Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

Posts

Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#1

Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

David Weaver

I can see the wear bevel on every iron, even 3V.

The A2 from LN and the V11 seem about even in terms of wear and visible wear bevel. I wouldn't bet one against the other at lloyds, but maybe as the feet add up, the V11 will separate itself to back up its claims.

I deliberately chose LN's A2, not because I was hoping for an outcome, but because it's been the best I've used anywhere. Not to mention, it's the only one I have at this point (I could buy another make if I had to). Subjectively, if someone came to me and said they wanted an A2 iron, I'd recommend the LN.

I hoped that my O1 iron would hang in feet planed. So far, it shows more wear than the A2 or V11, but more surface uniformity. I think it will come out of the cut earlier than either A2 or V11, though. Maybe my perception of how much I like uniformity of the surface and how I (and anyone else working mostly by hand) have increased shaving thickness to offset wear gave me a bit too rosy of an expectation for O1 against the others.

If it lasts two thirds as long, it's still the one I'd choose because of its tendency to release the wire edge more easily. I like to hone with one stone or one and a wire edge chaser. I think (I'm guessing, and will test) that the carbon steels' tendency toward surface dulling but not losing uniformity may make them a better choice if you're not going to go all out with the 1 micron sharpening routine stuff.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#2

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Planing at .0025 until the plane has trouble staying with the cut is not something I ever do. I think I do most work at the upper end of sharp.

I have been to 8 or 10 hand tool events. I have seen Japanese planes giving a surface like what I am used to with vintage irons, but all of the A2 planes, even ones freshly sharpened, they all fall short of quality. I don't really know if this is sharpening technique or a quality of the steel.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#3

Note on O-1

Wiley Horne

David,

Am much enjoying poring over your observations. Do your documentary photos jibe with your qualitative look and feel impressions? Seems to me they do.

I looked up ‘O-1’ composition, and it turns out there is no definitive O-1. There are numerous standards (about 30), and a like number of makers’ formulas. They vary some as to Cr and W (tungsten) percentages, within the range of 0.4 to 0.7%. But the biggest difference seems to be in vanadium presence and amount. Some of the standards do not include V, and others specify up to 0.3%.

Starrett quotes 0.2%; Uddeholm 0.12%, Hudson quotes 0 (zero), Ellwood 0.3%. And so on. Quite a few show no V.

Well, this may be absurd nitpicking. But I mention this because vanadium punches above its weight—it has an effect on abrasive resistance outsize to its weight in the formula.

Are you using Starrett?

Wiley

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#4

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

David Weaver

I don't do that, either, Warren. I generally sharpen as soon as I notice that I'm doing anything to influence the plane. I've learned through this test and a prior one that sometimes that's in error (and all that's needed is wax), but it's not an error with any real penalty.

The reason I'm doing this test until the plane stops lifting a cut on its own (which I'll document as cutting a length of shaving with only the rear hand on the plane) is so that it's less subjective.

The visual pictures are just too iffy to draw conclusions from, so all I can do is comment about surface quality and see when the plane no longer wants to take a shaving.

Pictures of surfaces would be nice, but the surfaces are glossy and the phone instantly recognizes them as such and focuses on them and eliminates the glossy look.

If someone seems my results and has an issue with them, they can go recreate them if it's something as simple as the wear limit being defined as the plane no longer staying in the cut .

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#5

Re: Note on O-1

David Weaver

Yes, starrett. The only two O1 steels I've used are starrett and precision presco. Both are good in my experience. I'm wary of unbranded stuff just because the standard isn't that tight - like you say.

W1 is even worse. Most manufacturers make something in a narrow range, but the standard itself is very loose, so I bought 1095 bar stock instead only to see that the knife makers say generally finding the right manufacturer to get a tight spec on W1 is better. In their words, it's usually made cleaner and to a higher standard than 1095. (The range I saw on one page was 0.6-1.3% carbon(!!)).

Not sure how much 0.2% adds, but the 2.75% in 3V must add a LOT the way it sharpens.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#6

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I should have been more direct in asking a question: If I see A2 giving poor results at a hand tool event, do you think it is likely the steel or the sharpening technique?

