Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

images at 1360 feet from last test

Posts

images at 1360 feet from last test

#1

images at 1360 feet from last test

david weaver

3v - this picture is misleading because the focus wasn't set right to see all of the grooves in the back wear bevel.


V11


and m4


for comparison, here is an image of 3v at 1020 feet.


and for a sideshow, the ward edge last night at 30 degrees after 550 feet (it was not entering the cut at this point...at all)


The ward is not as finely sharpened, but it wears evenly, anyway, without any defects occurring.

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#2

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

Wiley Horne

David,

Very very interesting! Three powder metal alloy steels and one vintage plain carbon. For the alloy steels, the iron-carbon lattice (tempered martensite) is the matrix in which the alloy carbides are embedded. For the Ward, it is all matrix, all tempered martensite, and given its wear rate, probably not many if any carbides (Fe3C).

Pure guesswork interpretation: For all 4 blades, the carbon steel matrix wears away first. For the Ward iron, which is homogeneous carbon steel, this leads to even wear.* For the alloy steels, the loss of matrix exposes an increasingly ‘rocky’ surface dominated by alloy carbides. More rugged and rocky according to the total carbide presence, thus highest for M4. Eventually, the alloy carbides get sufficiently exposed by loss of matrix, that the shear of the wood fibres begins to spall them off.

Wiley

*Wonder how Hitachi white steel would wear—it is also homogeneous tempered martensite, but with carbides due to higher C content.

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#3

some wear fundamentals

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have made contact with a metallurgist that has provided a wealth of technical support to the knife community. One of his contributions is to build a model of all the known steel variables that contribute to blade edge life from wear. Plug in the steel composition, hardness, etc and out pops a ranking of how that steel will wear under conditions not far removed from planing. He has provided days of reading material which I am wading through slowly as it is dense. Will summarize in the end.

But I am getting hints of why V11 wears so well. Almost 1/4 of this steel is a finely divided carbide, far more than M4 or 3V. Furthermore, finely divided carbides perform well to resist abrasion by a fine abrasive, like cellulose and lignin and a trace of mineral content (AKA wood), while at the same time yield to large pointy harder abrasives (AKA sharpening stones). The magic of powder metallurgy.

The knife people are decades ahead of us in understanding steel and taking advantage of different steels for different tasks. His information rationalizes why V11 is up there with M4 in wood abrasion yet far behind as a tool steel. It is quite likely if a knife company chose to build plane blades they would have quickly arrived at a steel similar to V11.

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#4

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

david weaver

That sounds like as good of an explanation for the view of the iron surfaces as any to me. Though my testing stops at the what in terms of publishing results, and less about the why.

I also wonder about the higher fe carbide irons that are well made so that the carbides are evenly distributed, but I only have japanese white steel in japanese planes, and they're all 8/10bu. I could build a temporary dai, but I think the design of the plane, the weight proportions, downforce, etc, is all too different for it to be comparable to these results.

Stan mentioned that he's seen white steel plane irons being made in some shops in japan (western style irons), but I don't know if that's in small quantity. I'd guess that it would probably plane for about as long as the hock iron and my O1 iron, perhaps as long as the A2 iron. That's just a guess, though.

I looked around for white rikizai (I've bought some powder metal bars ,too, to see how good a PM shop-made iron can be, knowing that it may come up a little short compared to the good ones), and I could only find three layer white rikizai. I would love to be able to find it in two layers thick enough to warm forge and then hand thin/scrape and oil quench. It's not to be at this point.

I think it would look a lot like the ward, though. Even the O1 gives no evidence that it wants to give up anything other than even looking wear. Maybe the particles are too small to be seen optically, that's possible. Both the hock and my iron looked very similar under the microscope, and very similar to the ward.

I will finish giving the ward some proper preparation on the back and sharpen it identically to the others used in the test to make sure that I have a good number for it. I expect that it will be similar, but it won't be hard to finish the job. It's much easier to test a plane iron that lasts 150 strokes than one that lasts close to 700.

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#5

K&K SEM pictures

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

left 40 m right 100m bevel side M2 not particle steel


Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#6

Re: K&K SEM pictures

david weaver

I can't see their wood quality, but they're seeing what I saw with some of my irons. The initial thinner bevel is less even after some wear, but as the wear accumulates, the line that represents the bevel edge becomes more uniform. Of course, that doesn't mean that the part of the bevel facing us is that uniform.

I noticed in terms of quality that obviously as the surface dulls a little bit, perfection is easier to attain. The super bright polish off of M4 and V11 at the outset is an almost impossible standard to meet. O1, tsunesaburo and ward irons did not provide the same quality and the hock developed a very short term dull stripe from a defect that occurred off of the initial edge and then "healed" itself with wear and the surface was uniform again.

At any rate, some of the alloy irons developed intermittent small chips, but they would come and go with wear.

The interesting things is that if wear was uneven but over a wide area that wasn't abrupt nicks, it didn't really appear as something you could see. In both maple tests, these occurred in the more highly alloyed irons, and then as the irons got "closer to death", more of them would appear. In heart beech on the main test, I didn't see much in terms of defects. I think the wood was just too pleasant to cause it, but it was a little more dry and dusty feeling than the follow up beech test (which did present smaller transient defects in the alloy irons). Strangely, the wood that ended up causing no defects still wore the irons faster. That leads me to believe that very small defects really don't have much of an effect on edge life unless a bunch show up unusually early (which would suggest diamonds).

I think there are mysteries even with the SEM pictures that will make it hard to decipher why each iron stopped where it did. A three dimensional flash-type model that you could turn around and see through and measure would be nice. That's probably a bit futuristic for this kind of thing, though, and the findings are the findings - I'm going to avoid much of the rabbit hole of why because it's less useful than what for someone looking to buy an iron and after this testing is done and results written, it'll probably become a distant memory (to me) because I wasn't looking to change anything. Though I will incorporate the fantastic piece of cast that Phil provided to me. If I find that it actually improves the ward's longevity, it may be a regular finish step for me. The wire edge that's created on the alloy irons is something that on 1 micron diamonds will just never show up on carbon steel or O1.

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#7

Re: (also)

david weaver

...it'd be a whole lot easier to determine what's what if all of the carbides just came in different colors.

"look, all of the purple parts are gone, and the red and green is left. Purple is tungsten, so tungsten isn't helpful in wood".

I guess the irons would be brown looking and pretty ugly if that were the case, though.

(can't always keep the train of thought in a creative mind from being wacky and going several steps into what if scenarios that make no sense to ponder).

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#8

compare pictures

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These surfaces don't look like your photographs. I don't see carbide lumps sticking up nor divots where there used to be carbide grains. The steel is ordinary M2.

I had an impossible time imaging shiny metal surfaces until I had access to the magical lighting of the metallurgical scope. I could image edges but not surfaces.

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#9

Re: compare pictures

david weaver

I don't think they would, because the SEM would illuminate everything including the stuff that's dark in the optical pictures.

It does strike me that one of the A2 pictures that you'd sent of the coated blades looks a little bit (the optical ones) like the pictures we've come up with.

It makes it clear that anything optical at high magnification is a matter of "it looks like" and not "it is". It may be both, but the difference in the looks of the PM vs. the plain steels may be more about what shows up visibly than what really is.

Re: images at 1360 feet from last test

#10

agree on all points

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

BTW, you are getting extraordinary pictures from the gear you have. Better than I got for a while out of a professional lab whose job it was to get photomicrographs.