Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

David, thank you.

Posts

David, thank you.

#1

David, thank you.

Brian Holcombe

David, thanks for the interesting topic and tons of research you have provided, it is very thought provoking.

The tsunesaburo blue iron is one of my favorites currently, I have one in my LN 7 plane and enjoy using it. Certainly it is long wearing but also provides a high quality surface.

As an aside, I resharpen with a high frequency and encourage my students to do the same, I think it's important to knock the plane apart regularly and be in the habit of sharpening it pretty constantly. That part of working entirely by hand has really stuck with me and I remains a permanent part of my working habits.

Sanding is not a very common task in my workshop, outside of chair making with modern chairs (which require it when built at higher volumes in my opinion). I very rarely sand before finishing and typically only do so on large surfaces which will have a durable surface finish applied.

Planing remains an an exceptionally fast way to make a crisp finish with sharp details.

Re: David, thank you.

#2

Re: David, thank you.

david weaver

Fast frequent sharpening....it'd be wonderful if someone could do a study on productivity around that, but I'm sure it comes out in favor of more frequent sharpening. It's a good habit for students to learn.

I think whatever the results of this iron test are, the typical heavy plane user is always going to come to using more plain steel irons. Discussing edge uniformity and predictable quality is a step up vs. just the number of feet planed, but there's a lot more in the tank that would be difficult to convey.

there have been a couple of questions about preventing the tiny lines that A2 and other steels leave behind, if it's a matter of poor prep, etc. As I recall, you saw the same things with the LN A2 irons, is that true? I've probably had 5 different makes of A2 irons (LN, IBC, LV, shepherd, hock...maybe I'm missing something else, too), and the LN have been the best of the bunch as far as edge uniformity and life - but they still do things that I can't tolerate on a smoother. At the standard that you have to work (which is well beyond mine), I definitely couldn't tolerate it.

Do your students do dimensioning work? It's a lot more forgiving of a softer iron (maybe even preferable for jack and trying since clearance and minimal wear isn't quite as critical) - one that's easier to complete the sharpening process on, and then learn to use a plane for more than tissue shavings in prep for the fleeting moment that's proper smoothing. (at least fleeting when the heavier prep is done right).

Re: David, thank you.

#3

Re: David, thank you.

Brian Holcombe

Every once in a while I get a chance to sharpen up and use an A2 iron since I dont have them anymore. It's typically a repeat of the same experience I've had previously.

I can get good results out of A2 but I certainly don't prefer it for how it wears with a ragged and micro-chippy edge. It also produces a very strong burr which is hard to remove without stropping. Stropping was deleted from my normal routine some time ago so retaining it for A2 is counter productive.

I teach students to joint by hand (face and edge) and occasionally I'll show them how to dimension. Most often I gear the program around what they have to work with and most people have a planer available to them, so we prep for the planer by hand.