Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Thoughts after 600 feet

Posts

Thoughts after 600 feet

#1

Thoughts after 600 feet

david weaver

The O1 iron is about to give up. The thinner irons bed OK but not perfectly on the LN plane, so they will be going back to the stanley plane to finish the test. (HSS, tsunesaburo and the O1 iron). Any less than perfect bedding seems to get exposed with an iron that runs out or clearance.

The tsunesaburo has a feel like it is also running out of clearance, but it's ahead of the O1 some. No clue if the gouges on the top of the wear bevel adversely affect the edge, too (not they can reach over, but is the same thing occurring right at the edge?)

The loss of quality suddenly in the LN edge is strange, but I saw this before with A2 - they can continue to cut for a little bit even after the quality goes on a steep decline. Terrible surface, though. One that you could still scrape and sand, but someone not paying attention may leave a flaw on a surface if they didn't do significant work.

3V feels unchanged. The V11 looks like it has a drastic hollow, but you wouldn't notice it planing, and I think the HSS is fine (it doesn't bed as well in the LN plane. All three of them have lost some brightness, but after having minor surface quality issues at first, none of shown the sudden decline (yet) that the A2 has.

So, what's wrong with the bedding in the LN plane? The top part of the iron doesn't quite bed solidly on the top of the frog, but it is bedding on something. Whether that's the dog sticking up from the adjuster or the lateral adjustment wheel at the end of the lateral adjuster, I don't know. I thought it might be the cap iron screw, but it's not as far as I can tell.

I have two choices - move those thin irons back to the stanley plane now that they have some wear, or figure out what the problem is with the LN and address it. The lever cap screw sticking out of the frog will need some trimming if the irons are able to bed down the whole way.

As this test has been run, the bedding of the iron down at the mouth has been solid and planing has been smooth. There is no oscillation or noise. The issue has only shown up as the O1 iron has almost run out of clearance. It doesn't functionally plane in the LN plane and only just does in the stanley. I would be extremely surprised if it completed another 50 shavings.

Shaving thickness at this point in determining the failure point is critical. Shavings vary while you're planing, at least slightly. I've been weighing them and if a plane gets slightly behind in shaving cumulative weight, I set the shaving slightly thicker. Everything plane has traveled the same number of feet, and all are within 10% of total shaving weight planed. The lighter irons in lighter planes tend to cause me to take a thinner shaving as you can feel more with them, so a thinner shaving feels the same as a slightly thicker one in the 5 1/2 or the LN smoother. Without weighing shavings, the total wood volume planed over the same distance would've varied.

Since failure is largely determined by shaving thickness (how much difference, I don't know), it's important that the failure point due to loss of clearance is done with care to set the cap iron just the same and the shaving thickness at failure just the same.

I don't think the slight variation in thicknesses to make up for weight has really amounted to much variation. Just a hunch.

A useful test later for curiosity would be to plane shavings until the plane stops picking up 1 1/2 thousandths, chart that, then plane until it stops picking up 2 1/2, then 3 1/2 up to 5 thousandths or so. IT really doesn't matter, but I've always assumed that pushing shaving thickness when planing accomplishes several goals (as long as the shaving doesn't result in poor quality or lack of control), one of them being that you're less sensitive to clearance. I should be able to document that.

Now that the O1 iron is close to failing, when it (presumably) comes out of the test first, I am going to see how many feet it will plane in cherry. It and one of the other irons will then come back to maple after being sharpened by a washita stone, and at bill's request, the next one that comes out will be sharpened with 5 micron diamond (something that literally could be a one step sharpening process, like a washita) to see how much feet planed is affected by the lower quality starting edge.

We are lucky so far to have results that seem to either match prior experience (I wasn't hoping to see the LN iron falling apart, but I've seen it before in the same wood from the same brand of iron - and the LN was the best in the last test I had, so there's not a quality issue that I'm aware of, more a characteristic behavior).

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#2

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your work can't be faulted for not being thorough.

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#3

Absolutely agree.  Last night I

Wiley Horne

replicated (sorta) David’s final hone of 1u diamond on cherry, except I used 1/2u on birch, cause that’s what I had. It is a super polish.

The photos and commentary are calling out to be organized into a report when Dvid finally gets all the rabbits chased down. Big thanks for David’s hard and exacting work.

Wiley

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#4

Re: final report

david weaver

I'm storing all of this stuff in sequence. The posting of the interim stuff has two purposes:

1) anyone who sees something that doesn't make sense that I missed can call it out.

2) morbid curiosity, or maybe not morbid - it's more fun to communicate this as it goes than it is to work hours in isolation.

It will be summarized into something more readable, though. It would be a sin to create a pile of information and then not try to make it more useful to the audience than a string of hard to find disorganized posts.