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#7

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

David Weaver

It could be some of both, but I don't think it's possible in an ideal scenario for it to match carbon steel as far as surfaces go.

I have two carbon steel-ish irons in this test. One in O1, and one in blue steel (Which is similar to O1). They both are leaving surfaces that dull as they dull, but the uniformity is still excellent.

A2 can have spans off of a sharpening where it may go a few hundred feet without untoward marks, but I wouldn't say that's a majority of the time. If you look at a surface that it planed, you can almost always see the path of where the iron went. Despite those clear spans, you can't rely on it. You can make it better, but it will drive a surface gazer nuts leaving little tiny lines at some point. Where you get to really having enough of it is when you sharpen to try to get a fresh surface, and then you take a few strokes and a couple of tiny lines show up again and you start questioning whether something could be embedded in the plane sole coming out, or maybe on your hands or whatever.

To my knowledge, only plain carbon steels give continuous work without marks, just a slight dulling of the surface brightness as they lose sharpness and clearance.

After I started this, Bill noted that K&K found the same thing with a planing machine that imitates hand planing (not the super surfacer). Only the white steel produced a top grade surface- everything else had a noticeably lower quality. In that was M2 and D2 steels. I don't think A2 was included.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#8

Re: Note on O-1

David Weaver

One side comment...

...I think one of the things I was hoping to find out is that well done O1 could almost hang with A2 and V11 type stuff.

I think I'm finding out that's not the case. Of course, there's no guarantee my O1 irons are better or as good as any others out there.

I'm such a fan of edge uniformity that I thought it might really help an iron reach up and perform better than it should. I think that the pictures of both O1 and blue steel are delivering on edge uniformity, but my O1 iron subjectively has the brightest wear bevel to the naked eye. I think I may be responsible for making the "worst" iron in the test as far as duration.

I didn't expect all of the tiny little pore looking things on the blue steel iron, and the second 50 shavings appear to have worn some of them away.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#9

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

“Only the white steel produced a top grade surface- everything else had a noticeably lower quality. In that was M2 and D2 steels.”

That would imply that the alloy steels have a different wear mode than the straight high-carbon. I wonder if blue steel, which contains tungsten, was also inferior to white steel in the KK study. For example, perhaps the white steel wears evenly, while perhaps the alloy steel loses the ferrite matrix preferentially over the alloy carbides, forming a sort of “exposed aggregate” edge. Just guessing obviously, but KK make an interesting observation.

One other variable we haven’t discussed is grain size. The Japanese irons that Warren commented on would have gone through multiple heats with hot work in between to reduce grain size. Vermuelen devotes a chapter of his metallurgy book to how this happens at the molecular level. Was the KK white steel iron smithed?

Wiley

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#10

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

david weaver

I think the iron was white steel and there wasn't a blue steel study (but we'll find out after translation). Most of the steels listed, Bill wrote names beside or I could go find a couple of citations (I haven't seen the whole study, but the steels are labeled in a diagram). They're things like D2, M2 and M42. As far as whether or not the white steel was laminated, it almost certainly must've been unless they oil hardened it. I don't know, though.

I don't know if I can say enough smart to describe failure modes, because I'm still not sure. I thought maybe I could prove that uniformity was just as important as abrasion resistance within a relative range both for surface (of course) but also for shaving lifting.

Bill had a good animal analogy about different types of planers and what they're looking for, separating people who pick a plane up fairly seldom to trim and fit things vs. those of us who use one a lot. It separates us into shaving lifters and surface gazers, more or less. I'm a surface gazer (I want the surface to be similar all the time, no matter what the level of sharpness) where as a shaving lifter is someone who just wants to lift a shaving. The latter type of person uses a plane less but also has less desire to sharpen. Whereas a surface gazer is resigned to sharpening whenever the plane needs it for feel and quality, a shaving lifter won't do it (and may dread it) until forced. The latter won't care about quality and will search for the longest lasting iron that lifts a shaving for the most number of lifts.

