Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Maple inclusions

Posts

Maple inclusions

#1

Maple inclusions

David Weaver

Heavily magnified




The one with the barky stuff looks similar to the one I planed through, except there was no barky stuff in that one. Just the shiny smooth hard stuff.

This is a approx 50x and 100x for the closest of the three pictures. At least that's what the scope claims.

I can't get any bevel side pictures that show anything useful with this scope, so the testing has moved on to detecting 3v and v11 head to head on maple.

I would sharpen both of these on coarser diamonds if I used them regularly, only doing the very last bit of polishing on 1 micron. The wire edge is really tough on 3v and I hope this test turns out the same as the first or I may question whether or not it was fully removed before the first test commenced.

Re: Maple inclusions

#2

Wire edges question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You have been doing a lot of fretting over wire edges in this work. I have come to trust that when you have a concern one should not dismiss it. On the other hand, your work has been influenced by razors where I suppose a wire edge leads to bleeding.

. Directions for sharpening my industrial sized planer knives call for grinding followed by dragging a piece of aluminum across the edges to break off the wire edge. Because edge life equals productivity with this sort of machine these directions would lead me to think the wire edge has little effect on edge life for this machine. In any case, the wire edge would soon come off by planing, probably quickly.

Here is the assumption I have been working under, apparently incorrect. If a bit of wire edge is left on a plane blade the first few feet of planing is going to remove it by wear or breakage. I have assumed no ill effects will occur from my leaving it on. (now truth be said I try to remove it, but do I need to if it is fine?)

Re: Maple inclusions

#3

Re: Wire edges question

Brian Holcombe

In my experience if the wire edge persists the cut is very lousy. I don’t consider an edge to be sharpened at that point, so if I managed to leave a wire edge I remove the blade and sharpen it again.

A machine planer is taking a much different kind of cut, and that too benefits from a fine edge.

Re: Maple inclusions

#4

Re: Wire edges question

Steve Elliott

I recently planed hundreds of lineal feet of teak using high speed steel knives and when I looked at the worn knives I was surprised that edges so blunt were still able to remove wood. The need for sharpness in a hand plane is orders of magnitude higher.

When sharpening 3V with one micron diamond I don't find the wire edge to be that persistent.

Re: Maple inclusions

#5

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

on 1 micron it thins and just floats away. The issue is David's upcoming experiment where he is going to try coarser final diamond refinement, 3 or 5 micron. This finish could leave a wire edge. Will it be important? How best to remove it, leather?

Re: Maple inclusions

#6

Re: Wire edges question

David Weaver

It's more of an elimination of a variable type thing. I noticed resharpening both V11 and 3V yesterday that they will have a tendency to retain the wire edge at the edge of the blade on the finest abrasive if you don't make sure you pay attention there (it's, of course, easy for me to view most of the center of the blade as important here because I am fencing the plane and keeping the cut in the center).

As brian says, the cut is a little more lousy. There is a feel issue here in that the LN 4 is nicer to use than the old record plane that I have, so the feel is a little lousy for the 3V no matter what. It's not unstable, it just feels different. The sweetness of V11 in the cut is also better, seemingly, anyway.

I would guess it could lead to the difference in the test between V11 and 3V, but that's a complete wild guess. I've done a second test in maple with V11 and 3V, but it was again partially (instead of completely) spoiled by inclusions. The results with damage show a toss up between 3V and V11 (3V slightly outlasted V11 by about 5%, but had much less edge damage from sneak inclusions in the maple).

There was no such wire edge issue on any of the other irons in the original test (I noticed the corners of the 3V iron still had a very small but stubborn burr on them when I was examining them to attempt to take a picture of the bevels).

I'll include that in the write up. Since the 3V iron is not commercially available, I'm not as concerned with it as I am some of the others. I would say the two are in an equal class if I had to bet at lloyds, except V11 is a little bit easier to sharpen.

After just taking another 3400 feet of shavings on maple, i'm not sure I want to re-test the two against each other on a cleaner wood, though I would do it on beech if both were commercially available. Maybe after the rest of the other variables are tested (angle, abrasive).

