Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Graph of David's data

Posts

Re: Graph of David's data

#2

Re: Graph of David's data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This data is so full of holes it could not hold holy water.

If an A2 iron, for example, is not sharp enough to give a good surface when freshly sharpened, its effective blade life is zero. And a fine surface is not just a goal, it is a symptom of how well the iron is cutting. The effort to use such a poor iron will be greater for its whole "life". This is important for someone who uses planes in a more than casual way.

And if a plane iron lasts twice as long, but then also takes twice as long to sharpen, there is no gain, and there could be more time spent pushing a plane that does not work very well.

The biggest problem with the whole experiment is that it is so far removed from how we actually use planes. The whole sharpening regimen was designed to accommodate the more raunchy steels, a system that David admits he would never use in practical circumstances. It is like getting a special set of teeth just so you can eat some tough food.

In the real world we are free to sharpen at the most opportune time, considering many factors: how long to sharpen, the performance of the plane, what kind of work we are doing, how tired we are. We do not continue to some degenerate condition of the iron.

Re: Graph of David's data

#3

As someone who is trained in parsing..

david weaver

...data and making conclusions from it, I get a little bit of an itch seeing a definitive chart made from one iteration.

I'd put two stars on that one. The 3V used a different plane. I suspect it may be the equal of V11, but I performed this test and I'll take the results as they are.

Making a second test and redoing it would just be a form of bias, and there's no commercial interest in 3V at this point. I don't have any reason to believe it's performance was substantially subpar but would've preferred it in the same plane with the same cap iron, etc.

I'd hate to plane three thousand more feet to see the same thing happen again - i would eventually work through my plane handle wood if I keep that up, and that would suck.

Star 2 is I don't really know what the chinese iron is (is it precisely M2? Don't know). If you have the ability to analyze one (if it's important), I'm still going to mail one to you. I have other chinese irons. If they don't look like this type (brazed on bit), they're all over the board. The ones that are brazed on to some kind of other steel are pretty much identical, from the muji planes to these irons with a different brand over a decade, they've all been the same. I'm guessing the bits all come from the same place, and they may all be made by woodwell and painted different colors)

Re: Graph of David's data

#4

In this iteration...

david weaver

..perhaps beech is more kind, but none of the irons showed any visible surface defects until the LN iron started to around 800 feet, and the chinese showed very small defects that nobody would probably notice.

This data is solid aside from claims that could be made about 3V deserving a shot in the same plane.

It's my opinion, as a user, that I would use the O1 iron for a finish surface for two reasons, though. It's been reliable in keeping uniformity in my hands, and it's easier to get a complete sharpening on it than the others. Lack of any defects in all uses means less to do sharpening, and in the event that one would misjudge how big of a wire edge to raise with it, the edge of the iron left behind is always uniform and still strong.

As far as how these irons are used, I'd imagine at this point, there are more people with prescriptive jig-based sharpening methods who just use irons like this (until they stop cutting for them) than there are people like us who don't.

If someone told me they watched david charlesworth's video and they take 7 minutes to sharpen, I'd point them to the V11 over the A2 based on this and suggest that they might learn a lot by planing with a stanley iron, a washita, no guide and a plain leather strop. Most people are looking to learn little from my experience, though.

The maple study will provide a little bit more on surface quality vs. duration. The beech just wasn't difficult enough to move the needle as far as surface quality goes - all of them did fine and there was absolutely no variation in the wood. All planed with the grain, all beech heart, one area of knots in the board at the start, but the small knots in beech that create a grain reversing area don't really feel any different with the cap iron set.

That said, the shaving lifters who just want to spread out sharpening intervals and who are already using wood that's been jointed and planed by a machine, so it's got a clean surface, they'll find this data pretty accurate.

The path for others (looking to do more than raise a shaving) is paved by learning to sharpen more quickly and with more understanding of what's going on. And learning to use the cap iron so that very little of the work has to be done with wispy shavings where this kind of idealized edge durability becomes more noticeable.