I'm getting off track a little bit. The pictures on the K&K study (drawings in what I saw) of the wear profiles showed substantially more wear in volume on the white steel blades, but also a slightly different shape.

I think the wear occurs slightly differently, but I also think the mechanism is the same. Particles are pulled or abraded off the wood, not sure how much it's that or it's impact, but the more interesting things I was hoping to find - that toughness could be a contributor to uniformity and thus longevity - it probably is, but I don't think it will overcome alloy based on how the irons feel so far.

I think the blue steel iron is reasonably representative of white steel in wear, but I can't prove that. This iron exhibits behavior like O1, but how they compare to 1095 is something for a future test (I haven't made a good 1095 iron yet, but that's on the schedule as something to try. white steel is out for me unless hitachi starts making two layer rikizai available...I was able to find three layer at one point and have some, but the lamination on the bottom makes it worthless for making planes).

Long winded way of saying I think that we're not challenging toughness that much with planing in ideal conditions unless there is a defect from sharpening, but the forging definitely benefits chisels where there is more failure from impact.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#11

toughness correlation, etc.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The white steel, in the publication labeled "Kigami", was the toughest steel tested*****edit correction no value for toughness was tabulated for Kigami. Don't know why. It was D2 that was the highest of the tabulated values)****** with M2 a close second. Toughness correlated strongly with the smoothness of the blade edge after use, and hence, surface quality I suppose. Wear resistance correlated strongly with how soon the blade no longer "dug" into the wood to lift a shaving(loss of clearance). There are a bunch of pictures in this paper of edges taken with SEM. Without the translation I don't know what I am looking at.

For the record, it was "grazers", those that settle in and plane surfaces, and "browsers" those that mosey through making a piece of furniture hitting a lick here and there to fit something or remove a machine mark. If you don't know the eating habits of deer and cows this analogy may be bewildering. Think nibble as you spend the day doing something else vs eat and rest.

What you grazers often fail to realize is that browsers don't get continuous feedback of the plane dulling when planing 400 ' in 20 increments over the course of a month. Dull appears as a surprise when the plane suddenly doesn't pick up a shaving that needs to be picked up to move on to the next step that could be fitting a mortise or whatever. Minimizing surprises is important for browsers. Ideally I would like to complete a piece of furniture before sharpening and then sharpen everything I used to be ready for the next project.

I finish with finishes that build on the surface so surface quality off the plane is irrelevant, as it will be to most. A properly sanded surface looks identical to one hand planed, unless I am staining, in which case the planed surface looks terrible.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#12

A compliment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In this work you have not lost sight of the needs and interests of people who use a plane for the purpose of removing small controlled increments of wood (fitting) with little regard for surface luster. The results are useful to all kinds of planers. A+

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#13

Kigami

david weaver

Kigami is listed on the yasuki steel page as Yellow.

It's the same as white with a tiny bit more tolerance for silicon, but not enough to consider it as any different (I don't think there's a person alive who could tell the difference between white and yellow in a plane iron).

Aogami - blue

Shirogami - white

Not sure when yasuki mill (now owned by or a sub-brand of hitachi?) made each, but the tolerance for silicon in blue and white is the same.

Blue is (not surprisingly) listed as water or oil hardening. Same spec as white with appx. 0.4% chromium and 1.75% tungsten added.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#14

Re: surface gazers vs shaving lifters

Steve Voigt

Dave, I'm enjoying reading this stuff a lot, though I'll admit I'm probably missing a bunch because there's a ton here. I'm having a little trouble finding a bottom line.

The distinction you made between "surface gazers" and "shaving lifters" is the crux of the issue for me. I imagine the latter want to know "how long will the iron cut?"

What I'm interested in is how long an iron can go before it stops producing a finish ready (or nearly finish ready) surface.

So I guess my questions are:

* Do all irons tested here produce a finish-ready surface?

* Which ones can produce a finish-ready surface for the longest time? Which ones poop out the fastest?

My assumption here is that on the question of merely lifting a shaving, the plain high carbon irons will give up earlier than the alloyed steels, but that on the question of a finish-ready surface, the plain high carbon will be competitive. Is this true?