Re: Maple inclusions

#7

Two similar processes -

Jim Matthews

Machine surfacing of wood involves rotating cuts that (effectively) eject a "chip" that has near zero thickness at the beginning and tapers to near zero thickness at the end.

This is more similar to machining metal than making longer shavings.

This has meaningful impact on where heat is generated and dissipated (hence the setting of feed rate and cut depth).

To get an "apples to apples" comparison on blade life, hand planing and "wood surfacing" such as with the Marunaka Super Meca which lifts near continuous shavings.

If the ideal steel for the Marunaka is the same as the surveyed hand plane blades, then more broad conclusions might be reached.

Re: Maple inclusions

#8

Re: agree

David Weaver

The specific issue here is that the 1200 ezelap makes a wire edge. I didn't apparently remove it as completely at the corners of the iron, just on the 3V. The center as I recall just left without issue, so I am probably troubling over nothing. IF there was wire edge left on the portion of the iron that did the cutting, it would've shown up on the microscope as it's unlikely it would've been perfectly uniform.

I examined the center inch and a quarter or so of each iron after sharpening for the test, but I didn't examine the corners.

It may just be a minor annoyance.

Re: Maple inclusions

#9

LN vs, Record

Wiley Horne

David,

Do you have the Ln in bronze or iron? Is the Record sole iron or steel? If the Record were steel, it would have a different feel, and worse, than either bronze or iron. You could make an inference about this by waxing the soles of both the LN and Record planes, to see if the difference in feel goes away.

These differences should not affect test results, however, only feel. I do recall numerous beefs from years ago about the degree of concavity of the sole on the newly reissued Records (is yours vintage or one of the newer ones?).

Wiley

Re: Maple inclusions

#10

Re: LN vs, Record

David Weaver

Mine is vintage cast, and the ln is bronze. The bronze is sticky, but not like a mild steel infill, which is really sticky.

The adjustment on the ln is just better and everything is a bit tighter on it.

Re: Maple inclusions

#11

Re: Two similar processes -

david weaver

I'm curious about the super surfacer because it's the closest thing, but it has two advantages

1) materially unlimited power

2) downforce - it can continue to deliver a clean surface after clearance is gone

I don't know what the heat implications are with it - the knife is part of a big metal assembly, but no clue how that works while the cut is going on (how hot the edge gets before the heat sinks into the rest of the machine).

Bill has a paper to be translated, but I think their conclusion was that alloy steels like M2 lasted significantly longer before clearance exited, but only the carbon steel blades produced a surface as good as, well, the carbon steel blade.

Both O1 and the tsunesaburo in clean wood have planed every stroke with a surface acceptable to be finished. None of the other blades have, though the defects were very minimal in beech.

In both maple tests, 3V and V11 developed little lines (before mineral destruction, then the lines weren't so little). I don't think it's a matter of bits not breaking off - I think the little bits just break off of the stuff closer to carbon steel in...well, much littler bits. The surface brightness drops pretty quickly, but that's just the initial edge leaving, and then they settle in.

That brightness is higher and lasted slightly longer with 3V, but it's a curse for two reasons:

1) if you were actually going to use it on purpose - it's transient. You'd have to sharpen all the time

2) the brighter the surface, the harder it is to hide anything.

While a super wet and reflective surface on maple looks neat, uniform and slightly less bright is a lot more practical to work with.

I'd imagine the few people planing to finish by hand will end up going with something that's the most similar at the first and last stroke rather than what's the brightest on stroke 1. Not because they're searching for a less perfect surface, but because it's just easier to work that way.

Re: Maple inclusions

#12

Surfacing versus rotary planing

Jim Matthews

I suspect the rotary planer has two advantages - the rotating shaft that houses the knives can be built with standard lathes to very high tolerances, at low cost.

The effective chip size can allow for an acceptable surface, in wood that otherwise tears out - at high pass through rates.

The downsides (which disqualified machine planing in my little shop) are high noise levels and fine dust generation.

Surfacers avoid these pollutants, but probably can't handle gnarly species.

They also avoid compression of "softer" species that compromises finishing.

I had a $900 door loss due to poor finish quality - it came out tiger striped.

****

For hacks like me, the obvious solution is to trade time for convenience and plane (or scrape) by hand.