Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Question to LV

Posts

Question to LV

#1

Question to LV

david weaver

LV mentioned on the PM-V11 site that they also tested irons in wood, even though the results appear to be from MDF accelerated testing (presumably due to the size of the group involved in the formal test).

If Rob is around and gazing at any of this, do my pictures from wood look like your pictures? They may not in shape due to the use of the cap iron, and others' usual focus of the bevel side (I have a cheap hand held scope and may take pictures of the final bevel side, but you can't tell as much as people think you can looking at them because the wear bevel may be longer but less steep on some type of steels vs. others. The quality and uniformity of the edge, in my experience, is a better guide.

I would be surprised if some of the tests in canada-land weren't done with maple given it's ...well, it's the flag!

Re: Question to LV

#2

Another question for LV

david weaver

Would you consider making and marketing a 3V iron? It's obviously harder to sharpen, but doing well so far. I'd assume that market price would probably need to be +50% over whatever V11 is if its workability after hardening is an indicator of its workability before it.

Can't blame a guy for asking. It's not something I'd expect LN to do.

I'll be doing a test of its durability when the finishing media isn't diamonds, anyway, as long as wiley doesn't yank the string on it and pull it home.

Re: Question to LV

#3

Re: Another question for LV

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, years ago, in the build up to deciding on a steel for chisels and plane blades, I was one of several who field tested a number of steel types (this process is a later stage of development). This testing was completed blind. I had no idea which steel was which. Later I discovered that in the bunch were 3V and M4 which is how I came to have these blades for the BU planes). Clearly the results supported the final choice of V11. The point is that consideration was indeed given. I imagine that it would be hard to justify marking blades in several different steels when only a very tiny number of potential buyers would be involved.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question to LV

#4

working 3V

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Where were you when we were making tools of 3V? 3V is sold in the annealed state and in this state it files and saws easily.....I mean really easily. You can mow through bar stock just like the softest steel you ever worked. This property is what enabled us to make tools with just a hack saw and file. But don't get it hot when working it or the teeth will come off the saw....NOT an exaggeration, they did come off the saw.

Re: Question to LV

#5

Re: working 3V

David Weaver

I vaguely recall when you were making tools, but I was probably too cheap to do it at the time. I remember you saying that if you worked it slow and cool, it worked easily.

The heat treatment if not done in volume is what poses an issue (due to cost). That may also been one of the things that kept me from making an iron at the time.