Apologies if you've already answered these questions and I'm just not finding it.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#15

Re: Kigami

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Kigami was translated as "cutlery steel" hardness 64. I was mistaken, there was no toughness value tabulated for the Kigami used, just hardness. Unsure why just this entry is missing from tables. Bevel angle was 30 degrees with 10 degrees initial clearance. As best I can tell the source of all the metals was Hitachi Metals.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#16

Not by chance...

david weaver

..that you haven't found a real defined statement about those things...I've rattled off bits and pieces, but I will summarize the findings of all of this in a more organized way either on google docs or something else that can be published all at once with far fewer words of pondering and far more statements of observations.

I suspect what's occurring is exactly what you said, sort of:

* by 400 feet, none of the alloyed irons give a finish ready surface if that means not being able to see the direction a plane traveled in raking light. That's a demanding standard, but it's what a finish planer would look for. In years past, I thought if the defects were small enough, I could remove them with a stiff wrist and some smoother shavings (burnishing), but it's not so.

* both irons closer to carbon steel are dulling in surface quality at 400 feet, but not showing any prominent lines. the other irons are retaining more surface brightness but adding little lines of defects. Do the carbon steel irons hide defects? I don't know. Not to the level that the lines occur on the others.

Plainly put, the A2 iron maintained good uniformity to 200 feet. Somewhere between 200 and 400, it started to show little defects that would annoy a surface planer. The chinese HSS iron had tiny defects in the first 200 feet and they seem to have stayed the same. The V11 iron and 3V show marginally larger lines, but I wouldn't say any of the four are materially different other than the perhaps lucky first 200 feet for the LN iron.

There are no lines at this point from any iron that would catch a fingernail, but they're visible long before that - anything that catches a fingernail is probably something that can be seen on the edge by the naked eye.

I think two divergent points will occur with this testing - those planing to finish will conclude what they've already found - that eventually, the alloyed irons will annoy them enough that they'll look elsewhere. The folks who are looking to trim doors and sand the finish, and who never sharpen often enough to be forced to become efficient and fast at it (like 90 seconds for a plane fast, and you can't stand nicks and defects when your objective is only to remove wear) - those folks will migrate back to the more highly alloyed irons.

For the matter of your planes (and mine, when i search for older irons or choose steel to make irons), if someone asks you why you don't put whiz bang CPM Rex super nova extra gravity vanadium tungsten atom splitter and rejoiner in your planes, the answer is probably pretty simple - you cannot finish straight off of them, and they don't facilitate elegant sharpening methods with simple abrasives.

I'm sure someone will contend that there is a CPM right around the corner that doesn't leave lines and lasts 6 times as long as carbon steel, but I just haven't seen it. Still haven't. Brian found the same and switched away from A2 as far as I know. Warren had proper observations and I like to think I'm as good at sharpening things as anyone will be, and I came to test these things based on my own observations. If I can't sharpen the alloy steel irons in a practical way such that they don't shed little bits, I don't think anyone can. I'm always willing to be proven wrong.

I mentioned statins in a prior post - the actual adjusted total mortality experience of people on and off of statins in a "man on the street" type level (as in, a person who doesn't have special exotic risk factors) found that most people don't benefit from statins even if they have elevated numbers....until they get to a certain age. There's something in that statin study to piss off everyone who wants to say "look, I win, you were wrong". I think my results will probably create a similar scenario when all is said and done. The shaving lifters will conclude "most feet, your iron is stupid", and the surface gazers will say "can't finish with it during most of those feet, your iron is stupid".

My motivation is similar to the UK study that actually looked at mortality with statin use and risk class - instead of inferring that some lesser test means bigger things, they measured the bigger things.

I'm just intent on measuring two of the bigger things - both separate goals.

Fortune telling, unless I do something to the edges, I think the carbon steel irons will come out of the cut before they ever produce lines on a surface. I don't think based on resistance at this point (just guessing) and now with what bill has told me that K&K saw, that they'll stay in the cut as long. I'd love to be wrong and find that the O1 iron and the blue steel iron last practically as long as any of the more highly alloyed irons so that I could tell everyone that they're wasting their time with things hard to sharpen, but it probably won't happen.

