Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

blade edge life and practical planing

Posts

blade edge life and practical planing

#1

blade edge life and practical planing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Somewhere in the discussions of edge life it gets asked, where is the need? The question comes from someone attracted to planing a show surface, on what, is not revealed. I faced two planing tasks today and avoided a third.



The reveal between these doors still needs to be refined and the intersections of the stiles and rails needs to be leveled in some cases. Both tasks I accomplish with a hand plane. The rails and stiles have been machine planed to thickness before assembly. I will sand them with 120 and 180 grit before applying a finish that has yet to be decided. The carving presents a staining problem I have not thought about solving yet. If the plane picks up a shaving and doesn't cause tear-out I'm satisfied. I'll sand the door faces with 120/180 and the planed edge of the door with 180- done. This task is not a finishing planing task nor does it seem necessary to approach it as one. Therefore, the most important attribute of the blade is does it remove wood and whether I need to sharpen it before I'm done. Yes/no?



Next I faced removing the home made(thick) veneer overhang from the edges of these shelves for the corner cupboard. These are not show edges. They will be finished but not stained. They won't even be faced; the plywood substrate edge will show. I just need the overhang to go away as quickly as possible. Planing seemed to be the most reliable way to accomplish the goal; the jointer was risky as the shelf size of the substrate was already fit. Therefore, the most important attribute of the blade is does it remove wood and whether I need to sharpen it before I'm done. Yes/no?

Finally, I need to smooth the sawn surface of the veneered shelves. Could be hand plane job for the skilled planer with time on their hands. I used junk for the least obvious side of the shelves and grain is going every which way. Too risky in my hands to even rough hand plane. This is thick veneer. I am going to see if I can send it through the thickness planer. Whether I can or not an air driven ROS will be employed to take the shelves to 180 then hand sand 180 out of habit and finish, no stain. Even if I hand planed these shelves, I would have no need to plane them to the standards David speaks of, nor have any need of a blade capable of delivering this standard. I would just want wood to go away and not have tear-out.

I have had a plane on the bench for most of this build , taking a shaving off here and there with none of it benefiting from a show surface of high refinement. If I had hand planed the stiles to some high degree I am sure they would have acquired scuffs along the way. How do you fix this highly refined surface if the scuff is next to the base molding, if not by sanding. Can anyone scrape to the refinement David speaks of?

For what I do I do not see an opportunity to need, or benefit from, the degree of refinement David asks of his plane blades. Which, it would seem, to ask if one of the steels that failed the refined surface metric was significantly better in the will it plane wood metric. Somewhat better is not worth the purchase of something different than what I have. Lacking data I believe, and waiting on David's data that I will believe, I have stuck with carbon steel. I think I here opportunity knocking.

Re: blade edge life and practical planing

#2

If the green chinese iron fares well..

david weaver

..i found a second one in my drawer. I'm going to send it to you when I'm done. I think it's a great budget iron for a shaving lifter, but the test could still prove me wrong. It's also not particularly hard to sharpen (I have been using oilstones on it, just as I would with V11 or A2 - but I can sharpen anything on oilstones at this point, not to maximum achieved level, but good enough to use - just as the 3V showed up).

When i found a gray version the other day on aliexpress, I ordered two and then ordered two more green ones. The princely sum total for the order with shipping was something like $42 for the four irons.

I have been using the green one for a little bit. I don't do as much furniture building as you do, but if I am planing a surface (like the top of a spruce telecaster) and a mark occurs, I decide first if it's worth threatening the surface (you're right, hangar rash is the biggest surface threat that a lot of us face. When I do build furniture-like things, I often wonder how nobody ever talks about it and assume that I am just ham handed). If the object being planed is a shelf, the answer is usually no unless the mark is significant. Damage occurs before assembly for me usually - handling the parts and having one fall over or some such thing. If that's the case, I'll re-plane the area.

