Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

a day of planing in my shop

Posts

a day of planing in my shop

#1

a day of planing in my shop

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Once when I was extolling the virtues of "infinite" edge life W.Pan asked in exasperation whether I was Superman. Didn't I need the break offered by the need to sharpen? I realized we lived in different worlds.



I was recently fitting coped M&T joints. Ideally, the front and back (back towards viewer) intersections mate perfectly. Anticipating not ideally, I work to ensure the back comes together at the same time or before the front show intersection. If the back is tight and the front has a tiny gap the joint is rendered perfect by shaving the back surface until both front and back mate coincident. At most a few or as few as 1 shaving is taken. Surface quality irrelevant. If the plane picks up a shaving the operation is a success.



Once the joints are assembled into a door it is common for me that the stile and rail are off-set more or less. A few passes with the plane is the best way to level the joint. If the plane picks up a shaving, and there is no tear out- success. It will all be sanded before staining.



Cases are assembled with half tails. If the tail is tight it is thinned by removing shavings until the fit is perfect.

These are three examples of operations critical to a good fit and certainly not demanding of plane or planer. Annoyance is getting part way though any of them and having the plane become too dull to pick up a shaving. Given the piddly, but critical, amount of planing I do, it would be grand to get though the entire project without the need to sharpen till the piece is done. Then put everything in perfect order to begin the next project with confidence unexpected dulling would not show up to spoil the day. .

The apparent 2X shaving lifting edge life David found for some blade steel over others is a huge advantage to me.

Re: a day of planing in my shop

#2

another day of planing in my shop

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


After making doors it comes to fitting doors. If much has to be removed the quickness and reliability of the power jointer is used. But in this case the reveal between the doors was not quite perfect. Shaving < 1/32 off a door is less reliable on the jointer. The hand plane reliably removes .002, more or less, at a time to enable sneaking up on the perfect fit.

Chalk up another 8 linear feet of planing. The claims of others to the contrary I don't believe there is any way to keep track of the dulling while planing these tasks, widely separated in time. Failure to pick up a shaving, or a nasty spot of torn grain, arrives as an unanticipated event. I would have preferred to do this edge with a #2, for I have a better time balancing it on the edge. But it's blade was too dull to perform. Seems like I just sharpened it not long ago. No recollection what it has been used for.

Re: a day of planing in my shop

#3

Re: another day of planing in my shop

David Weaver

I completely get it. I don't mind sharpening at all in the middle of a session when I'm doing a lot of planing.

If I am fitting something later and need to take off 10 or 20 feet of shavings and the plane is on the edge of not lifting the shaving, it just doesn't feel like a time that I want to sharpen a plane, and I'll end up doing the same as you did - pick up another plane.

Fortunately, the cap iron generally prevents damage if a plane is dull vs. a without scenario where you might be tempted to advance the iron until you get a cut.

Re: a day of planing in my shop

#4

Re: another day of planing in my shop

Hank Knight

I've gotten myself into the habit of touching up the iron when I'm done with a sharpening session before I put the plane black on the shelf; so it's always ready when I next pick it up.

Re: a day of planing in my shop

#5

It's not just you. Precision fitting

Chuck Nickerson

is like an Ionic Volute for me. If I have to stop for sharpening it brings me out of the chase and evolving judgement of when to quit.