(the older I get, the less ability I have to give simple answers. I never had that ability in the first place, but it's getting worse).

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#17

Re: toughness correlation, etc.

Steve Voigt

Bill, I have never understood this line of reasoning, though I've seen you present it numerous times. Even if you only take three shavings, how can you not see and hear whether the plane is cutting properly? And if you see it's not working, why wouldn't you pop the iron out and sharpen it?

I do plenty of planing obviously, but it's a regular occurence in my shop, as in yours, that I only need to take a dozen shavings off something before moving on to the next thing. I don't see how this has any bearing on my regard for surface quality. If I can see in the first 2-3 shavings (really after the first shaving a lot of the time) that it's not working, I have plenty of time to fix the problem.

Further, I don't understand the claim that surface quality is irrelevant because you're going to be sanding anyway. A badly planed surface means you're going to have to do a lot of sanding, perhaps starting with 120 grit and an ROS, and progressing to hand sanding with finer grits. A nicely planed surface means you can do a quick hand-sand with fine grit and be done with it. Given that the planing will take the same length of time whether it's done well or poorly, why not just do it well?

To sum up, I agree there is a distinction between "grazers and browsers," or as Dave said between "surface gazers and shaving lifters." But I don't think it has anything to do with how much time is spent with a plane. That's just rationalization. Once one has learned how to produce a decent surface, it doesn't matter whether you you spend two minutes or two hours with a plane.

Why do I care? Because there's an implicit suggestion in your claims, which is that that only the hardcore hand tool users can learn to produce excellent surfaces with a plane, while the casual hobbyist must be resigned to using a plane as a mere fitting instrument, without regard to surface quality, and i don't think that's true at all. Just my $.02.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#18

hitachi = yasuki

david weaver

I think at one point, the two may have been separate companies, but my understanding is that they're the same now. Yasuki, *i think* was the original company who came up with the white/yellow/blue blade steels.

Interesting that there's no toughness spec. 64 would be a good hardness for it, though. It's almost the same as white 2, and white 2 does very well for uniform failure at that hardness. It does well at lower hardness, but it would wear faster, and at higher hardness, it gets brittle and can be unforgiving and temperamental (I guess that's true of all carbon steels).

Whatever the case may be, kigami results being referred to as white steel for the average bystandard now is pretty safe. Given the ever so slightly tighter constraint for silicon, I wouldn't be surprised to find that shirogami (white) is just a newer and tighter spec (or to find that kigami was the first of this type of steel to be commercially made).

They're all hard for the average person to find in any stock that you can make things from (aside from little skinny knife blade blanks).

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#19

Re: surface defects...

david weaver

..in the case of this test, I'm not finding anything that wouldn't sand off with 400 grit paper in terms of the defects described.

The populace hates what I say when any other quality defects are mentioned - they're all preventable. When an iron sustains a serious nick (like hitting a stray particle on a surface or something that shouldn't be there), the defects might be big enough that you'd have to sand twice with 400 grit.

There are some tiny pin knots and other grain reversals from time to time in the board I'm planing, so I can see whether or not defects that would create more work occur, but the quality of the finish other than the tiny lines is similar. if anything, the alloyed irons are retaining brightness longer, but it's too early to tell if that'll be the case for more than the second set of shavings.

I think a shaving lifter could probably rely on very light scraping and sanding to remove defects. The cap is going to prevent any threat to more subsequent work than that all the way to dull for all of the irons (at least i hope that's the case).

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#20

Re: a more to the point answer

david weaver

I'm going to be smart and do a shorter response line by line because that's what people are probably looking for. They can compare it to my type-a-licious giant rambling answer in the other response:

Dave, I'm enjoying reading this stuff a lot, though I'll admit I'm probably missing a bunch because there's a ton here. I'm having a little trouble finding a bottom line.

The distinction you made between "surface gazers" and "shaving lifters" is the crux of the issue for me. I imagine the latter want to know "how long will the iron cut?"