If assembly is done, I will try to scrape slowly with a dull scraper with the grain and burnish the area. if there is minor variation, I'll live with it. I also apply shellac and wax or shellac and crosslinked acrylic spray finish to just about everything I make, so my standard isn't like oil rubbed sheer finish.

Re: blade edge life and practical planing

#3

Discernment

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The most important aspect of the art of sharpening is discernment. That is to say having a feel for how well the tool is cutting at all times. A worker who is not observant will never know how good their sharpening technique is, what subtle adjustments to technique will improve it, or what steps are a waste of time. You cannot learn this stuff by sitting in an armchair and speculating.

Discernment also helps us learn what techniques are abusive to the tool and shorten its useful life. And it tells us when it is time to sharpen the tool. Using the tool beyond this time results in poor tool performance and more work to bring the tool to a high state of utility. And quite frankly, a tool that is repeatedly abused by neglecting sharpening is very difficult to bring to high function. You want the tool to be in a tight range of sharpness for dependability and repeatability.

Working in this manner requires high concentration, but the rewards are speed and efficiency and quality work.

Re: blade edge life and practical planing

#4

Re: Discernment

Steve Voigt

Moving on from the topic of planes and blades for a moment:

Warren's post above is the sort of thing most beginners would see and their eyes would just glaze over. They want concrete specifics, like "should I buy the low angle jack or a dedicated shooting plane?" And I get that, I'm sure I was the same way when I started, thankfully before the advent of forums like this one.

But really, Warren's post is the whole ballgame. It's a manual, in one paragraph, for how to be a good craftsman. If you have that discernment, and an ability to form hypotheses and follow through on them, and a decent pair of hands, everything else ought to fall into place.

Re: blade edge life and practical planing

#5

Re: notice something and improve something

david weaver

Almost all of us come to this hobby from something else we already do well.

It makes it hard for someone to not want to have that same level of success when they start woodworking, and ego and impatience get in the way.

I like to think some of my interpretation of these results is driven by what I expect to see - just as you'll be able to tell my surprise if I see something different than what i expect.

It's easy to go into the shop and say "I'm too important to have time to learn that" or "nobody will care what it does for results, because they won't notice", but it's far smarter to go into the shop each time you're working an expect to both do and learn. The idea of being told what to buy and told by someone else why it's superior is OK as a starting point, but we can observe things, discuss them, and sharpen our own ability to branch off and either improve our own abilities or figure something out.

Some of it isn't easy to communicate. I still can't communicate that well why everyone who does nearly all hand work migrates to carbon steel irons. I could put out a whole bunch of bullet points, but someone has to feel them or see them or experience them after an hour of planing and then do that 10 times.

I try to observe something new or think about something new (even if I'm just building something in the shop) each time I'm in it, and if I'm in for more than a very short period, allow myself the room to make a mistake on something to learn.

There is no real need to run this durability test, except I feel like the community is owed a comparison of the V11 iron after Brent Beach made a decent display of just about everything else we use on a regular basis. Where the results come out, I don't really care.

But even in this, I learn or relearn something. when I did my first test of these irons - it's dullard work - i fence the plane with my fingers and the top of my left hand index finger gets smooth and burnished. It starts to feel after about 20 shavings like the bronze smoother is getting noticeably duller. The sole grips the surface of the work a little bit more, and that causes the same behavior as a dull iron in terms of smoothness. Add a little bit of wax and continue on and it's as if it's a different plane. I will remember that in the middle of planing something, it's often tempting to keep going and not wax the sole of the plane for what could be 100 strokes. I see how much effort I'm wasting by not pausing to do that.

This is now the second time that I realize what people often perceive as a dulling plane is probably them leaning on a plane that's got more friction due to loss of wax. And the precisely made premium planes have so much contact area on the wood that they really have some significant grip once the wax starts to go. Not sure if the bronze is worse than steel because I don't have a steel version to compare, but it does seem fairly grippy.