Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Chromium speculation

Posts

Chromium speculation

#1

Chromium speculation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

So what is the property of V11 that imparts superior edge life? It could be a more advanced particle steel than 3V. I keep finding references saying the particle process results in enhanced wear and improved grindability. Or it could be corrosion resistance. It is known that a corrosion resistant coating prolongs edge life for router bits, but that cutting environment may have little to do with hand planing, or not.

K&K have a series of papers that are translated but not read by me yet that involve coating Supersurfacer blade with chromium on one side. My recollection was that wear went to near zero on this side. Perhaps in these papers they speculate on what property of the chromium resists wear. 2nd granddaughter arrives for a week shortly so it is unlikely I will study these papers before next week. stay tuned

Re: Chromium speculation

#2

Re: Chromium speculation

David Weaver

I wonder that while I'm using it. It's slicker through the cut than the other irons, but it's not a matter of sharpness. What is it? It's not like it actually gets sharper. All of these irons silently remove hair after the sharpening process. Not hair pops off or anything like that, it lays over on the blade without being pushed over.

Not going to go into that, but it's a higher level of sharpness than hairs popping up.

3V has a little bit of cut resistance, which is what led me to go another round, and now I'm comfortable that I didn't bungle up the first test with poor sharpening, I just has a bit of back bevel wire at the corners, which didn't get into the cut.

Again this time, 3V had a little more cut resistance. Both carbon steels did, too. Same plane, same cap iron, etc (Except for 3V) for all of the steels. Do the vanadium carbides in 3V and M4 give it some grip? I don't know.

One can figure that V11 is loaded with chromium by the fact that stuff around it on the plane will rust and it won't.

Re: Chromium speculation

#3

Work not relevant

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have had a chance to look at these reports. Kato was investigating "self sharpening" in wood cutting blades and bits. The bevel of the blade was coated with something abrasion resistant and the base metal was something that would wear. Chromium and vanadium carbide coatings were investigated. The "soft" metal wore faster than the bevel coating resulting in the persistence of a relatively sharp cutting edge with clearance. Neat SEM pictures of the progress. Interesting but of little relevance to hand planing.