Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abrasives and angles

Posts

Abrasives and angles

#1

Abrasives and angles

David Weaver

All done on the ward iron to determine if follow up on longer wearing irons is necessary.

- 35 degrees, 1 micron diamond - 667 feet

- 35 degrees, 5 micron diamond - 410 feet

- 35 degrees, Dan's black Arkansas- 561 feet

- 30 degrees, 1 micron diamond - 612 feet

The feel of the 1 micron edge is superior. I'm not sure I see or feel any reason to perform this test with other irons

Re: Abrasives and angles

#2

Re: Abrasives and angles

E Phillip Smith

Is that 1 micron diamond on cast iron plate?

Re: Abrasives and angles

#3

Re: Abrasives and angles

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

Ditto Phil’s question.

Also, if there are pre-planing edge photos of the 1u/35 vs. 5u/35, that might be revealing, given the longer run of the finer honed iron. This is the fine vs. coarse test Bill T. Has been asking for forever.

If the diamond was on cast iron, a third run with 1u/35, plus final strop with 1u on hardwood would extend the test to ultra-fine vs. fine vs. coarse. Especially since the runs so far establish 35 as likely optimum or near-optimum for this iron on this wood.

Great work!

Wiley

Re: Abrasives and angles

#4

Re: Abrasives and angles

David Weaver

Yes. There's a step up in polish by finishing on hardwood, but I think it's just aesthetic. At least mostly. The cast is pure joy to use.

The bigger diamond, I used brass. I just don't want to contaminate the cast with it. The sharpness and ease of cut even from 1 to 3 microns on brass is stark. 5 is almost intolerable. I was surprised.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#5

Re: Abrasives and angles

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would have liked to see the test done on the steel most people use Hock or Lee valley O1.

I will have go find the paper where the work is described, but K&K found 30 degrees optimum and 35 degrees substantially worse (I think I recall).

How common is 35 degrees for a plane blade? If 30 degrees is typical there is probably a reason 30 degrees is typical.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#6

please clarify

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The sharpness and ease of cut even from 1 to 3 microns on brass is stark. 5 is almost intolerable. I was surprised

I don't understand what you are saying. What does sharpness and ease mean? What was intolerable? I use diamond on cast iron up to 15 micron , and even occasionally 30 micron, and nothing struck me as intolerable.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#7

Re: Abrasives and angles

David Weaver

I can do that. I do have pre-planing pictures, just didn't take edge pictures during and after because we know already what they'll look like. The ward iron looks the same in the end every time.

I'll need to redo a couple of these with that since this board is too thin for more passes.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#8

Re: please clarify

David Weaver

The difference in planing resistance. The plane feels dull with a 3 micron finish compared to 1, and 5 feels very dull. The plane goes into the cut very easily with the smaller abrasive and the entire cycle is easier smoother planing.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#9

Re: Abrasives and angles

David Weaver

30 or so is the grind. 32 is secondary and 35 is a small tertiary bevel. What bed angle did K and K use?

The edge is stronger and gets fewer defects at 33 or more, but much more and there are clearance issues.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#10

Re: Abrasives and angles

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

I hear you about commercial steel. Valid point, but the test with the Ward iron is valid to test the proposition. Not conclusive of course. I asked about the pre-planing pictures to see if the 5u iron had visibly more tooth than when sharpened to 1u.

I said 35 appears ‘near optimum for that iron on that steel’ because it had a 10% better result than the same test run on a more acute angle. I suppose one could hold out for 33.

Wiley

Re: Abrasives and angles

#11

Re: Abrasives and angles

Wiley Horne

David,

I asked about the pictures of the freshly sharpened irons because you got a 50% better result with the 1u sharpening than with the 5u, and I was curious whether there was a visible difference in the ‘tooth’ between the two.

Wiley

Re: Abrasives and angles

#12

Oh, I thought you were talking about the sharpenin

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

got it. The metallurgist says that scratches initiate chipping (creates a concentrated stress point). Interesting to see if you see evidence of chipping at 5 micron. I was predicting the roughness would smooth itself and settle about the same as 1 micron. Isn't research grand. Nice to get surprises

BTW, what is a Ward Iron?

Re: Abrasives and angles

#13

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is the difference planing after 5 micron vs 1 different enough that I could experience it confidently?

Re: Abrasives and angles

#14

Re: PS

David Weaver

You would feel it in beech very easily. I agree on a larger scale with the metallurgist that any defect sort of breaks up to a point and then smooths over, leaving bluntness. I just didn't expect it to be so drastic at what would be equivalent to a 3000 grit waterstone.

Ward is ward and Payne. A good quality vintage laminated iron.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#15

Re: Abrasives and angles

David Weaver

The edge on both looks smooth, but the surface finish looks much different. I'm guessing that the 5 micron edge rounds quickly as all of the grooves start to wear off.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#16

Re: Abrasives and angles

Brian Holcombe

This is very interesting, thanks for compiling such data.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#17

Re: PS

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

In the calculus of grit, a 3000g waterstone can be rated on paper as 5u. But as you know better than I, diamond makes deep scratches that punch way above their micron rating. Especially since a 5u-rated diamond compound has a statistical distribution of rocks that go well above 5u at 1 or 2 sigmas out. NOt preaching at you, you know this better than I.

Wiley

Re: Abrasives and angles

#18

Re: PS

David Weaver

Yes on that, it's a relatively harsh finish at that level and even micron to micron more coarse than a chosera 3000 stone, which leaves a dissatisfying starting edge.

I'll post the pictures of the edges later. The edge itself under the scope actually looked pretty decent, though. I can't convey how crappy it was at entering the cut, though. I expected it to be a little bit more tolerable. Over on the UK site, there are still site guys who fit with a plane finished on a fine India. It just really increases the physical work needed to make the plane operate. At least twice as much and the planing is far less accurate.

Re: Abrasives and angles

#19

If the schedule allows today..

David Weaver

..doing some review work for the daytime gig today, but if I get done early enough this evening, I'm going to run this test again with LN and my house O1.

I know bill prefers named irons, but I have hock and mine. Mine fits in the LN, which is the best test bed for all results, and now I have a baseline with the ward.

So, I will use my iron. I think it's reliable.

I'll test a little bit more for bill's concern about 30 degrees vs. 35, though Steve Elliot has already documented that somewhere in between the two on an infill bed seems to provide the best results for most steels in terms of longevity vs. quality. If quality gets bad enough, it threatens longevity.

It is unlikely that I will do these tests with a more long wearing steel before writing up all of these experiments, but I will take more pictures in this second iteration. I don't expect they'll show much, but will see if I can be proven wrong. I think what happens on the coarser abrasives is the initial edge fails at the groove depth and it leaves a more rounded blunt edge. I had hoped that once this was blasted off, I'd find the edge similar to finer abrasives (looking for a cheap easy way to get sharpening with one grind and one bevel - this is ideal for freehand). I'm not finding that, and this probably threatens my beloved washita for finishing stones!!

(I can do a freehand iteration with washita, too, so that I can be embarrassed).