Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

Posts

Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

#1

Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

David Weaver

I executed a retest of these two irons in maple to finish that test and see of the results would match beech.

Maple is out from now on as a testing medium. The results are as follows for the two irons:

1,624 feet for V11

1,748 feet for 3V

Here's the problem. There were more hidden inclusions within the maple board, as well as other fungus or mineral markings. Both irons took some damage, though V11 took about 50-75% more in terms of the length of the edge affected.

In both cases, the deflection caused by inclusions creates a small wire edge (deflected metal). That can be bent back in place by resting the blade on jasper. Not all of the damage is gone, but the edge is about 80% - guessing - improved from the damage without any resharpening.

This makes it very difficult to rely on this test for much of anything, other than to say that given all of the factors involved, it suggests 3V and V11 are in a similar class.

As I think about it, the only resolution is to re-do this test in beech. I see that my lumber supplier is now selling 5/4 again on ebay, so I am going to order some so as not to work through all of the lumber I've saved for handles.

Getting cheap and trying to use the maple has become very costly in time.

Re: Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

#2

Go Fund Me Account

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You need to initiate a Go fund Me account for this research.

I can get lumber to a hour north east of Pittsburg if that opportunity is beneficial. Friend makes several trips a year. I have cut piles of beech and burned it in fire place. Sometimes I just cut and let it rot to make room for a valuable tree species. I could easily rive out some billets for handles next time.

Re: Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

#3

comparing maple and beech

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Kato and Kawai reported that wood density was the primary variable affecting blade wear (discounting species that include silica). I thought beech was less dense than maple. Not so according to the USDA data. They are essentially the same. The maple and beech results should be similar, and indeed they are.

Re: Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

#4

Re: comparing maple and beech

David Weaver

They're essentially the same, but maple doesn't decide when it will stop pulling a plane into the cut as neatly. On top of the messy bits in it that completely bomb the test.

Re: Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

#5

Re: Go Fund Me Account

David Weaver

No need for go fund me. The total cost of this experiment will probably not be more than $100 net, and it will answer a lot of things that I wanted to know myself.

Mike digity is still cutting beech and he seems to always market 5/4. Even if I went through every bit of 5/4 that I have (I won't), I'd still have about 30 board feet of 8/4 and another 50 or 60 16/4, and my planemaking has taken a back seat to guitar making.

Wiley and phil have both lent or donated stuff to the cause, and you've donated time to track down someone who can identify the chinese steel.

Re: Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

#6

Re: comparing maple and beech

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This sounds like lack of experience. There are numerous examples where one wood is more abusive to an edge than another that has higher density. What we call stringiness is one factor. In general a wood with a homogeneous texture is easier on an edge than similar density wood with an uneven texture. And a given species would have a range of hardness and a range of density.

Although beech and sugar maple overlap in these characteristics, sugar maple is generally harder on an edge.

Re: Test 3 - V11 vs. 3V in maple

#7

Re: comparing maple and beech

David Weaver

I don't know what a machine planer would do. Maple and beech seem to go a similar number of feet if something catastrophic doesn't occur, but the planing is somewhat miserable.

The blades all did well with quality on beech. On maple, all except the o1 and tsunesaburo showed damage or lines before getting to the inclusions. Not large, but enough to spoil a planed finish. If sharpening isn't fully completed. The lines would remain on the edge.

Purely on number of feet, though, they're similar. But I won't be working it on purpose with hand tools again.