What I'm interested in is how long an iron can go before it stops producing a finish ready (or nearly finish ready) surface.

So I guess my questions are:

* Do all irons tested here produce a finish-ready surface? A2 did for a short period of time, but not long. Other alloyed irons, no. Both carbon steel irons produce a finish ready surface after 400 feet. Defects are not tearout or anything substantial, just tiny witness lines

* Which ones can produce a finish-ready surface for the longest time? Which ones poop out the fastest?

the carbon steel irons are the only safe bet for surface ready finishes unless someone wants to do light scraping and sanding (all of the irons do that well. So the answer is less about what does the finish ready the longest and more about whether an iron does it at all - only the carbon steel types show an ability to do it predictably

My assumption here is that on the question of merely lifting a shaving, the plain high carbon irons will give up earlier than the alloyed steels, but that on the question of a finish-ready surface, the plain high carbon will be competitive. Is this true? Well see once the plane finally comes out of the cut in terms of longest. the high carbon irons have already won the surface quality contest and now that their edges are worn and rounded a little bit, I doubt they'll do anything other than lose some surface brightness. It'll be interesting to see if the other irons cease to increase the appearance of lines once the little bits at the edge stop coming off - which may have occurred by now. Or more specifically, once they're supported by a more robust rounded wear angle, will they maintain quality

Apologies if you've already answered these questions and I'm just not finding it.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#21

Thanks, Bill

david weaver

The two prong test, and the test of actual planing rather than creating a machine to do it and accelerating it in something else (that's not aimed at any prior tests in particular - it's been done by almost everyone - using various toughness tests or machines to eliminate human error or subjective interpretations) is...

...well, an attempt to see what happens when we're actually planing wood.

Lots of tests with machines, with different materials, etc, but most leave us wondering "will this hold up if someone is actually planing in wood at the same speed someone would use a hand plane".

I don't want to wonder those things, and I doubt other people will want to.

The fact that the results seem to be diverging into two groups (plain steel vs. alloy steels) and that the surface quality question is well established now (and the wear feels subjectively like it's favoring alloy irons, even if they have more defects)....that'll still allow people to continue to argue about why their preference is better. I know people value being able to argue, and I'd hate to take that away from them!

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#22

clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Most of the planed surfaces I deal with on a piece of furniture prior to finishing are generated by an industrial sized thickness planer. When it is freshly tuned up I can start with 120 and an air driven ROS. Otherwise its start at 100. A hand plane working properly for me is will the blade pick up a shaving and no tear-out.

David's metrics for a properly planed surface are something more refined than 400 grit paper. For the finishing schedules I use I rarely sand beyond 180 grit. Clearly our desires for surface off a hand plane are different.

I don't know what I would do with a surface as refined as David's goal. There is no way I can preserve it through the building process. I can't handle a 150 pound piece of furniture during the build (typical chest of drawers) without it getting some scuffs and the like. There are places where these scuffs could not be replaned in the finished piece. I always find myself going over the piece with 180 on a sanding block just before staining and then it is forge ahead without hesitation until a protective finish is in place.

For the record I have carbon steel blades in the planes I use, except in the shooting plane where the PMV11 blade gets dull about as fast as a carbon steel blade as best I can tell. The only 3V blades I ever made were for a Krenov style plane that I now never use. So I am sitting on the sidelines waiting to see if something better ever shows up for sale and watching David's work with great interest. Occasionally look at my jointer whose particle steel M2 blades get sharpened about every 5 years and wonder, what if.......

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#23

Alloy and finishable surface

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

“A2 did for a short period of time, but not long. Other alloyed irons, no. Both carbon steel irons produce a finish ready surface after 400 feet. Defects are not tearout or anything substantial, just tiny witness lines ”

The main observation above is that the alloy blades (other than LN A2) never produced the quality surface. Never did. Left traces of themselves from the first stroke. Which means that the alloy edges did not fail in use. There was something about the edge quality after sharpening, but before use.

So perhaps it is the tenacity of the alloy wire edge, even the teeny tiny wire edge left by the diamond-on-cherry strop. Wire edge behavior is a primary characteristic you mentioned from the start.

