Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Edge progression pictures by type

Posts

Edge progression pictures by type

#1

Edge progression pictures by type

David Weaver

Each set of pictures is as sharpened by type. You'll notice I left a few more stray scratches in O1, but realize that these are at the 150x optical level. They are insignificant with O1 because they do not result in faults as you'll see from picture 2. I don't think some of the other irons tolerate stray scratches to the edge as well.

Also, I'm not advertising my iron making skills, so if I cost the iron 10 shavings, I'm not worried. The uniformity of the edge in picture one suggests no foul. This is the last iron I sharpened after the absurd 1 hour and 45 minute session of back and forth sharpening and viewing on the scope after hitting the inclusion on maple, so it got treated like that. It still lasted better relative to A2 in this test, and the tsune, anyway.

In short, if you want to complain about my sharpening of my own iron, put a trash can over your head before you start complaining. All of these irons (O1) included, are so far past the hair test at the beginning of this that it's silly. Hair just silently wipes off of your arm. Nothing jumps or evades a single pass of any of these irons.

Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#2

3V pictures

David Weaver

3v 0:



3v 50:



3v 100:



3v 150:



3v 200:



3v 250:



3v 300:



3v 340:


Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#3

Tsunesaburo Blue Steel Pictures

David Weaver

Tsune 0:



Tsune 50:



Tsune 100:



Tsune 150:



tsune 195:


Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#4

V11 pictures

David Weaver

v11 0:



v11 50:



v11 100:



v11 200:



v11 250:



v11 300:



v11 350:



v11 392:


Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#5

O1 Pictures

David Weaver

o1 0:



o1 50:



o1 100:



01 150:



o1 195:


Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#6

LN A2 pictures

David Weaver

ln 0:



ln 50:



ln 100:



ln 150:



ln 200:



ln 245:


Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#7

Chinese HSS Blade Pictures

David Weaver

hss 0:



hss50:



hss 100:



hss 150:



hss 200:



hss 250:



hss 300:



hss 339:


Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#8

How oil affects these pictures

David Weaver

On some of the sharpened irons, there is a whole train of lines that look like they go together like a scratch pattern, but they're not there away from the bevel in subsequent pictures.

On the second O1 picture, you might be sure that you see abrasions perpendicular to the edge. Most of what I thought was careless edge prep on the O1 picture is oil, as are the lines running perpendicular to the edge.

If you wipe an iron completely twice, you will see oil like the first picture. If you wipe an edge twice, use it, and then pull the iron back across your shirt after 200 feet of planing, some oil will still be pulled across the edge after that. The solution to this is to pull just the edge lightly in a direction parallel to the iron width. I guess there was still a tiny bit of oil left.

From experience, if you get lazy and wipe your first iron on your shorts when it's got some WD 40 on it, you will not be able to wipe the same spot on your shorts for the rest of the night without ruining the microscope pictures.

The same is true for dust on the other side of the bevel. If you plane and you don't wipe off any straggler wood dust from the bevel, some will sit on the edge making the entire edge look jagged.

Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#9

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The pictures are the flat (top) side of the blade, right? After some use the pictures show an altered band next to the edge and past this band what appears to be a surface unaltered. Does the edge of this band correspond to the position of the cap iron, that is, the portion of unaltered appearance was covered by the cap iron?

Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#10

Re: Question

david weaver

I believe the cap iron was probably about three times as far away as the wear on one of the irons.

Because of the limited focal depth of the microscope, I cannot install the cap and get a clear picture of it and the iron, but I can install it and you can see where it is because it's a dark blur due to its reflecting light in a different direction.

That's something that should be included in the study.

For scale of these pictures, I put a piece of wire in a photo. The wire is .007" (it's the bristle from a grill brush - I could've just used a .009" guitar string, but I'd have needed to measure that, anyway.

I took a picture of the cap set but didn't upload it yet. The typical set for this test is .008-.01", so slightly further from the edge than the width of this wire.

I figure there might be some disagreement from folks about using the cap iron, but this is the smartest way to use these irons in this plane (and the record plane).

I intend to publish all of these details, too, so that anyone else who wants to do a similar test can do it and they can post their results. The photos are necessary (to me), not because they're all inclusive, but they really hold your feet to the fire in terms of practicing care of these irons in sharpening and handling.

It's not a small feat to get the irons to this point of sharpness so that there are no deep scratches at the edge (anything deep erodes and makes a line that is not the fault of the iron) and then handle all of the irons without bumping one into anything on the edge. Or to put it more accurately, it's a bit of a pain in the ass. I devised a good way to stack them (staggered) so that I could carry them around.

Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#11

Re: Question

Kees

Nice pics. Hour scope is a lot better then mine or brent beech’s scope. The wear bevel on the flat face of the blade appears quickly and the doesn’t change much in length. But you can see very nicely in the deepness of this wear backbevel in the O1 and the blue steel blade. Nice! It is believed that it gives a bit of self sharpening to the edge because it removes some of the edge rounding.

The bevelside of the blade has the real wearbevel. This one is convex and grows in length almost linearly with distance planed. Another factor is edge wear. It creeps backwards from its original position. You can put a scratch on the bevel with a carbide scribe to meassure from the scratch to the edge and you will see that it recedes. Just a pitty that the dirt from planing makes the scratch harder to see after a while.

I have never quite gotten a good correlation between the lenght of the bevel wear bevel and actual planning behaviour. That is because a handplane has more trouble with the convexity of this wear bevel and that one is very hard to meassure. But that convexity is what makes the blade not wanting to be drawn into the wood anymore. Something very well demonstrated in Steve Elliot’s papers.

I think you mostly look at the smoothness of the very edge. That s mostly a factor for wood surface quality I think and not so much weather the blade stays in the cut or not. Unless it gets very bad of course.

Re: Edge progression pictures by type

#12

Re: Question

david weaver

that is precisely what I came up with. It would be nice to have an SEM type picture and be able to see the bevel from all sides, but kato and kawai already show some pictures in their literature that confirm that the shape of the bevel can be all over the place depending on the steel used, the wood type, the grain orientation of the wood being planed.

Since it's much harder to get a good visual picture of the bottom bevel (the length of the top one will never increase much because the cap iron is turning the shaving up. Instead, it will cup just like the K&K pictures, and if it's smooth enough, display its curvature.

It's a given to me that the bottom bevel will round and scratches will run back up from the edge if they form, but if they are significant, they will show up on the very edge. I learned from sharpening and selling older razors and sharpening stones that I can rely on seeing a smooth edge and little thickness to that smooth edge by how long the light is in focus. If the edge is smooth and thin, the shave is good. Translating over to planes, if the edge is thin at the start, and smooth, the iron will be very sharp. if it can manage to wear, change geometry, but maintain a very nice smooth edge - it may not be the most durable (the length/weight planed addresses that), but maintaining uniformity is a very good indicator of what will maintain quality in use.

That works down to the irons that maintain uniformity also end up being the easiest to resharpen because complete sharpening maintains uniformity, and incomplete unintentional incomplete sharpening still rethins the bevel most of the way and resets most of the wear off of the bottom bevel.

Nicks from defects tend to leave people coming up short. Especially when they're paired with really difficult steels.

(I realize that most people are just going to want to see what planed the most feet, though. And that's OK).