Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Caution on using company "wear" data

Posts

Caution on using company "wear" data

#1

Caution on using company "wear" data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Continuing to poke around for fundamental information that would explain the qualitative ordering of the edge life of these steels I found that some of the published data on wear may be useless for our purposes. The Crucible Products data is most likely determined by an ASTM test where metal rubs on metal. Good data for a die or cutting steel. But this wear includes adhesive wear, irrelevant to wood planing. Wood is mechanically too weak to bond and then pull pieces of metal from the plane blade. While this kind of data comparing 3V and M4 shows that M4 has much better wear resistance we have no clue how these steels compare if the adhesive wear component is removed. Bottom line: the company data may not be of predictive value for planing wood. We may have to go to the knife people to get data comparing the abrasion resistance of these steels.

Re: Caution on using company "wear" data

#2

Re: Caution on using company "wear" data

david weaver

Knife people are a good start once edge geometry and finish is controlled. There are people on youtube who describe their sharpening and then do something relatively easily repeated, like cutting rope. What I see from folks in terms of results slicing seems to translate well to planing (not surprisingly).

I've always discounted wear data to some extent because I think little of it is generated at angles around 25-35 degrees of angle. What I've learned is that there is a lot of relevance to the wear data, but assuming proportional application vs. charts online just doesn't seem to occur.

I feel like there's more in the tank for the M4 - I'm still sitting on the pictures from this test (haven't uploaded them yet), but something causes it to have grip in the wood and I can't help but think that this affects the test results. What causes this? I get the sense (without proving it) that it would be vastly superior to V11 in something harder than wood. It (PM M4) is nicely behaved on the diamond laps and released its wire edge with less of a fight than 3V in the little that I've sharpened it.

3V also has a little of that grip, but not as much. Still curious about what makes V11 slippery in the cut. I'm guessing chromium, and that 440C would do the same, except 440C has a top hardness that really isn't very good for planing (mid to upper 50s, practically) when it comes to wear resistance. Something I could easily notice on razors, too - the friodur razors take a fine edge, but they will not match a carbon steel razor for holding the fine edge. Just as well, many razors have been sharpened on natural stones for eons, and 440C at 62 hardness wouldn't have gone over well.

Re: Caution on using company "wear" data

#3

affects results but not conclusions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

M4 - something causes it to have grip in the wood and I can't help but think that this affects the test results.

Must keep in mind the experiment was a practical performance test. Some unexpected attribute of the steel might result in an unexpected conclusion but the fact this steel planes farther than that, under these experimental conditions, remains valid. The "why" remains to be discovered.