Wiley

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#24

Re: Alloy and finishable surface

david weaver

Actually, the wire edge and whether or not it's there is a good point.

On this test, I run a clean finger over the end of the blade to remove any last little bits that are there, and then I have to wipe the iron briskly on my shirt (so it's getting a very light stropping), put it under the scope, and then often do it again. It's not getting done with significant pressure, but I think the wire edge is gone.

It is extremely noticeable if significant work is done on the 1200 stone, even though that stone is fine cutting, but careful work on the 1 micron diamond weakens it and makes 99% of it depart. if there is any remaining amount, you can actually see it, but you must take the iron and flash the edge across some light source (toward a window is fine), the same as you would have to do to see wear on an edge.

I have avoided taking a picture of the typical defects (I think they are rather the product of particles coming out, and not the product of the wire edge - though leaving bits of wire edge on wouldn't have helped) for the most part because I don't want people to get the sense that they represent the bulk of the edge. I will, though, take pictures of a couple of the edges to show what minor defects look like. I don't think the phone camera will be willing to cooperate on wood, but I may be able to create them on a flat surface and get such an amount of wood filling the viewable area that the camera can't try to ignore them. Phone cameras seem to be software-made to immediately focus away from surfaces with a shine. I can see the shiny surface for only a split second and then the software focuses on something else in the background before the picture is taken.

It may be worthwhile to take one of the irons after this is done and make it flaw free again and then actually see what stroke the small lines show up on. I check the edges before starting with the microscope scrolling across the entire edge to ensure there are no deep scratches left anywhere (those will become edge failure even if they don't leave a mark right away) and to ensure that there are no deflections or bent looking edges (which probably aren't bent, but are some lack of uniformity).

So, it's not a wire edge issue. The other thing that makes me think it's not is that no matter what, even after green chrome ox, I have never been able to get A2 to keep uniformity over a significant period of edge life. Same with the (probably) M2 irons that come in mujingfang tools. Both the LN and the muji blades are such fine pieces of gear that it's a shame that they can't be forced to act exactly like carbon steel.

Other far less refined irons have included the ones that come in primus planes (if tracks were breadcrumbs, nobody would ever get lost using one of those) and even worse, the hard to sharpen irons that came with shepherd planes - those released larger defects than typical, and early.

What I can do is get a picture of the wire edge as it's left after a 1 micron diamond without alternating or stopping. It'll be an oily picture, but you'll be able to see it.

The little things that I do with a clear finger and then with a clean shirt are maybe things the average new user wouldn't perceive or know to do anything about, but selling sharpened razors has made me very wary of what's on the edge and how gentle you have to be to get rid of it. The bar is higher there because even O1 has too much of a wire edge holding tendency to make a good razor. A good razor must tolerate linen and leather, and after holding the wire edge, O1 fails to stand up to the process that's designed to remove it and keep it away.

Which may beg the question, if I can just get the wire edge off with a clean finger and a shirt, why is it such a big deal? the answer, I think, is two fold:

1) the tsune iron just makes it unavailable to even worry about very early on (that's nice, and I think more about hardness than alloy)

2) what happens when we step down from 1 micron diamonds to something less refined. then, at that point, all irons have a wire edge to deal with, and it could be tenacious. Certain things like slurried japanese stones do well to limit the formation of a wire edge, but that takes user touch to understand. It's not practical for me to convey.

Re: Observations on wear after 400 feet planed

#25

Re: Alloy and finishable surface

Wiley Horne

David,

“It may be worthwhile to take one of the irons after this is done and make it flaw free again and then actually see what stroke the small lines show up on.”

I would much appreciate your doing this, if you can work it in. Use the 3V. If flaws show up instantly, like on the first stroke, then it’s something the matter with the edge before it is used, or something about the sole of the plane being used, like burrs from filing the mouth or somesuch.

But if the flaws show up only after some passes, then that would reject the plane sole and persistent-wire-edge theory, and argue for particles spalling off the edge

or the ‘exposed aggregate’ theory.

Thanks for your good work and your patience with armchair analysts.

Wiley