Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

Posts

Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#1

Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

david weaver

..and I will test the hock high carbon iron vs. my O1 iron. I don't really care what the results are, but he's correctly pointed out that the average reader of the results will have no idea what to expect from commercial O1 steel vs. mine, whether it's to assume that I have some magic touch, and my iron is probably better (I seriously doubt we'll see that), or that my iron is trash and the hock ends up between A2 and the other irons (I seriously doubt we'll see that).

He may also hardness test my O1 iron, which through my stone sense, I suspect is about 62 hardness. He can easily embarrass me with that if he finds that it's 64 or 60, because that's really an unacceptable difference vs. my sense based on stone feedback.

I don't mind getting embarrassed, though.

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#2

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

david weaver

Phil Smith has provided one of his dandy CPM M4 irons for me to have temporary custody of and work up against the V11 iron in a head to head test.

There's M4 (very wear resistant, low toughness) and particle M4 (just as wear resistant, much higher bar on the toughness chart).

We'll see. Not sure whether or not to look forward to testing, but pictures will be once every 100 rather than once every 50.

If my hunch is correct, I expect 2000-2500 feet of planing for anything where V11 gets 1500. If those two numbers actually occur, I would be very surprised. Some of these one off head to heads will be in clear cherry because I have a lot more of it. It does seem like getting 4000 shavings out of maple is too risky to try, and i can't imagine curtailing a test of these two irons due to contaminants at 1400 strokes, and then having to start over.

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#3

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I have a couple of M4 blades. After a hollow grind, they are straight forward to hone on Sigma stones.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#4

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

david weaver

Thanks, Derek. I look forward to testing it. Phil has done the heavy lifting preparing the iron in general (I still haven't looked at it, but I trust that will be the case) and as a bonus, provided a "good" cast plate for other testing, which I've never had. I can probably document the edge finish on wood vs. cast just for visual entertainment (I don't anticipate that the gentler wood effect or higher level of visual polish on wood would have any material durability effect).

I'll prep it to the same 35 degree bevel as the others (mostly 33 degrees and tiny 35 degree final polish bevel) and we'll see how it goes.

Hopefully uneventful. Testing is a pretty comfortable thing due to the stipulation (only until the plane materially comes out of the cut), but the potential for 4000 feet from two planes is "going long".

I expect the second test in maple (being held up by waiting for a hand scope to take pictures of the bevel side of the irons) may clear up (3V vs. V11) whether or not we should expect that those two are comparable or if V11 just lasts longer in good conditions in two different woods, and the CPM M4 is probably academically the longest expected edge life for the curiosity of anyone reading the report and wondering "home improvement" style what has the most horsepower.

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#5

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi David,

I own a CPM M4 blade given to me as a gift about 10 years ago. Fits my Stanley 102 "roughing" plane. A superb iron! Easy to hone with Arkansas stones. Holds an edge in the pernambuco and snakewood I use for making bows.

John

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#6

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

david weaver

Thanks for the attestation, John. A lot of the literature about powder metals discusses the improvements in their grindability (and thus presumably sharpenability) and then refers to their improved wear characteristics to go along with that.

I'm curious as to what the iron will do in the test, but also hoping i can manage to find a clear span of wood with no defects for a duration long enough to go with this and V11. 4000 feet of planing with two irons in heart beech seems possible.

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#7

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

E Phillip Smith

Is that a commercial iron or a custom iron? I don't know of anyone who makes commerical particle steel M4 irons.

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#8

The owners club

david weaver

of not only an M4 iron but a particle M4 iron would have to be pretty small!!

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#9

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4 *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Phillip,

This little blade was made in 2009 by Stephen Thomas, of Elmira, NY. This is the same Stephen Thomas who designed and made several of his "loopy infill" planes. The blade has a short, maybe 1-1/2" long CPM M4 tip that is butt welded to a mild (?) steel rest of the blade. The blade fits my 102 plane and is about 5" overall in length. I was told by Stephen that the CPM M4 material was very expensive, hence the welded approach. I'm pretty sure he told me that the blade was sent out and professionally heat treated. Cryogenically treated afterward, I can't remember.

I think he made some blades with CPM M4 for his loopy infill planes. Maybe someone else can remember...

