straight and flat, unlike I've ever seen before, but one has to be willing to iron those issues out).

The biggest sin that I see in planes in use when I have bought used tools that were in current use is lack of finishing of the sharpening process. None have been exceptionally finely sharpened that I can recall, but that's not the worst thing in the world if sharpening is actually completed. I don't have the experience that you do with teaching individuals, so I don't know what's practical and what's not at this point for beginners, and I'm sure once I write up all of this stuff, I'll be quoted as saying all sorts of things that the report doesn't actually say, or linked to making recommendations that I never made.

The two things from it that I wanted to find out, though, if anything - how much potential difference in longevity for V11, which had 3V and M4 added - turns out to be more than I expected. Could I have lived without knowing and without using them? Sure.

And a quantification of clearance angle since I am often told that anything over 30 is counterproductive, and I used 35 in this test for ease of method. That turns out to have less of an effect so far than even I expected, but I also didn't know which way it would go, either.

I've got a youtube channel where I've detailed making planes. From time to time, I get a snarky commenter who thinks the idea of using a washita or arkansas stones is antiquated, slow and hokey. My first recommendation for someone who despises sharpening is always, learn to sharpen faster and to do it with a method that ensures you complete sharpening each time. We don't skip parts of the lawn on purpose so that we can come back later and make extra laps, and we don't purposely push the lawn mower as slow as possible and measure every blade of grass.

I still think learning to sharpen quickly is more valuable than switching steels, and I've learned more about planing productivity from soft steels than I have from hard ones.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#14

Re: Probably closer to 86.25º

Sgian Dubh

"I don't have the experience that you do with teaching individuals, so I don't know what's practical and what's not at this point for beginners, and I'm sure once I write up all of this stuff, I'll be quoted as saying all sorts of things that the report doesn't actually say, or linked to making recommendations that I never made."

Well, when it comes to teaching, if that's ever likely for you, and specifically teaching sharpening to beginners, my advice is use the KISS principle. That is, don't get too technical: all this stuff you've been outlining in this hand tool forum would probably blow the mind of beginners, bore them to hell and back, and more than likely put them off the idea of ever continuing developing woodworking skills.

So, teaching freehand sharpening, my method because I can't stand all that pointless farting about with prissy guides and all the rest of the nonsense that goes with it, consists of a basic combination oilstone, some 3 in 1 oil, a rag, a blunt chisel (or plane iron), and a demonstration of how to hold the blunt tool as it's whisked up and down the stone, followed by a bit of flipping of the sharpened tool on the palm of the hand, and back to work.

If a combination oilstone isn't to hand, any other stone type will do, e.g., Japanese water stone, ceramic, diamond, and I'll even tolerate demonstrating the technique using abrasive paper on a flat surface (another, in my biased and cynical opinion, overly precious and pointlessly complex sharpening method involving too many ever finer grades of abrasive paper).

Once the learner(s) have got the basics, you can move on to discussing and demonstrating methods for creating a more refined edge, e.g., moving on to finer stones, and a bit of leather and fine abrasive to finish off to get a really sharp edge.

As I strongly suspect you are aware, I'm not into making an essential and basic skill (sharpening) into a complex, mysterious and unnecessarily difficult process. As I said earlier, I'm a Sharp'n'Go man: I generally sharpen as much as I need for a particular job, and no more, but I can and do sharpen to a higher standard if the task in front of me demands it.

As a final aside, in this response I've deliberately not mentioned the regrinding process - I've said enough already. Slainte.

Re: final bevel angle poll

#15

Re: Probably closer to 86.25º

david weaver

I don't know if I typed it already, but I've taught a few people at work to sharpen knives. I pointed them to a combination india stone, and they are happy.

Though it's not stylish, my ideal sharpening setup for a beginner would be an india stone, a washita stone (or some other medium fine arkansas stone that could cut fast enough to ensure they could actually use it) and a piece of plain leather.

None of this stuff about microns would ever come up. We'd never get out of the first class if it did.

One of the local class instructors here asked if I'd be interested in getting the materials together to coordinate teaching his students to make a wooden plane. He saw my double iron planes (I sold him my old bench) and said he has about a half dozen students who are potentially interested in working entirely by hand.

I thought about it for a second and told him I didn't think I was cut out to teach. I'm cut out to experiment and make things for myself. I can teach someone else who wants to do the same thing or try to learn how to be curious and solve problems that maybe they wanted to avoid at first glance (basically my role at work with one or two people at a time). People who will take information and run with it without any curiosity, that's not for me. It's all or none. Teaching people at work to sharpen knives with an india stone is a sort of none thing. I think it works well. It looks like "all" to them just to learn to sharpen something, and it makes a perfectly functional knife or scissors ("you can sharpen scissors!!??. They work so well now!!").