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#5

I'm trying to figure out.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....a suitable way to reward him for these useful and interesting results. Maybe a session of shoulder message therapy?

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#6

Articles Department

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Maybe someone with influence can get the report into the WoodCentral Articles.

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#7

Re: I'm trying to figure out.....

david weaver

Participation and input in the results to keep me from making unnecessary errors is plenty. If this community manages to extract anything more out of Wiley, I think he'll be practically insolvent!

(I'm sure that's not true, but it seems like if Wiley extracts a mosquito bite of blood, he gives 10 pints in return).

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#8

Re: Articles Department

david weaver

It may not be good for a site that needs sponsors. i don't want to saddle them with that.

You mentioned (I think here, perhaps in email) that the fact that all of these irons worked through 400 feet of hard maple with little issue really shouldn't be lost -regardless of what the conclusions are, people shouldn't allow themselves to get sucked into an errant idea that some of the irons in the test are good and some are not.

They're all pretty good. I intentionally didn't choose any junk irons (in my experience, the irons that come with primus planes would not fare well in this test)....well, Mine might be junk aside from the uniformity.

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#9

Re: I'm trying to figure out.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Maybe a session of shoulder message therapy?

This not is a lot of work compared to the planing David has done routinely in the past. It is not a lot for someone who knows how to plane efficiently.

Lee Valley cites their "1.6 miles of planing" for testing various alloys as if it is a lot, and all this work is supposed to justify their keeping PM vii secret. David has done maybe three quarters of a mile in less than a week of spare time, and he has had to fiddle with microscope, camera and computer, and switching out plane irons periodically. And found time to make 90 posts on this forum.

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#10

Re: I'm trying to figure out.....

David Weaver

It is dandy easy planning compared to what we'd normally do, and I do learn a little bit each time I do something like this. I don't often plane to total clearance loss, but it's interesting on the 01 iron how quickly the iron went to cutting poorly and with scope and surface confirmation that it's not related to edge quality.

I have some thoughts to put in the final document based on how much of a fallacy it is for a beginner to believe they can just lean on a plane a little longer and get a good surface.

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#11

Re: I'm trying to figure out.....

Wiley Horne

I recall Warren saying recently that, if you sharpen frequently (before it becomes apparent you need to), blade maintenance becomes a regular part of the work rhythm. Just melds in. As opposed to blade maintenance becoming a project in itself. This is additional to the benefits of surface quality.

Wiley

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#12

Re: I'm trying to figure out.....

Charlie

Find a steel that tires out at about the same rate as you do. Take a break, hone, back to work. I think what David is ultimately saying is this: if the surface looks different between the steels you're using then the craftsman is doing something wrong.

All steels reasonably used for woodworking tools should result in very close to the same surface quality the vast majority of time, with some differences at the margins.

In other words, nobody in the world could tell the difference, to the point of being able to identify, a surface planed with 01 and one planed with A2, PMV-11, or whatever. They may be able to say, "well, the craftsman let his blade go too long..." but I doubt even that.

And none of this accounts for the scraping and/or abrasives that may have come afterwards, or should come afterwards. All woodworking is not a broad, flat surface, and there is the matter of applying a finish to the completed project.

If I had a boatload of gnarly tropicals to plane, I'd just get a few high speed steel cutters like these or source some old Stanley and Record ones which they used to make for the Australian and New Zealand markets. No big deal.

https://www.kirschen.de/en/Special_Plane-Irons_p23.html?page=1

Re: Thoughts after 600 feet

#13

Re: I'm trying to figure out.....

David Weaver

Sort of except there is a visible difference in the surface left by the tsunesaburo iron and the O1 iron vs. the other four. That is, you can see lines in the work from the last four.

For the few people who are actually going to finish a surface straight after planing, the four that suffered edge imperfections will not satisfy.

We are accommodating the desire of those edges to chip more easily by going all the way to 35 degrees for the final bevel, but they will still develop defects fairly quickly.

That said, if you are almost anyone else who doesn't attempt to finish straight off of the plane and you scrape or scrape and sand, you're not likely to care about the marks as they're cosmetic but usually not big enough to feel with a fingernail.

My comments about the irons lasting 400 feet isn't to suggest the surface would look uniform without any visible marks (it only does for the two mentioned above), just that all plane smoothly without much perceived difference in the "pull" into the cut. Because there is glare off of the surface in raking light, it is extremely hard to take a picture of the lines with anything that has auto focus. I'll have to figure out how to get a picture of that.

When this is all said and done, I'll probably go back to using the O1 iron that I made and tested.

One other important point is that this is all only in the context of a smoother. Jack and try planes work with a shaving thickness deep enough that an easy to refresh iron seems nicer to use than one that lasts super long.