John


Loopy Plane article

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#10

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

david weaver

Fortunately, the CPM M4 stock has come down, but I'd imagine the treatment and surface grinding is never going to be cheap.

I could track down CPM M4 stock from NJ steel baron (when they get it back in stock) for about $30 an iron, but it seems like something unlikely to be done well in the shop by eye, to say the least. No clue if you can cut and shape it by hand well when annealed, or if it has a problem with work hardening.

(I liked those loopy planes, but they're way outside of my tinkering budget).

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#11

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

E Phillip Smith

I talked to Bruce Norton last night about the work you are doing blade testing. Bruce machined both the 3V and M4 irons that you are testing. Both machine in the annealed state, the M4 is actually better to work with than the 3V. With 3V the blade does not get hot but the chips come off the milling machine hot and air harden, he said they make wicked metal splinters.

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#12

Re: Another iron provided - CPM M4

david weaver

For a guy like me who isn't afraid to make an ugly iron and do minimal work (as in, it's pitiful looking stuff that nobody would dare sell), I'm curious as to the ability to drill the stuff at low speed and then saw and file it.

Everything will harden with air - I found that out the hard way with the files that I made into rudimentary chisels recently. They won't harden into what you want, but if you don't make an effort to allow them to cool slowly, or do something like lay them on an anvil (which will suck the heat out of them), all of the sudden you can't shape them like you'd like to.

I'm a little gunshy about what might happen on the micro level.

The tinkering habit makes me want to buy stock for a single iron (about $35), heat it to bright yellow (completely ignoring the soak schedule and rules about gradual temperature increase) and give it an interrupted quench in oil and then finagle something with the can forge and a paint stripping gun to see if I can get it to a nice dark gray tempering temperature.

But I know that's likely to produce garbage. And if you can't drill and file it easily (figure 1/2 or 1/3rd of the metal removal rate with files being "easily"), then it's a bust all the way around.

Making an iron with lots of screwing around (foil wrapping, etc, all of that stuff) that doesn't perform better than the $7 chinese iron due to suboptimal process...that would also be dumb. I've done plenty of dumb things experimenting with tools, though.

The sound of the properties of M4 (its ability to be more fine seeming than 3V, and the attestation of quality of carbide dispersion in the PM version, leading to good sharpenability - and not to forget, its ability to work at high hardness and also be relatively immune to grinding heat after its made....all very tempting, even if it really means making the irons and sending them out for the rest.

Out of sharpening laziness, I'd probably go back to ward and O1 irons, though. I get off track from what I would normally do when I experiment with stuff like this test, because I'm doing something different than what I'd do day to day.

Last year or two years ago, I used the hardest purpleheart I've ever found to make a skew shooting infill plane. I sized the blank with one of my softest irons, and thanks to the cap iron presence, it wasn't as big of a failure as I thought it would be. I think I sharpened once while doing it, and once before.

(but the tinkering with stuff like PM M4 is still a draw. I have bar stock in another PM stainless that has a more household attainable tempering temperature and a very wide range for heat before quench).

Re: Bill has requested..(a more standard O1)

#13

Side comment about sharpness and PM...

david weaver

i noticed that (pardon for not looking up the name or reading back through the posts) the maker of the loopy plane mentioned that M4 PM (unless it was someone else) seemed to take greater sharpness than other more standard steels, and presumably since the initial sharpness of everything is very transient, that's probably more related to sharpness in the first long stretch of work.

I was surprised in the first test that with V11, the initial wear cycle actually left a brighter surface, and subjective sharpness in the cut was better than my carbon steel irons. That may be due to slower wear, as well as the strange habits of the tsunesaburo iron to lose chunks. O1 and even the tsunesaburo retained great uniformity, but less brightness. The brightness of the V11 iron left later in the cycle, but it eventually went, too. The first couple of hundred shavings, it was so reflective off of the wood that to plane a surface with no defects at that level would've been almost impossible.

But i'm surprised to see the sharpness comment and would've written it off without this cycling of irons that I was doing through the same test piece. I wouldn't have believed it and may not have noticed it without moving irons through the plane every 200 feet.

I didn't notice it with 3V, but test 2 will see if that remains. 3V was also in an older record plane, so it was hard to really judge how it felt against others with no differentiating variables.