Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

No additional results so far..

Posts

No additional results so far..

#1

No additional results so far..

david weaver

...finished the maple test on 3V and V11 and then started a test on cherry to see how my O1 compares to hock. Not because I was going to, but bill suggested that I be able to make a note in the report how it compares to a commercial iron.

Pretty close so far, but after 800 feet each, both my iron and the hock are still planing. The hock is obviously slightly harder, but only just. The edge looks finer under the scope in most places because of the hardness (with the wear level), but it leaves tiny visible lines on cherry.

I don't have the picks handy, but the cherry has left strange abrasions on my iron (some on the hock, but less prominent) that don't nick the edge all the way through but look pretty garish. No clue what they are. They occur off and on through the entire used edge length - more wide and shallow.

what in cherry would do that? Not a mineral issue like maple, as they're not visible to the naked eye and the surface quality on the wood still shows nothing.

i have a feeling the hock will last 100 feet more than mine when all is said and done, and I'll have been wrong about edge life being better slightly less hard (quality is slightly better, but it'll take another shop session to determine edge life).

Back to settling the 3V and V11 thing in beech after this, and then on to the more interesting and instructive tests of edge life with 5 degrees more clearance and coarser abrasives. As well as a test of Phil's nicely made CPM M4 iron.

I have some other things i want to see, too - like a test of edge life pulling the plane backwards on a surface under its own weight (something few people admit to, but I'd bet a lot of people do - I don't, not for edge life, but because it's more physical work to lean on the plane both ways). And I want to put a plane down on a freshly sharpened blade and see if any damage occurs.

Re: No additional results so far..

#2

house O1 - 1052 feet, Hock 992 feet

David Weaver

That's the results of the house O1 in cherry vs. the hock in the same piece of wood, alternating every 200 feet.

House O1 appears to have more wear, but slightly more uniform.

I think the difference between the two is insignificant and could be attributable to the LN plane being better fitted than the old Record.

This should give a purchaseable point of reference for the O1 results in the test (interchangeable with a hock iron).

Re: No additional results so far..

#3

excellent

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Now you have a "stake in the ground" that every planer is familiar with that all your other work can be compared to, including the home made blade.

Conclusions:

1. David can make a blade as good as a commercially made blade.

Alternative conclusion

1. There was discussion somewhere back that Hock blades were lacking. Confirmed they are as good as David's, or visa versa depending how one wants to look at it.

2. If there is a hardness difference between these blades that data show that it is not significant in feet planed to failure. (you need to get hardness tested on your blade)

Re: No additional results so far..

#4

Re: excellent

david weaver

I'm partly responsible for that (discussion about thinking the hock blades could be better with better stock or lower hardness). I thought that I could make a better blade than hock just because of their hardness - I thought they'd be better a couple of clicks less.

This is on the hard side of O1 blades for me (the one in this test), but it is below chippy. It's not really a matter of skill in making it, I just made it, tried it, then put it in the oven increasing temper a little bit until it stops showing any surface irregularities. That seems to be about 380 or 390 degrees with starrett O1.

But, I was wrong about durability. The hock lasted right with it and surface quality was little different. I guess this is about the most distance one could get from O1 unless there were some other more advanced tricks.

Next test, re-do of 3V and V11 in beech, and Phil's iron will go into the mix since these two irons will give it a chance to be in rotation in a board for a while. I'd prefer not to have any iron planing a whole bunch of distance by itself in a board because there's nothing relative to compare it to then if there's something about the wood that bungles an iron.

Re: No additional results so far..

#5

Even when something isn't especially..

david weaver

..skillful, I guess you can still do it wrong.

O1 is really forgiving, but I have a very ideal setup to heat and quench irons. With one mapp torch, a coffee can forge heats an iron like this relatively slowly so you don't run much risk of overheating it, but it still gets uniformly hot (vs. just trying to use a torch against bricks, etc) inside once it's heated.

It's more like cooking. Choose good ingredients, use decent equipment, pay attention. Results will be good. Try to short one of those things, and results may not be good. At least with O1, even then, they'll still be usable.

if I had a manservant in the house, I'd have him testing all kinds of things all day. I'm curious now about how long a good stock stanley iron would last, because I still really like a good stock stanley iron just as much. I don't think they'll last quite as long, but it doesn't matter. They have good manners and refresh quickly and completely on the stones very easily.

Re: No additional results so far..

#6

Hardness testing

david weaver

If you want to hardness test any of these blades after I'm done with the planing, I'd be glad to mail them to you. I have a guess on the hardness of these two. I think they're one or two C scale points apart. I'd guess 61 for my blade, maybe 62 and just above 62 for the hock - like 63.

It would be interesting to see how good my guesses are, but as you mentioned with the hand held tester types, I'm not going to go there. I think I can gauge hardness with a stone within a range at least as accurate as those hand testers.

Re: No additional results so far..

#7

Re: excellent

E Phillip Smith

The M4 will be interesting. If I remember correctly it was hardened to RC 63 - 64. It maybe the hardest iron that you test. Interesting to see if it chips at this hardness.

Re: No additional results so far..

#8

Re: excellent

david weaver

IIRC, it was designed or specified to retain toughness at high hardness, and probably won't be challenged by beech.

In maple, the O1 separates itself from the others in terms of surface quality, but longevity doesn't appear to be affected. A really bad contaminant, like the one I ran into that ruined all of the irons spares nothing, though. Seemingly clear maple does do bad things to the alloyed irons that beech doesn't - no clue why.

Subjectively, beech planes like cherry just a little harder. Both have a slightly more dry and dusty feeling in testing than does maple where the shavings seem more pliable and smooth, and they have great tensile strength (as learned by burning up my leaf vacuum cleaning them up, and then nearly killing a second one).