Re: Graph of David's data

#5

Why the data is relevant to my work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

David deserves encouragement and praise, but he is more apt to get it on the Main Message Board where the audience for these results will find it useful.

For the last 20 years or more there has always been some major piece of furniture in my shop under construction. I expect this situation to continue for I have a seemingly endless list of requests and a lot of lumber. Your opinions of how I plane, what I plane, the quality of the result is irrelevant until you provide me with some evidence that what you do would improve what I do.

As it stands what I do meets my needs and they are to remove small increments of wood in a controlled fashion without tear-out. The resulting surface is irrelevant so long as any torn grain is easily sanded out and in most cases even torn grain will not show on the surface I am planing. Push plane, shaving forms, success. Exactly what David tested.

Lets take an simple example. I need to replace a worn out blade in a Stanley #2 (which I use in tasks most would use a block plane). What do I buy? Because this is a new purchase, I have the option of buying anything that fits. What criteria do I use to make the purchase? Price, availability, performance which in my case is exactly what David measured- how many feet will the edge last. I power grind and refine with diamonds. M2 is no harder for me to sharpen than a Stanley blade. Hence, ease of sharpening irrelevant.

A blade that lasted 10% longer and cost 5% more would be a sound economic decision for a new purchase. A PMV11 costs 15% more and lasts twice as long (error bars +/- 20%) as an O1. For my work David has shown me that I should buy the PMV11 when the choice is to buy this or that. Should I replace the O1 in my #4 with an A2? No. Should I replace the O1 in my shoulder plane with a PMV11. Probably not, I don't plane that much with it. Should I fit a 3V that has been sitting on a shelf into some plane I use often. Definitely. You see, I have found Davis's data already beneficial.

You will never have any motivation or need to change what you do, and few would have any desire to do what you do, what ever that is. You don't have a horse in this race that involves change.

Re: Graph of David's data

#6

Error bars

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The graphing program I used did not enable me to put estimated error bars on the graph. This addition would have bee useful. Maybe someone more capable at graphing can provide a better graph.

Re: Graph of David's data

#7

Re: As someone who is trained in parsing..

Charlie

David, you look like a null hypothesis. A math joke, nothing personal.

Re: Graph of David's data

#8

Re: Why the data is relevant to my work

Warren in Lancaster, PA

How long does it take to sharpen a plane iron after you beat the crap out of it?

Re: Graph of David's data

#9

Re: Why the data is relevant to my work

Charlie

Maybe a couple of minutes. Tops. It's not something to make a habit out of, but it's not the end of the world either.

Re: Graph of David's data

#10

Exactly

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, it takes extra time to sharpen because you waited so long, which cancels out savings from not sharpening earlier. And in the meantime, you have a plane which is not performing very well.

Re: Graph of David's data

#11

Re: Exactly

Charlie

Can't argue with that.

Re: Graph of David's data

#12

How long does it take a strawman to hone an iron?


Re: Graph of David's data

#13

Re: How long does it take a strawman to hone an ir

david weaver

simple steel, grinder and stones, about 5 minutes if the nick is something serious.

I completely get what bill is saying. The lens is far different that warren's perspective. When all you're doing is trimming joints and fitting things, or prepping for sanding, the cared for edge that warren prefers (I like it, too) isn't really the target.

I don't think it would save time for bill, either, who to my understanding has a grinder.

The straw scenario of a person who uses one of the $10 chinese irons I showed in this test could freehand diamond sharpen the iron and grind it with no ill effect, and it would hold its edge longer than any plain carbon steel in almost any case. the primary problem people have with these steels is handling the wire edge without going to submicron abrasives. I'm going to cover that separately in the same paper as the wear test, but first, will test some scenarios (waiting for diamonds) that are equivalent more or less to using a washita to maintain carbon steel.