Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

For amusement only, chip breakers

Posts

For amusement only, chip breakers

#1

For amusement only, chip breakers

Rum

From lee-valleys (no longer in print) reprint of "Popular Mechanics: The Boy Mechanic vol #2" circa 1913-1924.

I thought at least some here would find this amusing, what is old.. is often new again.. is old again.


Re: For amusement only, chip breakers

#2

Some things get rediscovered regularly


Re: For amusement only, chip breakers

#3

to far?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1/32 is 0.7mm which is several times greater than the set backs K&K employed (.1 to .3 mm).

Re: For amusement only, chip breakers

#4

Re: to far? possibly...

Rum

I've been working on my "ability to avoid actually measuring anything" (limited success, but happier when achieved.. not measure != no comparisons/guaging just no arbitrary numbers) so the "set together tip down on soft scrap, angle slightly towards the chip breaker, lock in place" has been my current modus operandi.. at least for smooth planes.

That's perhaps a bit close for some woods/plane types though... in those cases it quickly becomes obvious and resort to the Mark-I eyeball. I suspect 1/32 was derivative of a similarily fine gradiation of measurement in the original argument and may well have been well undre 1/64 in actuality.

Re: For amusement only, chip breakers

#5

Re: to far?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We use a much wider range than just .1 to .3 mm. I don’t think Kato and Kawai were woodworkers.

Re: For amusement only, chip breakers

#6

Re: to far? possibly...

Brian Holcombe

I think measuring the chip breaker setback is very tough to do and probably not as useful as tuning to the chip. Doesn’t take long before you get a feel for eyeing the setback.

I assume the author of that note did the same thing and when put on the spot he probably just decided to say 1/32”.

When I do planing seminars or classes I have simply refused to provide a simple answer to that question, but I happily show people my setting and how the setting changes the result. The take-away is that it’s a setting very much reliant upon the situation, depth of cut and type of wood grain.

Re: For amusement only, chip breakers

#7

K&K tutorial

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Kato and Kawai taught at a technical school. They developed a tutorial for planing for the students going out into whatever are the Japanese trades. We have only translated part of the tutorial. They taught that if the shaving scrunches up like an accordion it is too close. Just right is between there and normal curl, that is to say if the cap iron is working it shows up in shaving longitudinal compression, which of course is how it mitigates grain lifting.

Re: For amusement only, chip breakers

#8

Re: K&K tutorial

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I introduced the accordion shaving concept on this forum years ago. Since then David Weaver, Kees Hayden, Steve Vogt, Brian Holcombe, and others have expounded on using the shaving as diagnostic tool. We can also judge the surface the plane leaves behind. An experienced user can feel these things with eyes closed.